Unmuted Podcast | Episode #93
Why Great Executive Hires Fail at Startups

Guest: Jamie Savage – Founder & CEO, The Leadership Agency
Host: Jeff Waldman – Founder of ScaleHR & SocialHRCamp

Episode Overview

You've hired an accomplished executive with an impressive résumé, experience at recognizable companies, and a proven track record.

So why aren't they succeeding at your startup?

In this episode of Unmuted, Jeff Waldman sits down with Jamie Savage, Founder and CEO of The Leadership Agency, to explore why even exceptional executive hires can struggle in high-growth startups.

The problem often isn't the person. It's the expectations, timing, and fit between what the organization needs and what the executive was hired to deliver.

Drawing on more than 20 years of recruitment experience, Jamie shares why founders need to think beyond impressive résumés and compensation packages. They need to understand their company's current stage, anticipate what's coming next, and clearly define what success looks like over the next 12–24 months.

Together, they discuss the importance of building leadership talent pipelines, being transparent about business challenges, and recognizing how AI is changing the skills organizations expect from senior executives.

And despite all the technology transforming recruitment, Jamie makes a compelling case for why executive hiring must remain fundamentally human.

We Explore:

  • Why accomplished executives sometimes struggle in startup environments
  • How misaligned expectations between founders and executives can derail a hire
  • Why founders must understand their strengths and what responsibilities to delegate
  • The importance of hiring for the company's stage of growth and future needs
  • Why impressive résumés and recognizable company names don't guarantee success
  • How proactive talent pipelines can improve executive hiring decisions
  • Why transparency about growth, product-market fit, churn, and business challenges matters
  • How AI is changing expectations for startup leadership
  • Why chemistry, connection, and honesty remain essential in executive recruitment

Practical Advice for Startup Founders:

  1. Define success before hiring. Identify what the business needs to accomplish over the next 12-24 months and the leadership capabilities required.
  2. Align expectations. Be clear about responsibilities, resources, compensation, and what both the founder and executive expect from the relationship.
  3. Hire for your stage of growth. A leader who excels at scaling an established organization may not be the right fit for a startup still finding product-market fit.
  4. Build relationships before you need them. Maintain a leadership talent pipeline rather than recruiting only when a position becomes vacant.
  5. Be transparent. Give candidates an accurate picture of the company's opportunities, challenges, and direction.

Timestamps:

00:27 – Introducing Jamie Savage and the episode topic
02:36 – Jamie's work with high-growth, VC-backed companies
04:30 – Why executive hires at startups can fail
05:07 – Misaligned expectations and defining the role
08:48 – Founder strengths, hiring priorities, and delegation
11:06 – Why impressive résumés don't guarantee startup fit
14:34 – Hiring for the company's stage and future growth
18:21 – How AI is changing expectations for startup leaders
21:14 – AI across products and internal operations
22:59 – Why executive recruitment must remain human

About Jamie Savage

Jamie Savage is the Founder and CEO of The Leadership Agency, an award-winning executive search firm helping high-growth companies hire exceptional leaders.

With more than 20 years of recruitment experience, Jamie has partnered with organizations including Shopify, Geotab, Waabi, and 1-800-GOT-JUNK?.

Recognized by Forbes as one of Canada's top executive recruiting firms for two consecutive years, The Leadership Agency has established itself within the startup and technology ecosystem.

Jamie was also named a 2026 Top Female Entrepreneur by FoundersBeta and previously served as Board Chair and Interim CEO of Startup Canada.

She is a passionate entrepreneur, speaker, and advocate for building stronger startup leadership teams.

About The Leadership Agency

The Leadership Agency is an executive search firm specializing in helping startups, scaleups, and high-growth organizations recruit exceptional leadership talent.

The firm partners with founders and executive teams to identify leaders who align with their business needs, growth stage, and long-term ambitions.

Website: https://leadershipagency.com

Key Takeaway

Great executive hiring isn't about finding the most impressive person on paper. It's about finding the right leader for where your business is today and where it needs to go next.

As AI reshapes leadership expectations, organizations must continue investing in the human elements of recruitment: honest conversations, clear expectations, meaningful relationships, and mutual trust.

About ScaleHR

Unmuted is powered by ScaleHR (https://goscalehr.com/), helping emerging HR, Recruitment, and Work Tech companies accelerate brand awareness and lead generation through Catalyst, our community-driven omnichannel marketing solution.

Unmuted is also part of the WRKdefined podcast network, making it easy to listen or watch on your preferred platform, including Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and more.

Explore Unmuted: https://goscalehr.com/theunmutedpodcast
Find Unmuted on WRKdefined: https://wrkdefined.com/podcast/unmuted

#Podcast #ExecutiveRecruitment #StartupLeadership #TalentAcquisition #HRTech #Leadership #Startups #FutureOfWork

Powered by the WRKdefined Podcast Network. 

[00:00:00] Welcome to the Unmuted Podcast. My name is Jeff. I am the host of the podcast where we talk about all things HR, talent, HR, tech, world of work, AI, yes, AI, of course. And I'm also a founder of ScaleHR. And this podcast lives on our website at goscaler.com and also on workdefined.com, where you can check out a bunch of other podcasts as well.

[00:00:27] So the podcast lives on YouTube, Spotify, iHeartRadio, Apple Podcasts, and so on. So we have lots of great guests and topics and so forth. So this one's a really good one. It's called Why Great Executive Hires Fail at Startups. So it's really specific to the startup crowd, but I know a lot of you are in a startup environment or a young tech company environment.

[00:00:53] So this is a really good one. We have a great guest, Jamie Savage, and I'll bring Jamie in shortly. But I just want to set the stage, frame the conversation first with a couple of key points. And so here's the first one. As startups grow, there's often a point where founders realize that they need to bring in someone who is experienced as a leader to help take the business to the next level.

[00:01:17] And naturally, they look for executives with impressive background, proven track records, and then experience scaling companies. But just because someone has been doing that, they've been successful leading a larger organization doesn't necessarily mean they're the right person to help build a smaller one. Right? That's the first point. Second point. So what's interesting is that when an executive hire doesn't work out, we always assume that the company hired the wrong person.

[00:01:47] Right? But maybe the bigger issue is that the founder wasn't entirely clear about what the business actually needed at the stage of growth. And so are they hiring someone to build, someone to scale, or someone just to manage an established operation? Those are very different leadership challenges. And so there's a lot to unpack here. And I want to welcome our guest, Jamie Savage. Finally, you're here.

[00:02:15] Welcome to the Unmuted Podcast. Jeff Waldman, thanks for having me. My pleasure. So we've known each other for a long time. And we've been trying to get you on the show for also a very long time. But we are here finally. And so I thought maybe you can start off by just telling our guest a bit about what you do. For sure.

[00:02:37] So the leadership agency, which is a company I founded in 2017, is an executive recruitment firm that works exclusively with VC-backed high growth companies. So anything from like a seed or like round all the way to pre-IPO or companies that have even IPO'd. We work at a leadership level.

[00:02:57] So we categorize ourselves as, you know, the firm that helps the boldest, the most impressive companies, the most daring companies, the highest, like the fastest growing companies hire for what's next. Right. So we don't look at executive recruitment as only C-level or only at the board level. We look at leadership hiring, you know, everything from, you know, a manager or a team lead all the way to the C-level.

[00:03:26] So we're really integrated with our organizations and our partners in all stages of their growth. Right. So if you're only hiring at the C-level, you typically only intersect with that organization once, twice, maybe a handful of times. We're quite different. We're quite, like I said, integrated from, you know, very early stages to the later stages of their organization because we're involved in all areas of that company's growth.

[00:03:51] So we are a Forbes recognized and, you know, accredited organization two years in a row as one of North America's best executive recruitment firms for high growth companies. And we're all throughout North America. So we're headquartered in Toronto, Canada, and we recruit in the U.S. and Canada.

[00:04:10] Fantastic. So obviously you've seen quite a bit and I, and I would also argue that your business has probably changed a lot since COVID and then coming out of COVID, you know, so you, you've got a really interesting vantage point probably with a lot of different technology companies. And so, yeah, I mean, it's great. So, I mean, obviously I'm a huge fan of your show. So, all right, so let's dive into our topic here. Okay.

[00:04:35] So the topic is why grid executives hire fail at startups. Okay. I'm a former HR leader and I've seen this happen a lot. Also probably not nearly as much as you, but it was a real interesting topic, you know. So, so here's my first question for you. So you've seen many startups make their first executive hires and you probably noticed some patterns that keep coming up. One of those hires don't work out, right?

[00:04:59] So what are founders typically getting wrong and why do these situations happen so frequently? Yeah, it's a great question. And it's something that we are often brought in to solve or to avoid. So this is definitely an arena that we're in all the time, more often than not really. So there's not really a simple answer to this, but there is a pretty common thread.

[00:05:26] And what we see often isn't about the wrong hire being made or a founder not being good at this, you know, world of recruitment. Really what we see here is honestly a misalignment and expectations. So, and what I mean by that, that's a really big statement, but really what I mean here is when you go to market to hire, say, a chief revenue officer, okay?

[00:05:50] When you go to market and you think, okay, what does that chief revenue officer need to look like in terms of experience and where do I want them to come from? That's often where we hold the most space in this hiring decision is what you want, right? And what you want them to bring to the table. And that's not really the right question to be answering. You need to think about why would somebody want to join my organization? And what are the expectations that I have of them?

[00:06:19] And what expectations do they have of me? And those questions can be answered, but if they're not evaluated with what comes next for the organization, that's when things can really fall apart. Oftentimes founders or anyone making a leadership hire is really looking at the hire and what needs to happen through the lens of what the current organization needs or what the organization currently needs, right? It's not about that when you're making a material impact hire.

[00:06:48] You should be looking around the corner of anywhere between 12 to 24 months minimum, right? And so what that does is it creates this intense amount of vulnerability because a lot of times you don't know what that is, right? You're like, well, I want to double in revenue and I want to, you know, have higher productivity. And maybe in the world of revenue, you want to increase your average deal size or decrease your sales cycle or whatever it may be, right?

[00:07:14] But sometimes you don't know the answers and that is what you're looking for is somebody who can point to what needs to happen for what comes next, right? So that can be really challenging. And one of the things that I hear most often on both sides of this hiring equation when it comes to our founders or clients all the way to the recruiters on the other end of it, whether it's in-house talent or even people on my team.

[00:07:40] I've heard people say this before, like, well, the compensation is not high enough. We can't compete at that level or this search is really hard because of X. Those are really misnomers in terms of why hires don't get made successfully because you can increase your compensation or your affordability line. But if your expectations increase with it, then that dial hasn't moved, right? So people don't realize that the talent market is a market.

[00:08:07] It responds, it reacts, does all the same things essentially that a stock market does, right? It's very reactive. It's very volatile. And so when you increase the comp and you increase your expectations, nothing's changed, right? So if the feedback is like you're expecting way too much for what the organization has capacity for.

[00:08:28] So let's look at that versus increasing your compensation because that's not going to change necessarily what makes us a really compelling opportunity for somebody, right? So expectations, market understanding, and vulnerability when it comes to founders or any leaders making a leadership hire. Yeah. Yeah. Do you also find that founders or any organization at all, they want everything?

[00:08:55] So they just throw everything at the wall and see which sticks because I've seen that happen a million times. I remember when I was leading HR, I used to have to bring my peers back down to earth, right? I'm like, well, you know, congestion for 22 different things. Sorry to say, but that doesn't exist here in Canada. So do you ever see that where they, you know, kind of falls into the, you know, lack of clarity, I guess. But I'm just wondering if you can comment on that. Yeah, of course.

[00:09:22] Like the thing is, is sure. You can want all of these things, like whether it's everything or too much or even sometimes too little, right? That's, that's common. It's human nature. I think the, the thing that, you know, we use as, as evidence for founders in this situation is, okay, what aren't you good at? Like where, what, what are your strengths and what aren't you good at?

[00:09:52] Like if you're a technical founder, maybe you're really good at sales also. Like that's great. You have a superpower, but probably not where your strengths need to be invested in, right? So like if you're a technical founder, product market fit and expansion and all those things, that's where we want you to focus. If, and vice versa, like if you're a marketing or a revenue founder, perhaps product and the technical aptitude of the organization might need to be invested in, right?

[00:10:19] So helping founders and leaders see what they're not good at. And one question that we find really, really helpful that we use in a lot of different scenarios and we use for ourselves is what's one thing you wish you could stop doing today? What is one thing that if you could stop doing or having to do today, what would it be?

[00:10:40] And, you know, vice versa, we use that in the interview process as well as when we're looking at leaders, we ask them like, what's something you've stopped doing that you were doing six months ago? You know, we were looking for obviously enhancements in their process and AI and so on. But when you ask somebody what you want to stop doing or what you've stopped doing, it's a really big indication of a lot of things. And is that person willing to actually let go? Right? You know, founders have a hard time actually letting go.

[00:11:09] All right, we'll dive into that more. So startups often gravitate towards executives with impressive resumes, right? You know, credentials, experience, working at a larger organization. Why doesn't that experience always translate into success in a startup? And then what should founders be looking for beyond someone's resume? Yeah, that's a really good question.

[00:11:29] And it's something that I don't think is ever going to change per se because the interview process and how we engage with talent is designed specifically for people like who interview well to win, right? So and it's not really any different. Like when you present facts about yourself, whether it's your experience or your, you know, your successes, when you present it in a way that makes when it's a common language, people are going to gravitate towards that.

[00:11:57] And I think that, you know, if you look at the world of business and companies, 80% of business to business brands have never been heard of, right? So when you have a resume that is stacked with brands and organizations that are relevant to you and that you can see yourself having experienced in the past or you admire for whatever reason, that becomes really familiar, right?

[00:12:21] But there's an entire world of organizations that exist that, you know, hire and develop phenomenal talent, right? So my point here is that, like, if you look at a lot of what Elad Jill says about how founders, you know, and executives should be hiring, it is an engine that should never stop running.

[00:12:42] It should be, you know, like the first line of defense, so to speak, for founders about, you know, okay, who do I need to be attracting to my organization? It's a pipeline, right? So executive and leadership recruitment should never stop. And what that does also is it allows you to learn about the organizations that are out there that are hiring great talent, that are developing great talent, you know?

[00:13:10] And I think that that is something that, you know, is obviously a secret sauce and a superpower of what we do, right? We are in the market 24-7. We understand, you know, where companies like the big VC firms like Insight Capital or Insight Partners and Andreessen Horowitz, like we see the shifts of the organizations that they're investing in to the hires that their portfolio companies are making. And that's our full-time job, right?

[00:13:37] So the point is that when founders start to invest more of their time, not in making hires, but learning about the market and how to build a pipeline, that's when those sort of, I guess, typical hires can avoid getting made. Yeah, because I think to the earlier point, candidates that actually go through a process, maybe two weeks, two months, you know, it doesn't really matter. But it's a very short-term window, right?

[00:14:04] And people that are really good at presentation obviously can, I don't want to say game it, but I just want to say that they can very easily portray an image that they want to in a short period of time, okay? But if you build a pipeline, then those people are getting to know these organizations with time. It's very difficult, if almost impossible, to hold that image, a persona over a long period of time, right? Absolutely. Two colors come forward, right?

[00:14:34] But I think that is especially critical in a senior executive type role. You mentioned earlier that founders often aren't clear about what their business actually needs at its current stage. So there's multiple stages, right? So how should founders think about the type of leader that they need today versus the leader they might need maybe two or three years from now? Yeah, great question. So I think the mistake I see is founders waiting until something breaks, right?

[00:15:04] So that's often what we see, you know, and then hiring becomes a panic-like situation. And it forces you to just look at solving a current problem or fixing what's broken. And that, I mean, of course, that's life, right? Like you can still hire perfectly fine in that scenario, but it's about realizing what situation you're in. Like, are you reacting to something that's broken or something that needs to change?

[00:15:34] Or are you strategically planning and responding to where your company, you know, where you want the company to go? And I think that, you know, looking at growth is different today than it was obviously, you know, a year ago. Whatever period of time you want to use as a framework for that.

[00:15:54] Growth now means, okay, yes, people, of course, like, you know, you want to look at leaders who have grown the company by headcount and so on. But it's about doing more with less. Growth isn't necessarily measured only in revenue and in people now. Revenue, of course, is going to always be the front runner. But really looking at, okay, does my organization need to hire more people? And do I need a leader whose skill set is that?

[00:16:22] Or do I need to find a leader who is going to help me do more with less? Is this leader going to help me pivot our organization from being an SMB, you know, solution to an enterprise level solution, right? So it's really being honest with the market and with yourself, right?

[00:16:40] So if you go to market as a founder and say, okay, like right now we're at 10 million, we're profitable, we have all these organizations, but you're not, you know, as partners or as clients and you're in all these markets and you have all these employees. But if you're not honest about like your churn rate or, you know, things like, okay, well, we have a terrible product market fit in these three verticals. We have one superstar vertical. And if we lost that vertical, we'd be in really big trouble. We haven't diversified, you know, things like that, right?

[00:17:09] So those are the things that you want to get really honest about with the market because then it responds the way that you need it to. That's an excellent answer. I've been shaking my head to your earlier comment about how founders tend to react to one of the problem. And I can't tell you how many dozens of times I was a former HR leader where I'd meet with founders and I immediately knew that they were going to talk about problems, right? And things that they were dealing with and things that they need to solve right now.

[00:17:36] And then I tried to call them back while still talking about that. But I used to act on about their long-term plan. And you remember one founder asked me, does that matter to an HR leader? I said, excuse me? I said, because I'm running a business function and I'm your right-hand person and I need to make you aware because if you have a strategy, it means nothing to me. I'll let you have people doing it.

[00:17:56] So anyway, they need to think more long-term, but also be really clear about what some of the pain points are because I know that in the interview process, the company wants to give off impression to the candidate things are all perfect. Bullshit, right? And I have to say, no, please tell me the good, the bad and ugly because my job is to help you fix those problems, right? So anyway, really interesting.

[00:18:21] So as AI changes how startup companies operate, allowing smaller teams to accomplish more, do you think the profile of a successful startup executive is changing? And then what advice would you give founders preparing to make their next senior leadership hire? Yeah, great question. So it's undeniable that the expectations of leaders, you know, in this particular category has changed.

[00:18:48] So, you know, based on a recent study that we did on our own database and our own searches, we went back and evaluated every single transcript of discovery all the way to searches to all the way to roles filled, right? So we use three major data points in our own practice. And this time last year, only 17% of our executive hires needed to have some sort of AI capability or playbook, right?

[00:19:16] It was on the radar or they wanted it to be on the radar or in some level of functionality of their playbook. Now it's 74 and the expectation of that 74% is an entire playbook. Okay, so that pendulum has swung for sure. And that's within our own practice.

[00:19:37] So that is something that is really powerful because the expectation of, you know, leaders has changed, but also so has the leaders of founders and organizations. So what I mean by that is, you know, people looking to make career moves, like you have to think about it as a leader. Regardless of where you come from and what you're doing or not doing, you are looking at your next move as where can I invest my expertise?

[00:20:05] Where can I invest, you know, my investment of myself to another organization? And they're going to be looking for a founder and an organization who has accepted and adopted and is investing in that in their organization as well. I would, you know, bet on the jockey here and not the horse when it comes to what people look for.

[00:20:27] If you were in an interview as a leader looking at a founder and that founder says to that leader, okay, like everything is broken or nothing is the way it's supposed to be. We will literally give you every tool and resource that you need or to support your playbook to, you know, better productized our organization, bring us in, completely transform us. That is a way more compelling opportunity, I think, for a lot of people than if you sit across the table from a founder who says, everything is great.

[00:20:56] We have all the AI that we need. Everyone is completely up to speed and trained. And we have all these agents running for us and everything's great. I just, I don't, I don't buy it. And I don't think that other leaders would look at that as something that's really exciting. So when you're talking about this though, because AI is merely in the use cases, right? And so for me, I look at it from a, okay, so AI for our main product to go to market.

[00:21:25] So how do we leverage AI to touch and make our product better? We can use AI for customer support. We can use AI for sale, right? So there's the external facing product side of things, but that's also the internal operations. So are you seeing both? Because obviously as a leader, both have to be got into it. So what do you think now? Well, I think it's everything. Like even like a lot of our clients are AI native, right? So they're an AI native organization. They are the ones going to market selling an AI native solution.

[00:21:54] But they themselves are still looking to create the magic playbook internally in a lot of cases, right? They still need the leadership capacity and the AI horsepower that any other organization needs. So it very rarely has to do with who the organization is. It's more about the willingness and the mindset and the investment about changing or enhancing or sometimes even scaling back.

[00:22:20] Like sometimes, you know, and I think this is what we're going to see a lot in the coming years is, okay, we have way too much in our playbook or way too much in our tech stack. What's actually working? What's important? What's actually, you know, moving our business forward? What's too expensive? What's, you know, not expensive enough? And let's buy more of that. And like things like that.

[00:22:42] Like I think we're going to be really at this unique stage probably this time next year about evaluating what's working and a leadership skill set to be able to do that. So it's, it's never going to stay the same. And I think it's moving faster now than it's ever moved completely. So we've talked about quite a bit. If there's any one thing that you want our viewers to take away from this episode, right? So what is that one thing? For founders to take away? Anyone, you know, just from what we've talked about.

[00:23:11] Yeah, I think that the number one takeaway for anyone listening to this podcast is to remember that we are humans. Our candidates are humans and that the business of recruitment is still fundamentally human, right? And we can look for, you know, what our business needs and, you know, what the challenges are.

[00:23:38] And we can, you know, incorporate all the things that are important, you know, in this moment in time of AI. But the real, the real winning that's happening here is when we are still incredibly human. That will always win over the algorithm when it comes to leadership recruitment, because so much of the success is about chemistry. It's about human connection. And it's about being really, really honest with ourselves and with other people.

[00:24:08] That is an excellent way to conclude this episode. So Jamie Savage, thank you very much for being here. Really appreciate it. And to all of our listeners, I'm Jeff, host of the Unmuted podcast. We are nearing our 100th episode. I am not going to divulge who is going to be the guest on our 100th episode. That's coming soon. But you can find us on our website at GoScaleHR.com. Also on WorkDefined.com. And you can pick your platform of choice.

[00:24:39] Spotify, iHeartRadio, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and so on. And so we talk about all things HR, HR tech, world of work, AI, and much, much more. So Jamie, thanks for being here. Thank you. And that's a wrap. Thanks for listening to the Unmuted podcast with Jeff Waldman. Real conversations, zero corporate filter, all about the future of work. If you enjoyed this episode, subscribe, leave a comment, and share it with someone smart.

[00:25:09] New episodes drop every week. Until next time, stay unmuted. .