Alex Alonso, Chief Knowledge Officer at SHRM and a Fellow of SIOP, joins Charles Handler to work out how industrial-organizational psychology, artificial intelligence and the HR profession fit together as work is remade by AI. You will learn why HR and IO psychology both have a brand problem, how to make the business case for people science with a proof of concept instead of a budget request, what SHRM means by AI plus human intelligence, and why the resume, the interview and the work sample no longer prove that a candidate can do the job. The episode ends with Alex's view of what assessment has to become now that candidates can fake almost any skill with AI.

Key Takeaways

Only 31 percent of HR professionals know what IO psychology is, and fewer than one in ten who have worked with an IO psychologist want to do it again, because IO rarely shows HR how it creates business value.

About half the behaviors in HRX, SHRM's new framework for an excellent HR function, are IO science, so the value is real but it is not being translated.

The skill that carried Alex's career is speaking data to humans: translating what the research shows into something the people doing the work can use.

Talent analytics earn their keep when they show that the work raised revenue per employee, lifted engagement in ways customers felt, or increased the return on the employer brand.

Do not bring the C-suite an idea and ask for an investment. Run a proof of concept on one site or one team, show the business result, then ask for the resources to scale it.

AI plus HI changes the ROI equation. HI is human intelligence, the judgment, creativity and context a person brings that the machine does not.

SHRM moved from warning members about AI's legal and bias risks to teaching them where a human and an AI working together produce more than either alone.

HR generalist roles are being automated away, and the CHRO is evolving toward a chief work officer responsible for the humans, the technology and how work gets done.

Hiring's proxies are shattered. Candidates use AI to fake resumes, interviews and work samples, and 80 percent of HR professionals say they have hired someone who could not do within three months what they showed in the process.

Assessment has to measure how well a person works with AI, and it has to be dynamic, meaning something a candidate cannot plan for or fake.

Timestamps

01:13 – Speaking data to humans

10:05 – HR's brand problem, and IO's

11:42 – Talent analytics that make HR a value creator

18:49 – Why practitioners never get the performance data

21:06 – Proof of concept before you ask for budget

30:17 – A number for the board next to EBITDA

35:14 – AI plus human intelligence

44:35 – The shattered proxy, skill fishing and ghosts

45:40 – Assessing how people work with AI

50:10 – Dynamic assessment and the ChatGPT history test


Keywords

AI in hiring, candidates faking skills with AI, skills-based hiring, industrial-organizational psychology, making the business case for HR, return on workforce investment, AI plus HI, assessing AI skills in hiring, AI policy at work, future of HR

Powered by the WRKdefined Podcast Network. 

[00:00:09] Hello, hello, and welcome to the Psych Tech @ Work podcast. I am your host, Dr. Charles Handler. And boy, howdy, do the guests just keep getting better and better. My guest today is none other than Alex Alonso. Alex is the Chief Learning Officer at SHRM, just a little organization that a few of you may have heard of.

[00:00:37] But SHRM has such good visibility into the world. And guess what? SHRM values IO psychology in a big way. I didn't know Alex before, although we've probably crossed paths and been in the same room, but he knows a lot of the same people that I do. And he knows a lot of the same stuff as I do and more, especially about how IO and HR need to come together in the age of AI to kick some ass.

[00:01:04] So without further ado, welcome, Alex. Thank you so much for taking time to join me today. And I can't wait to hear about some of the stuff you're doing. I really enjoyed your talk at the sign up LEC, which by the time this airs could be long in the rearview mirror, but we'll talk about what you shared there. So tell everybody, you know, who you are, what you do, how you got to be doing what you do.

[00:01:31] Well, Charles, I really appreciate the opportunity to be here. I've always been a fan of yours. And more importantly, I'm excited to be on this to have this conversation with you. Candidly, I'm enthused and thrilled. For context, I'm Alex Alonso. I'm chief knowledge officer at the Society for Human Resource Management or SHRM. I'm a fellow of PSYOP for the last since last six years, since 2020. And I'm a member of the board of trustees for the PSYOP foundation as well.

[00:01:58] I started my career out. And part of the reason I think we're here is I learned early on that I had one kind of not superpower, but one part of a trick that I could always do, which was I could speak data to humans. And I like to translate that very thing. And it's something that has been at the crux of or the heart of my relationship with IO psychology in general and HR. It has been being able to translate what it is happening in the wild to the people in the wild.

[00:02:27] So that's what I really love to talk about. That is so cool. So you're a fellow PSYOP fellow. That's cool. I think I was 20, 22, something like that. So, yeah, that's that's really cool. It's one of the biggest career honors I've had. I haven't I don't have a ton of skins on the wall in that regard. So it's nice. And, you know, I I connect really well with what you're saying, because I think that's been a big part of my career, too, is building trust with practitioners,

[00:02:55] because I can say dumb this stuff down or whatever. Right. And and be flexible, you know, understanding the context. It's everything's not a research project where we have a lot of control over what's going on. So definitely a skill for sure. My SHRM connection besides paying attention to what you all do. I've been to the conference a couple of times and multiple times.

[00:03:19] Really, I taught the prep class for the SHRM PHR exam in 2002, something like that. So a heck of a long time ago. And I'll be honest, as an I.O. person coming through that program, there's a lot of aspects of H.R. I didn't know about. So teaching that class really gave me a good foundation. And I'm curious, you know, I'm glad to see an I.O. there. I figured there would be, but I'd never really met anyone.

[00:03:49] How does that work with, you know, what we do? I'm a selection guy, so I'm always focusing on that. You're probably more broad. But how does I.O. look within you get what I'm where I'm going is, you know, Yeah, there's a lot going on and we can be kind of narrowly focused sometimes. So how do you spread yourself out across all that? Yeah. You know, it's sort of funny because you want to talk about a sort of an interesting experience. I think I was the second I.O. psychologist ever hired at SHRM there.

[00:04:19] I think Mark Schmidt. I was just writing that down. I know Mark really well. I was writing Mark Schmidt on my on my notes because I know he went there. Yeah. Mark Schmidt was there probably about a year before I was, you know, God love Mark. He and I are still friends.

[00:04:33] One of the things that struck me was my role was a unique role because it came about in large part because SHRM had a desire to get more rigorous about what we did to educate, to prepare, to identify and professionalize HR professionals. Right. To your point, it is a broad kind of profession and it has many sub disciplines, just like I.O. psychology does. Right.

[00:05:00] I remember the days you and I are probably both old enough to remember the days where we used to have the argument or the debate about what's more important, the I or the O. Right. Yeah. Yeah. And one of the things that strikes me is HR is the same way. You've got your comp and bend people. You've got your talent acquisition people. You've got your talent management people. You know, Alan Church and I have had numerous debates about that because he's arguing that's a whole other profession. Right.

[00:05:25] And all that to say they approached me because I had been a contractor to them, really trying to help them put some rigor behind what it is that they were doing to develop the HR profession. OK.

[00:05:38] And as I as my career evolved, because I've been there for 15 years now, as my career evolved, one of the things that struck me was HR is so broad, but the principles of what can help professionalize it are extremely narrow. And what I mean by that is it just needed the rigor that was associated with being professional.

[00:06:02] And the first thing that we all know you start out with is let's talk about what really goes into this profession. Let's detail. Let's analyze it. What do we do better than anybody? We build competency models and we analyze jobs. Right. Yeah, that's that's that's the birth of our that's the core of what we do for whatever purpose, whatever approach that is the foundational element of what we do.

[00:06:25] Yeah. And that was really the nuts and bolts of what started. You talked about the PHR and and that that's our former our legacy credentialing group. Now we have SHRM certification, SHRM CP and SHRM SCP certified professional and senior certified professional. Part of what we were looking to do was actually have a competency model that really served as the foundation for what made HR truly the next generation kind of profession.

[00:06:53] And that was my task coming in. It was so weird because by the time that I got around to actually doing that work and Mark was a great help in that, we started to do another thing, which was to bring in IOs to do other things at SHRM. Let's start building indicators of national employment in a different way, different than an economist would. Let's look at how IOs psychologists can contribute to policy positions and thinking about regulatory practices.

[00:07:21] Let's think about how IOs psychologists can build in better program evaluations to demonstrate that if you fund better education and better preparation in organizations, that will have greater economic mobility outcomes, right? All of a sudden we went from two IO psychologists there to now we had a team today. I have a team that is close to 22 IO psychologists. Really? Yeah. And it doesn't even include the data scientists or the economists or,

[00:07:50] or all the other folks. The whole team is about 65 people. And we are basically applying our craft, which is critical thinking and analytical capability to the way work gets accomplished. That's really the, and especially the work of HR gets accomplished. That's really where IO applied something that changed the very dynamic, the very fabric of SHRM and then the HR profession beyond that. And I'm not giving myself credit.

[00:08:19] That was really the brainchild of Deb Cohen, who was our leader at that time. Well, I'm glad people recognize our value. And yet for sure, it all starts with understanding what is the, what does the work require? If you don't know that you're going to be off target with everything. So, you know, HR in the, in the greater world, HR gets a pretty bad rap as being the administrative people, as being the cops, you know, the downers that are sitting in the workplace that you want to avoid, et cetera.

[00:08:49] So how does that, cause we know it's way more than that. Right. But in fact, that's not even legit in some sense. If I, you know, we're, we're keeping the company safe and the people that work there safe, hopefully. But, but how, you know, how is the perception of that internally? And have you all worked to kind of help the brand represent something more than that? I guess.

[00:09:14] I'm sure you have, but in, in the walls, how do people talk about that? Do they think about that as a real problem and own it or, or, you know? Yeah. Anyway. Yeah. So we definitely talk about it. There's no question about it. Right. And it's funny because we even have conversations about this with groups that are the top, the very top of the HR profession groups that are kind of industry groups as well. Right. And, and we, we talk about it to CEOs too.

[00:09:42] We talk about it to you know, the C-suite in general, cause we actually have a core of members that includes, I think it's 98% of the fortune 500 CEOs. And one of the things that we've, our CEO, Johnny C. Taylor Jr. is very fond of is talking about, I think of it and, and I'm a big fan of the office, right? I love the office back in the day. I was just going to mention that. Yeah. Like that's hyperbole about it. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So everybody thinks about Toby and what a monster and Michael called him a monster.

[00:10:11] In fact, I started a book once with a quote, there are monsters and then there are the most horrible monsters you could ever imagine. And then there's HR, Michael Scott, right? And it was based upon this notion that Toby Flunderson is your, your stereotypical HR professional. Yeah. In reality, what Johnny always tells us to think about is HR at its finest is actually Wendy Rhodes.

[00:10:38] And I don't know if you've ever seen billions, uh, the show billions on Showtime that has come and gone. But what she was, was an analyst who could unlock performance. She was a psychiatrist, but an analyst who could unlock performance and understood potential to me. That is actually not just HR that's IO. That's what you get when you get HR and IO together, right? That to me is sort of how we change the brand of both HR and in some ways IO, right?

[00:11:08] Cause you were at my, my talk at LEC. And one of the stats that I always hone in on is if you ask most HR professionals, whether or not they would actually, well, one, do they know what IO psychology is only 31% of professionals so that they do. Right. Yeah. And what's even scarier is if you ask them, how many of them would you want to work with after a six month engagement with them? That the number drops down into the single digits, right? That's, that's scary. Yeah.

[00:11:33] And the reason for it when I asked why is, you know, they don't understand the entire concept of what creating value is to the, to the organization, right? Especially human capital value. Yeah. And so all that to say in reality, Charles, yes, we think about it all the time. We are very fond of thinking about how we evolve that. I think there are two levers where IO really plays a key role, a key, key role in helping change that dynamic.

[00:12:03] Number one, the key to anything that we do is talent analytics, people analytics. And I, you know, I don't want to sound like Josh Burson, but at the end of the day, that is the truth of the matter. If you can demonstrate that you've increased revenue per FTE, that you've increased the amount of engagement that leads to positive customer engagement or consumer engagement or customer experience, and you can then also demonstrate that you are generating greater

[00:12:32] return on brand visibility in some way, shape or form. Those metrics are the kind that will guarantee you that not only HR is being seen as a value creator, but then beyond that, that it's also being leveraged through the analytics work that an IO psychologist can bring to bear. The second lever is a key thing that I have found absolutely critical with the most forward leaning IOs I've ever been around, future thinking, right?

[00:13:01] And I say that, I really distinguish that and say, think about the future, not future mongering, right? Somebody once gave me a note on that and said, it was in fact that somebody is actually Gary Latham to be completely clear. He said, don't call it future thinking, call it future casting. What you are trying to do is, and what we want us to be able to do is, I think IO psychologists

[00:13:26] as a whole are pretty darn good about seeing what implications of the future are and how work needs to rise, change, shift to actually help that future come to fruition, right? We do future oriented job analyses as an example. To me, that skill set is deficient amongst HR professionals, but IOs can help create that skill set within organizations.

[00:13:50] And that is something that is lost across the board and getting further lost as we look at this era of AI. Oh, yeah. We'll bring in the AI conversation here in a minute. I've been trying to, I haven't been trying to avoid it actually, because it's all I talk about. But, you know, I want to get us a foundation before we just jump into that. Obviously, it's pretty hermitating almost everything. So a couple of thoughts I had. I mean, one of the interesting things if you look at, and I feel the focus in IO psychology

[00:14:18] as well, because we deal with big companies for the most part. SMBs make up, well, like, I don't know, is it like 75% of all the people in the US are employed by SMBs? And some of those are very small. Some of those have one person who does HR and a lot of other stuff, you know, now we have technology, I think, to help that. But I just feel like that schema in my mind, I don't think about HR in that realm of the

[00:14:47] small businesses. You know, I own a small business that's not related to this. I guess I'm the HR department. I don't know, right? And there's stuff I have to do. And I think about it that way. But the funny thing is applying the IO psychology to that business. It's funny. My guys are like, hey, this isn't a corporate work. I don't know. I get it on a tangent. But I live that a little bit. But I feel it. Yeah, I feel it.

[00:15:13] Let me tell you, 11% of our membership is what we call an HR department of one. We have 350,000 members at SHRM. And 11% of them, that's over 35,000 of them, are actually HR departments of one. And when you look at that, what that means, in many cases, that's people like you who run a small business and are doing so much more than just the HR function. You're the engine of the catalyst for what is total administration and business operations, right?

[00:15:42] Now, doing it in a way that actually helps those organizations and actually bringing IO science to those organizations is actually something that is a lot of what we've done over the years has been targeted towards this notion of not to derail us here, but this notion of what is, in essence, big businesses, right? Big workshops, big a lot because we are so quantitatively grounded. That's what you see.

[00:16:11] But what you're seeing is a movement, and I go back to Ed Salas, actually, who talked about this back in 2011 and 2010. We need to get back to some of our roots, ethnographic research, observational research, all the things that really are the notion of that theory building that goes with social sciences and triangulate solutions, triangulate the way that we think about that. That, to me, speaks volumes.

[00:16:38] You don't have a well-rounded education in IO if you can't do those pieces, too. Yeah. And so, as I look at that, that, to me, is a really big deal because, to your point, over 70% of the workforce is employed by a small to medium-sized employer. Yeah. And they don't often use what we do. But one of the things I feel like has really been beneficial is the technology platforms, AI or not.

[00:17:06] As an HR department of one, you can now manage everything from one platform. And it makes stuff a lot easier, you know, because there is a lot of paperwork and a lot of admin stuff that nobody likes. But we're getting more and more able to automate those things. And so, technology is bringing us as HR people because you'd think in those systems what HR people and even IO people know how to do. And the good ones, and hopefully a lot of them, is baked into that. And you may have a bot in there that can help you, you know, within that environment instead

[00:17:36] of just going to ChachiGP to get your advice. And it's even more aligned with the software, you know. So, technology is, I think, having a lot of change there. And, you know, in most of those businesses, well, I'm sure you get this a lot when you tell people you're an IO psychologist. And they say, well, don't analyze me. Or I need you to analyze me, you know. Help me with my problems, you know, kind of thing.

[00:18:02] And you have to explain to them, you know, I'm a work psychologist. I don't really do that. I know your job, though. I can tell you what you need to do to be able to do your job pretty well, pretty quickly. So, to the levers you were talking about, though, again, I go to my notes here as we're going. I feel with the data part, you know, you got to care about the data. And, I mean, how many times as a practitioner I've put a selection system in place and then

[00:18:28] tried to get the dang performance data to actually show what's going on. And everybody feels they're too busy or it's too disjointed. And you can't show it. You're kind of neutered there. So, it's a little bit difficult for that. And then, you know, the future casting, too. It's all about execution. Like, we can bring the concepts to the table and the education to the table. If people don't really push it through and say, these are the things we actually need to do

[00:18:58] to execute this stuff, it can be frustrating for us. I know I've been quite frustrated, especially as a consultant. Although there, what I like is, okay, because I like helping people solve problems, especially when it helps people have a happier job experience. I mean, we burn our energy almost 50-50 between relationships and work, you know. And so, the relationship part, I can't do anything about. You don't want me helping you there. But the work part is a lot of your brain, right? And a lot of your energy.

[00:19:27] So, it's, I guess, sometimes good for me to be able to walk away and say, all right, I've given you the advice. Please follow it. But internally, it's a different thing. This episode of Psych Tech at Work is brought to you by Rocket Hire's TA Tech Navigator. The TA Tech Navigator is your expert guide to the hiring technology landscape. It's an interactive AI that provides expert human analysis delivered at scale.

[00:19:53] With over 540 objective vendor profiles, it helps you understand the trends, find the truth, and lower risk when making candidate evaluation and assessment purchase decisions. It's the single source of truth when it comes to this complex and rapidly growing market. Sign up now at rockethire.com. So, execution, you know, how do you all help in that realm?

[00:20:17] How do you help preach that, the longevity, the penetration of what you're teaching people to do? And I guess that probably gets to leadership, right? And I guess then the question, I'm elevating the question, how do you see the relationship between HR and VPs of HR, etc., CHROs, and the rest of the C-suite?

[00:20:40] You know, how much has HR been really able to lobby for themselves and executing as we need? So much of what we do as IO psychologists rests on the science and what we bring to bear. But I think some of it needs to rest in principles of good product management, right? Okay. And I know it sounds a little funny, but there are other disciplines across the business sphere that I think we could learn from.

[00:21:09] To me, proof of concept and MVP are two things that we need to build into what we do, right? I used to have a neighbor, I'll never forget, he was a professor at Miami-Dade Community College, and he taught English, or excuse me, history. And he said his favorite president was always Harry Truman. Why? Because Harry Truman was from the Show Me State. He was from Missouri. But he believed in show me what you can do in small increments, and then I will open up the aperture for more and help you get stuff done.

[00:21:39] I look at that and I say to myself, so much of what we IO psychologists do are ready-made, baked kind of solutions, approaches, those kinds of things, because we know what we know. And it's sort of the anchor that goes with being an expert, right? But at the end of the day, I think if we applied some of those principles around get me an MVP, get me sort of a proof of concept, that would help us go a long way to getting people to help us get more stuff done

[00:22:07] and to really live to what data tells us. Now, the reason I bring that up and start even there is, to your point, HR has that same problem when and has traditionally had that same problem when thinking about how it is that they developed that proof of concept for many C-suite leaders, for their peers in the C-suite, right? And I remember back when I started to show them, you couldn't even say that the CHRO was a peer in the C-suite, right?

[00:22:37] More of them reported it to CFOs and CAOs or COOs than the actual CEO. Today, that dynamic is very different. And we have COVID to thank for that, right? COVID changed the dependency on your human capital and changed the way that we go about doing things. What I think that we're seeing and how I think that we're looking at this is, in many ways, HR still needs those tools to offer up both those analytical ways of thinking about it, that data,

[00:23:05] but they also need the skills to be very good at providing a proof of concept of how this will work. That's a lot of what makes effective CFOs work, effective CTOs work, and other C-suite leaders, right? I think about my peers in marketing. They all go about providing some sort of proof of concept, right? To me, the easiest lever for changing the dynamic between CHROs and other C-suite leaders

[00:23:32] is having them act the same way that those other C-suite leaders do. Don't bring me an idea and ask for an investment. Show me a proof of concept on a smaller scale and then ask for more resourcing to get bigger effects. That's how you go about doing that. To me, that's a key component. And I see it with all the best leaders, right? I think about Donna Morris at Walmart, right? Donna Morris had an example where she, when she first came in, she said,

[00:24:01] if I showed you that if you raised one point of engagement at your stores, at three or four of your stores, that would yield nearly $80 billion in return once applied to the entire enterprise. That is something that was a whole, if you think about it, Walmart is, at that point, was a $580 billion enterprise. She was threatening to deliver even more value, right?

[00:24:27] Those are things that she was able to do because she asked for proof of concept. And she then brought that proof of concept to the rest of her peers. That is a different way of thinking about the relationship than what has traditionally been the case. Interesting. Yeah. So, I mean, Walmart, and we all know a bunch of IOs there, right? They have so much data. I mean, David Futrelli, a while back, did a presentation. I know Dave, yeah. Yeah, yeah.

[00:24:53] They had so much data they were able to predict even when people dropped out the first five items or something of their assessment, like who would have been a good employee or whatnot. And it's just, that's incredible. Go ahead. Trent Burner worked for me at Shurton for a while, right? Yeah. And Trent was one of those IOs as well. I think he was maybe first or second at Walmart. I got a funny Trent Burner story and Walmart story.

[00:25:19] So, I have written about assessment for a very long time. And, in fact, when the Electronic Recruiting Exchange started in like 2001, I just showed up and said, let me write articles about assessment. And back then, there was one place to get your content out there. And, thank goodness, because that really helped my career with a lot of talent leaders because they were reading my stuff. And I would put up interesting things.

[00:25:47] And one time I saw a thing on the web that said, you know, you can click here, pay whatever, and we'll give you the answers to the Walmart employment test. So, I put that in my blog. Like, hey, this is a problem. And look, even just for Walmart. So, I got a letter from the Walmart, you know, legal team that said, take all this down, you know. And I did, of course. But I didn't think about it that way. And then, probably 10 or 12 years later, I was with a vendor.

[00:26:15] And I made a call to Trent about stuff. And he said, well, you know, we can't really talk to you here at Walmart. You've been banned from any conversations with us because of what you did. And I sent him up. Actually, I sent him a FedEx with a letter that said, I'm really sorry, but don't confuse lack of judgment with a lack of integrity, you know. And then I got back in the good graces of people there.

[00:26:45] So, I don't know. That's my story. I felt really bad. I'm like, can I go to the store and buy some sporting goods or something? Are you going to keep me out of there, too? Anyway, I digress. But the other thing is, you know, if you get the IO that is actually a CHRO, too, like my friend Jana Fallon, I've worked with forever. She's nationwide, I believe, as the CHRO. Really proud of her. She's excellent.

[00:27:14] There are probably some of us out there that are in that role. And that's a really strong position to be in. Without question. And I'll tell you what. She's a great example of that. You've got a variety of others across the ecosystem. But I go back to some of the legends that actually did it first, right? Peter Fasolo at J&J. You got Brian Silva at Fresenius Medical Care, who's one of the first that I remember. You've got people like David Rodriguez at Marriott, right? We knew David Rodriguez.

[00:27:44] I serve on the PSYOP Foundation board with him. And Marion Gratic-Weir at Merck, right? She was another prime example of that. They are really the pillars of bringing science and the practice of HR to the very top at the highest order of industry, right? And to me, that's just remarkable. Yeah. I just thought of a study for you guys. You might have already done it, though. No, not necessarily.

[00:28:10] Have you ever looked at the relationship between companies that have IOs and their increase in share price or any kind of overall business metric? You know, we haven't done that. What we have done, and we actually have this new framework that's come out recently called HRX. It's really about excellence in HR and what organizational capability maturity looks like and how that impacts key outcomes, right?

[00:28:38] So we at Sherm are on a big kick around HRX in particular because we're bringing a whole new suite of products to kind of help HR really step up their data game and their quantifying game. What is fascinating about that is if you look at the behaviors that go into that organizational capability framework, I'd argue about half of them are really I.O. kind of science work.

[00:29:00] And if I was able to tease apart just those things and really use a path analysis to determine what is it that actually delivers the greatest shift in performance and maturity along the way, I guarantee you what we'd find is that doing great I.O. actually is a key driver of revenue per FTE share value or stock values.

[00:29:26] And arguably, I'd say it's probably important for other factors too, like well-being, ability to predict turnover, all those things that a lot of organizations don't have. In fact, my charge, my personal charge, right, at Sherm has been a variety of different things. But my dream has always been to take, you know, if you sit in a board meeting, the CFO always ultimately reports out what EBITDA is.

[00:29:53] EBITDA is the one metric that everybody loves it. Yep. Will bring you, it's easy to understand and it goes. My argument is we need to develop Gershwin for the HR profession. And George Gershwin to me is growth, annual growth, right, in revenue times your basic workplace outcomes, your human capital outcomes divided by what your workforce investment is, right? The idea being it's return on workforce investment, but only if you have growth.

[00:30:23] There is no return on your workforce investment if you have no growth. And so I use the enterprise kind of annual growth and revenue as a driver for that. That to me is if I had a dream for what I could walk away from Sherm and feel like I've actually accomplished something, forget launching the Sherm certification, forget all the work that I've done before,

[00:30:44] bringing in 22 IOs over the course of my time or anything like that, it would actually be let's give a scorecard to HR that they can present at a board meeting. Yeah, you said Gershwin. I immediately thought of George Gershwin, the composer. And then I thought, can I think of one of his, did he do the Appalachian Spring? Is that him? Yeah, that was the one I could think of. But yeah, that's great. That's a great tune. Yeah.

[00:31:10] And, you know, and I did a psyop panel about this, I think maybe four years ago. The idea that the biggest, most successful titans of industry have the most IOs besides federal government, who has unfortunately less probably now than they used to. Your Amazons, your Googles, your Meta, your Walmarts. These people have a big cadre of IOs and they realize like that to me, there's just a correlation there.

[00:31:35] It's not just a population probability that the more employees you have, the more likely you are to have an IO on board. And I've seen my friends, you know, making huge impacts there at those companies. And as you said about scale, at the scale of Walmart, a 1% reduction in turnover is billions of dollars, right? The ROI of the stuff we do in selection, especially because you're putting a gate up there and saying, who gets to come in here and do the jobs we have?

[00:32:05] Who's going to be excellent at them? And, you know, there's a lot of false positives and negatives going on that kind of lower your capabilities. So, you know, the better we can do is awesome. So, I think this is the longest I've ever gone in the last four years and one of these things without talking about AI. Because there's a lot of other stuff in what you all are doing that transcends AI or not, right? But let's now talk about AI.

[00:32:34] Tell me the SHRM, everything I've looked at and read, it's a very AI forward, AI positive type of thing. And how did that go down with you all when it first started coming out? People were very concerned. I remember reading some SHRM stuff about how to navigate this stuff, how to think about it. You know, some good content you all put out. What's been the story there with AI? Yeah.

[00:32:58] So, you know, like any good kind of industry trade group or anything like that, we're a professional association, right? Like, one of the things that we have really focused on is, first, helping people understand what the regulatory and policy landscape looks like, right? And so, just like anybody else, we were involved in trying to understand where is it that this is playing a role in bias?

[00:33:23] Where is it that this is playing a role in terms of key jurisdictions where you have regulatory bodies or legislatures trying to demonstrate that they're going to put their arms around AI and how it can be used in employment? And then we got into tangential things like intellectual property and what it means for employers overall. So, our role was really to play the key role of being an advisor.

[00:33:47] What we came to realize pretty quickly was HR, like any profession in this space today, is at risk of either being left behind or being materially transformed if you don't really arm them with the tools they need to be great at using AI and designing their work to be focused on how they can accomplish things with AI as a tool to them, right?

[00:34:12] And so, we moved pretty quickly from what was an era where we were looking at how AI changes the world of work, what it is that it does to change law and the way that we can actually select, bring people in, think about what people do, how they're promoted, all those things, right? To the next phase of it, which was an AI plus HI changes your ROI equation, right? And so, as you start to think about that, AI is the artificial intelligence, HI is the human intelligence.

[00:34:41] And then what you get out of that combined facet or that combined skill set is what drives home some real return for your organization. What we have been focused on is, one, identifying where it is that humans and AI together are more likely to generate results that are either really different, really creative, or more productive in some way for organizations. So, we've pivoted.

[00:35:10] And then the second layer of that is how do we develop HR professionals to know when it is that they should use AI effectively, right? And not just generative AI, but other forms of automation, other forms of machine learning, other forms of analytical kind of capabilities. And so, all of that has really become the kind of thing where we are now playing the role of educator and helping organizations actually do that.

[00:35:36] In fact, next year, we'll have our AI plus HI project in October in Charlotte. And one of the things that we'll have is about 1,000 or so people in the space of HR employment really focused on how they use, develop themselves in the use of AI and how they can apply that back to their workplace to ensure that they are really developing the skill sets that they need to make the most of the combined kind of talent that you have, the artificial and the human.

[00:36:05] In addition to that, though, what we're now seeing is a transformation of how HR as a profession actually exists, right? It used to be that the core of what made up the HR profession was actually generalists. And it was a core of about 880,000 generalists in the U.S. out of a profession that was close to 1.8 million.

[00:36:27] What we're seeing is those generalist roles are starting to really dwindle off because a lot of it is work that could be automated in some way or could be treated in an intelligent way using artificial intelligence. One of the things that we're seeing is that it also changes the way that other roles in HR are actually executed. And so all of a sudden, we started to see this morphing of what the HR profession looks like.

[00:36:55] And we're seeing what is a transition from the CHRO to what we envision one day soon. Our CEO actually spoke about this at our conference this year was the chief work officer. When do we become the chief work officer? And it's not about the humans and their experience alone, but rather it's the humans, the technology, and how work gets done. So that's really what we're starting to see. And there's some great examples of organizations that are already doing this.

[00:37:22] You talked about organizations that have more IOs than anyone else, right? Amazon is an example, has more than anyone you might imagine, right? Fortune 1. And they actually, their HR function is known as people, experience, and technology because they're actually executing work that way. Moderna, right? We heard the whole notion of how their CHRO became their CHRO, which was the chief human AI resource officer.

[00:37:48] So all of a sudden, we're starting to see that transition come to fruition, and it's happening pretty quickly. So we now see ourselves as helping kind of shepherd that transformation for the profession as well. Yeah. And it really is an era of transformation. I mean, even if you strip away the marketing speak of that when you, and, you know, in my travels, the people I know, the new people I'm meeting are very enthusiastic internally about what it can do.

[00:38:16] And, of course, there's a lot of, we all know, there's a lot of things you have to manage and do to make sure that you're using it correctly. And education on that is really important. And, you know, you start to see more people with internal chief AI officers, and maybe not even in just the HR space or just the people space. But it, you know, it transcends. It's an umbrella.

[00:38:43] And the people area is a lot trickier, as we know, right? I like to say all the time, you can use AI to optimize your supply chain. There's no risk of any kind of bias. There's no risk of, you know, getting in any real trouble. It's all just optimization of physical things and pathways. But with people, it's not like that at all, right? We have so much more opportunity for problems.

[00:39:10] But as a profession, too, I believe, you know, the first 2022, everything, you go to PSYOP, you talk to, you look at the temperature. It's, hey, this is terrifying. Do we even try this or whatever? But it has gotten very democratized, right? And every month that goes by, I mean, I can't code my way out of a paper bag, right? I understand what's going on. I just can't do it.

[00:39:37] I'm now built, like, three apps, you know, three different apps I've built, some not related to I.O., a couple related to I.O. That have empowered me, you know, to be able to actually execute the things that I know how to do but can't create or whatever. So there's these pathways where it's getting easier, easier, more and more transparent. And my thing is at PSYOP, and I think outwardly, pretty soon we're going to just, it won't be about AI.

[00:40:06] It's just about here's how we do this thing. And AI is part of it. You know, I just came back. Have you ever been to HR Tech? I just came back from HR Tech. I have, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And that's a pretty crazy, there's not a lot of I.O. there. And, in fact, my, I did a little field research because of the database I publish of talent acquisition tools that make predictions. And this year, usually I just buzz by, you know, and don't really engage with people.

[00:40:34] This year, I went to every one of those people and asked them, you know, are they using the science? How's the science being included in how you're ranking people, rating people, et cetera? Or it was almost, you know, non-existent in that. And so, which is the signal I'm getting. So, we have an existential thing going on, too, where this stuff's moving fast. And these, all the HR technology, obviously, is in the HR world, in the HR department.

[00:41:01] That's what people are using to run there, to make it happen. And science isn't there. So, that's a crusade we all have to be on, you know. And the stuff you presented at the LEC, why don't you summarize that research a little bit? Because if you didn't see that, it was a good dovetail or connection, whatever, with what I'm seeing within the talent realm, which is no science, barely, at all. Yeah.

[00:41:25] You know, it was interesting because, so, at SHRM, what we wanted to kind of understand was, where is it that HR is actually using AI today, right? And, as you might expect, the majority of it was being used in the selection space and the recruitment space. Recruitment, more often than not, really being used to speed up, augment screening, do all the things that you might expect. The development of job descriptions is still the number one thing that people use, right, AI for.

[00:41:53] But as you start to disentangle that and do it by different types of tech solutions, what you quickly see is people are going at it from a scenario where they're doing two things. One is they're jumping in real fast at anything that is optimizing, anything that makes them much more efficient, provided one key facet. It doesn't create additional risk, but they don't know what additional risk means or how they quantify it, right? So, they hear bias when it comes to selection.

[00:42:23] That's risk. They hear, you know, benefits kind of provisioning and figuring out what best solutions are for benefits or best offerings. That doesn't feel like risk, so they go about doing it that way. They look at it very differently. Today, what we know is about 41% of employers actually have some form of policy as it relates to the use of AI, and about 81% of workers say that they're using AI, right? So, think about that.

[00:42:53] You're creating risk across the board because your intellectual property is going out, your data is going out, your ability to make decisions is going out the window. And what we are starting to see is a death of the traditional proxies for what it meant to be capable and be able to select great talent, right?

[00:43:12] The whole premise of my talk was that we have a shattered proxy system, meaning if you were accustomed to using some sort of selection instrument that said this person can do what they said they could do, that is no longer the case. We are now in an era where skill phishing happens, meaning people can fake it, they can create a digital veneer that allows them to demonstrate that they can accomplish things that they really can't even do.

[00:43:34] We're seeing, for example, that 80% of HR professionals say they have received and hired someone in their organization, received a candidate and hired someone in their organization who, within a three-month period, they found could not actually do the things that they demonstrated they could do. A work sample doesn't even work anymore. And so, that leads us to the point where we're actually validating what we call ghosts in my world, right?

[00:44:03] I'm validating that this person has some sort of skill, and it's not real. It's not real in any way, shape, or form. That is a real problem for us. So, part of what I've been on a mantra for, what I wanted to do at the LEC was say, hey, there's two things that are very clear here. One, we need to think differently around how it is that we assess capability, how it is that we assess skill, because what we've done in years past isn't enough anymore.

[00:44:32] It's becoming increasingly deficient. And the other piece is, as we know that work is changing and performance looks different, we are also seeing greater criterion deficiency. And so, because of that, we need to start to get into the habit of actually being able to assess capability, but capability along with AI capability. Not just a person's literacy, not just their fluency.

[00:44:59] What can they do when given a task together? And stop, I mean, vilifying to some degree, because I sat in for a day and a half, right? And I'll tell you, Charles, I always laugh a little bit when I sit this, because we want to maintain rigor. But at the same time, there's a group of us that are very small in the world of IO who are looking at AI saying, this is the reality and we have to keep going. And there's a group that's actually vilifying it in some way or treating it as just a tool, probabilistic, all those kinds of things.

[00:45:28] Probabilistic is today. Yeah. Yeah. If you think about where it will be 20 years from now, it could be very different. It could be its own sentient, right? Oh, yeah. Yeah. I mean, there's no doubt about it. It's happening fast. So I'm with you. I feel like companies should definitely be assessing AI capability, but in applied things, right?

[00:45:52] And instead of just trying to play whack-a-mole with barriers to say, look, you're going to use it on the job. You may even use it to try and get in here. So use it and show us how you can use it to do your job. It's still going to be a problem that we're going to have to work on because, as you said, people can misrepresent. Even with AI, you can be using AI on the side while you're doing it.

[00:46:18] But I've seen more and more people come into me, non-IOs as well, multiple ones, with, hey, here's a tool we're going to use to evaluate people's AI capabilities. One of the other interesting things, several of my friends are starting to get into breaking jobs down into tasks that use AI or not. So you can start looking at position requirements, et cetera, in a little bit of a different way, or at least to your case, future casting.

[00:46:47] What kind of stuff is our company not going to need people for? And how do we transform our people that are in there now to be able to do the other stuff? Or how do we hire for that, et cetera? And, again, I go to my notes here. You mentioned resumes and job descriptions, right? I'm going to ask you, at what point are you guys going to come out with a mandate that we ban those things, right? But because a lot of these matching tools, that's what they use.

[00:47:16] And so you're building the house on sand, as I say, as the theme here from the beginning is understanding what things about people are needed on the job and measuring and nurturing those. So, you know, if you're not really getting that signal coming in properly. But then, you know, we talk about assessments being a great opportunity to give people the equal playing field or whatever. And now that's compromised a little bit by the thing you're talking about.

[00:47:45] So it is a very – it's a difficult situation for us at this point. Things are infinitely harder. So maybe we can use AI to help us solve those problems. Or, like you said, we won't even be there to do it. I don't know what we'll do. Yeah, you know, I look at it and the existential crisis is there for HR. It's there for I.O. It's there for a bunch of us, right? And, you know, one, thankfully, I can't speak to banning resumes or job descriptions. I do recognize that. Yeah.

[00:48:14] For the most part, it's a joke. Oh, no, I know it's a joke. I get it. But I'll tell you what. I'm friends with Keith Sonderling, who is the secretary of labor. He was on the show. I know you. Yeah, I know you know Keith well. Yep. Yeah. Taylor Stockton, his chief innovation officer, has got some really interesting ideas about how they are looking to incentivize employers to walk away from that. So don't be surprised if you see some traction over the next couple of years.

[00:48:38] One of the things that strikes me, though, is I actually am a big advocate for what is what I call dynamic assessment of skill. Right. And what I mean by that is assessment of skill that someone can't plan for and can't fake. Right. You can tell I was you can tell I was trained by Vish Vestran, who's my major professor. Yeah. And so I'm always going to think about integrity and faking and all that and work with him, Denise Ones and those things.

[00:49:04] What what strikes me is there needs to be in this era a way to develop and scale assessment that allows us to get to the heart of what capability and knowledge skill ability is in ways that are dynamic and someone can't plan for, can't work around, can't do differently. And I'll give you an example of this. Right. This is Alex talking. Right. I'm all for banning resumes. I'm all for doing away with with job descriptions, but I would do it only if I was allowed to do one thing.

[00:49:34] And this is what I keep advising HR departments to do left and right without giving people warning. Ask them to give you one hour's worth of access to their chat GPT account and their prompting history. Ah, interesting. You would be able to figure out what people accept as answers. You'd be able to figure out what ideas they bring to bear, how they use tools, what they do without prompting them and without allowing them. Now, I've ruined it for everybody because somebody is going to go run with it. But it's not illegal yet.

[00:50:03] But figure out how to do that and watch how you can create a scenario where you will learn more about the humans than you might have expected. Yeah, that's different kind of digital dust in a sense. That's right. Yeah. I mean, I'm a huge fan of the applied stuff. I also envision just, you know, from a selection standpoint, you'll never be able to do it. But, you know, you give it's an immersive assessment center.

[00:50:27] You give them a device and, you know, they just interact in a simulated environment for a couple of days or whatever. And they're doing all this stuff. And, you know, it's being evaluated. We're up on time. There's a lot more we could talk about. I will say, you know, I've worked a little with people in the ed tech world. And there's some really good stuff like the Chamber of Commerce T3 initiative. I'm not sure if you're aware of that. Oh, I'm very much aware. I know them well. Yeah, yeah.

[00:50:55] So I had a, gosh, I can't remember. I'm getting old. The main guy on this show as well. Oh, God. Justin. Justin. Justin. Yeah, it was a different guy. But that's okay. We don't need to work on that.

[00:51:07] I think that ongoing, like you were saying, too, it's in the education world, validating skills by your peers and by things where, you know, you're breaking down the entire pathway of school to work into a set of durable skills that you can measure and see how they grow over time. And you're carrying that with you as a person. It's a little bit pie in the sky.

[00:51:31] And that transition between education and work has been a very difficult one when it comes to skills transfer and stuff. It's going to take a lot of effort still. But I like that people are doing it. So we're running up on time. I really appreciate it. What message would you want to leave the audience with here? And how can they do the things that they should be doing in this realm, if that makes any sense? Yeah.

[00:51:57] So I'm a big proponent of trying to buck the trend on what your existing norms are and what your existing kind of principles are. I believe that any good science needs to go through that. Any particular kind of discipline needs to go through that over a given period. For HR, we're seeing that come to fruition now for a variety of reasons, right? We've seen executive orders change the way that we think about compliance. We've seen AI change the way that work gets done. I think HR is going through that revolution.

[00:52:26] And I would argue that we're about to see changes that look like some of the foundational laws like Fair Labor Standards Act and all those things evolve. IO needs to do the same. We have done too much in the 120 years that we've been around that have now become the realm of quantifiable analytics and not actual meaningful impact. To me, we need that transformation and that reinvention for our discipline.

[00:52:55] Not just because it's an existential crisis, but God, because it's goddamn exciting. It's good to be at IO. Yeah. And I want us to go through that. Yeah. And, you know, connecting with SHRM is a really good way to help spread that gospel because you have such a big audience, which is awesome. So cool. Well, thank you so much for being here. I always ask people how they can find, how people can find them. But LinkedIn is obviously the place people find you.

[00:53:22] LinkedIn, if you want to find me, knowledge at SHRM.org. That is actually my inbox. You can find me anywhere you want. See you, Charles, next year in Chicago. I want you at our conference. Oh, cool. Well, actually, I got invited. I did two proposals for the one in Denver in April, right before. Yeah. I put in a couple of proposals to speak for that. So about this stuff. But yeah, man, I would love to. You know, I've been to a lot of SHRMs and seen the, I always like the keynotes, man.

[00:53:52] They have the best keynote, big time celebrity keynotes ever. So yeah. We'll see you at HRX Live 2027. Thanks. Thank you. Appreciate it. Bye-bye. Take care. Bye-bye. This episode of Psych Tech at Work is brought to you by Rocket Hire's TA Tech Navigator. The TA Tech Navigator is your expert guide to the hiring technology landscape. It's an interactive AI that provides expert human analysis delivered at scale.

[00:54:16] With over 540 objective vendor profiles, it helps you understand the trends, find the truth, and lower risk when making candidate evaluation and assessment purchase decisions. It's the single source of truth when it comes to this complex and rapidly growing market.