The application used to be a front door. For a lot of candidates, it’s now a black hole. Carin Van Vuuren, CMO of Greenhouse, talks about the changing and evolving world of talent and her journey to CMO.
Links: greenhouse.com
Powered by the WRKdefined Podcast Network.
[00:00:04] Welcome back to the channel as we are live at HR Tech and we're doing some things. We're talking today to Carin Van Vuuren. Oh my god, I... She does it every time. It's okay. It's okay. I butcher names like it's like word salad. I mean, it's just the worst, but we are so excited because she's from Greenhouse and a CMO, which is after my own heart. Oh, thank you. This is like my geek out moment. I'm here for it. I love anything GTM and marketing.
[00:00:31] So why don't you give us a little bit about why you joined Greenhouse a little bit because I would love to hear that. Okay. I actually am a CMO with an eight-year tenure at Greenhouse. I mean, that is... You would know it's kind of crazy. It is because most CMOs don't last that long and I'm like, so what's different here? And I think the thing that's different is I joined Greenhouse because there was a brand challenge. We were a really cool startup and wanted to like go up market and needed to evolve the brand into a more sophisticated,
[00:01:01] enterprise-ready kind of brand. That was a great assignment and I think we did a good job there. But the other challenges were twofold. One is going up market from having our roots in SMB and mid-market. That means retooling. It means like a new kind of team. It means a new approach to marketing. And the second thing is expanding globally. So I have these lovely challenges and they keep me really busy. So there's no time to be thinking about what else to do.
[00:01:27] But I'm working with an amazing boss and Daniel Chase is the CEO of Greenhouse. And I love working with him and alongside him. And I think, you know, the values that I embrace and the purposeness that comes from what we're trying to do is something that Daniel personally embraces. And that makes work meaningful. For me, that makes work really meaningful. Is hiring product, is this your first hiring product to be a CMO?
[00:01:54] Yes. I was a CMO in a couple of tech companies, like mobile technology, et cetera, et cetera. Large company like Capgemini, 150,000 people. But when I landed in Greenhouse, it's like, oh, hiring software, fabulous product, meaningful purpose. Let's make hiring better, not only for companies, but also for the job seeker. Because the job seeker is being screwed. And so that I found personally kind of very purposeful. And I've spent eight years like doing something about it. So I've loved it.
[00:02:23] I love it. And so we got access to a report. We haven't looked at it yet because we just got it like, last night. I don't even think Ashley knows we have this thing. Today. Because it was like, it was an embargo. And we love a good secret. You know. But I love it so much. What can you tell our viewers a little bit without giving away all the stuff? Sure. Or you can give it away. No, no, no. I mean, there's some stats and I probably will get some of them right and some of them wrong. Yeah.
[00:02:52] But essentially what we were doing is we were looking at how is AI being used in hiring and how do recruiters use it? So that's our audience, but more to the point, what's happening with job seekers? Yeah. How do they experience it? And because we all know that they're kind of at the short end of the stick here. And so there's a, for example, there's a stat there that says only 7% of applicants ever get an interview.
[00:03:20] Like hundreds of applications happen in every role and we know more than ever before, but on the average job, fewer than 7% of those candidates will get an interview. And so now you think about that stat and you're like, holy crap, no wonder the job seekers are trying to do everything in their power to navigate what they perceive are the blockers or the, maybe the boss that are trying to keep them from getting an applicant, getting an interview.
[00:03:48] And so we were trying to understand, you know, from the recruiters perspective and from the job seekers, what is their actual experience? So, um, ton of, um, applications, you open a job and before you know it, you'll have more than 300 applications on average. Yeah. Our data showing us that the report says so too. Um, we know from the report that, um, applicants are saying we are using AI in, in our job search.
[00:04:15] 88% of them are saying we use AI in our job search. And we know that we have to do this because we know that recruiters are using AI in screening applications and screening us out. So it's like AI fighting AI in the job application. She believes it's, it's going to be real. It's going to be bots and bots. Well, but that 88%, I read that and I was like blown away. Like we are in the worst market. Like she thinks it's 2022.
[00:04:44] I think it's right now. It's like, it's right now. It's like it is happening because candidates are experiencing things in a such a different way than 2022. Yeah. Like we weren't experiencing this, right? It's never been harder to find a job. Like let's be very clear. It is hard to find a job. And then if you think about recruiting teams being really pressured, they're lean, they don't have all the resources that they need. And so they open a job and all of a sudden the flood starts. So what are they going to do?
[00:05:13] They can't spend every waking minutes screening everything. They need tools to be able to do that. So, you know, I'm in an industry where we're putting a lot of AI into these tools. And the question is, how do we actually create an experience for candidates that they feel seen? Number one, they feel that they've gotten a fair shake. Like they have at least some communication, you know, at this moment looking for a job is like speaking into the black hole.
[00:05:40] Like you put your stuff in there and you don't hear anything back. And then it is very expressly tell us that they know that companies are using AI, but companies are not saying it. So 78% of those recruits, those candidates are saying we are using AI. If you just tell us what you would like to have us do or be honest about how you are using AI ourselves, then it will set our expectations and we will feel that you are more honest and you're
[00:06:10] being more open to what you're actually doing. So that's the same. There's receptivity. Candidates don't feel like companies shouldn't be using AI. They hate it when companies use AI in a bad way. And many companies are using AI in a bad way. They're like, you know, you do your application at six o'clock in the evening and six or three, you get the rejection. Like that is automated screening. That is quick matching. And suddenly there's AI that's made a decision. That is bad AI.
[00:06:39] That is not right in terms of how the company is doing it, but it's also not fair on the job seeker. And the challenge, we were talking about bot versus bot just now. You know, the process of hiring is basically one of understanding whether the applicant matches what the role is needing to do. And we call that signal. And so the higher quality or the stronger the signal, the more likely that that application will be successful.
[00:07:06] When a recruiter uses AI to post a job and a candidate uses AI to customize their resume for that job, what happens? Signal goes away. Because the job looks, the resume looks exactly like what the job is looking for. Now a recruiter has 500 candidates who all look the same. How are they going to make that decision? And this is where we think the evolution of hiring is really going to play out. The resume is dead. It's awesome.
[00:07:34] The resume is dead because it does not carry enough of the signal that a candidate can say, this is me. This is my professional experience. Here's how I can stand out. Here's why I want this job. Here's why I would be good in that job. And we believe as Greenhouse that we need to fix this broken process. And it isn't just by white-funting, you know, it's not just by applying, being at the top of the queue. It's not these like, it's not just referrals.
[00:08:04] It's fundamentally revisiting the overall way that candidates are applying for jobs. Yeah. I definitely think that. I can shut up now. No. No. Go forever. No, I definitely think whenever we think of the implementation of AI, how it all impacts one another. So we talk about all the time. Eventually, what's been the norm of the one-page resume is going to become a 67-page resume if it's all based off hot words. Oh my God.
[00:08:28] If it's all based off of how much you match on the 2 plus 2 plus 4 equals algorithm that is doing the AI filtering, then you have to add up to that. And so people are going to be changing that. And so people are going to be changing that. But also, one thing that you mentioned was 7% of them get interviews. Oh. I have a kind of curiosity about that data set only because now we have so many more applications. So it shrinks that number to 7. Whenever you used to, you would only have like 100 applicants.
[00:08:56] And so I am almost curious if it's the same ratio of candidates being sent through the funnel. Because if it's 7%, but now we've upped it to 500, it's probably still the same amount of candidates going through. Or are you all looking through it holistically full funnel? The gating factor has always been the bandwidth of the recruiter. Okay. They can only do so much. Correct.
[00:09:18] And so what percentage of the volume of applications that they're going to be screening, will they have the capacity to actually filter or screen? So I think the percentage has actually reduced over time. Okay. Because the recruiting team size has reduced. And so you have twice or three times as much volume, and you have maybe one recruiter doing six or seven jobs. It's going to be hard.
[00:09:43] Unless you can put effective AI on it, the percentage of applications that get screened is not going to be meaningfully in more. And that's one of the reasons why we believe putting better AI at the top of the funnel, potentially actually giving more candidates the opportunity to actually have a voice interview, as opposed to just sending a resume. And the reason I say that I think that we can affect the 7% when we actually change the way that we learn about the candidates.
[00:10:13] Correct. I agree. If you have AI that can actually be applied, and you invite every candidate in your funnel to say, we are going to ask you to have a conversation with AI. You can do it whenever you want. You can do it in the middle of the night, if that's convenient to you. But when that screening happens, you get to tell your story more comprehensively than what is on your resume.
[00:10:37] That conversation is structured because it follows what it is that I'm looking for as the hiring manager. So it's got a scorecard. It's got like, how does this candidate perform? How did the interview actually yield the outcome that says to me how this candidate would match up to the attributes, the skills, the capabilities that we're looking for? And then that data gets given to the recruiter. If the recruiter now looks at this information and goes, oh my God, look at how much I've learned.
[00:11:05] I've got a score in terms of how strong this candidate actually matches what I'm looking for that can make a much faster and more informed decision to say, oh, I want to have the next interview with this candidate. So I think that we have an opportunity to actually affect what happens at the top of the funnel when we employ technology better. Yeah. And then rather than just relying on the human because I know she wants this mic back so bad.
[00:11:35] I'm going to ask one more question and I'm going to give it all to her and she's going to run away with it. But one of the questions that I have, because on the internal side, one thing that I've seen a ton with my clients, which I probably shouldn't be saying this, but I'm going to is internally whenever they write these job descriptions, they're not great. So whenever we talk about signals and using that as a goalpost to create the signaling, it's almost a false flag 99% of the time because the JD is written with the hoopla.
[00:12:02] So how do y'all work with your companies internally to make sure that we're actually testing the proper signals that we're actually targeting reliability and validity with the persona that we're looking for?
[00:12:16] The fundamental way to get that is to take a structured approach to hiring. This is what greenhouse has been like. This has been our Bible for 15 years because the reason why those job descriptions look the way they do is because there is no clear alignment and discussion between the hiring manager and the recruiter. What are we looking for? What would good look like in this role? What are the skills and attributes that you really want in this candidate?
[00:12:42] If you spend even just five minutes doing that and you develop the scorecard against that, then you can actually give it to AI and go, this is what we're looking for. Here's what a good answer sounds like. Here's what a not good answer sounds like. These are the core capabilities. If you get from a structured perspective, you get that initial plan and definition right, then you can actually apply technology to more of the process because it's coming from this agreed template.
[00:13:12] Right. And many companies don't believe it. This is the way to do it. Absolutely. So I'm going to wrap it back to you a little bit because this is super interesting to me. I was on the recruitment marketing side. I love brand and marketing. It's like brand experience.
[00:13:27] Yeah. So in this world of crazy that we live in right now, how do you as a CMO, like take this on and say, we need to earn the trust. Like, how do you create that in a world that looks like this? I'm super interested.
[00:13:47] You know what? The answer is not hard. Really? The answer is clear, proactive, transparent communication. Like seriously, it is so basic. If you think about in all this AI and everything, the candidate experience is still essentially the most critical denominator. Right.
[00:14:04] And so you sit there and you go, okay, so what do we want our candidates to experience when they first apply the job? When they first come to us and like they're on our website, what do we want them to know? We want them to know about the job, obviously, but we want them to learn how we're going to treat them. So we actually have, and I will use greenhouse as an example.
[00:14:23] We have content on our careers page that says, what do we do? How do we use AI? How we think you should be using AI and what you can expect from this process. Let's text on a website. It is like really easy to do. But what that does is it tells the candidate that the brand has thought about them and what that experience is going to be. So that's step one, really important, proactive information. Then you think about the candidate experience and you go, okay, from the minute that you're going to be a good job, you're going to be a good job.
[00:14:53] You're going to be a good job. Now you're going to be a good job. Now you're going to be a good job. Now you're anxious. You are wondering, are you going to hear back? What if you just set up your system in a way that at these critical milestones, the communication will simply say, we are likely to be in this process for two weeks. We are going to get back to you. It might not be tomorrow, but here's what you can expect. These are systems letters that you could set up. They are not very difficult. And by the way, you can write them like a human to a human.
[00:15:22] Right. As opposed to like, dear, bot, bot. The bar is very low. The bar is low. It's very low. This is where I feel AI highlights the fracture in the human process because now we perfectly have the capabilities to do all those things at scale, at mass scale, to put those things in. And we still know.
[00:15:39] You can time it. You can schedule it. You can do all the things. There is no candidate that needs to sit and wonder what's going to happen. You know, obviously hiring is an anxious process. Like everyone wants a role. There's very little that you could really do to take that out of it. But we believe fundamentally that the best candidate experience comes from our recruiting team calls it the no update update. I'm just, if a candidate is in the pipe, I'm going to send you, Hey, I'm touching base. I just want you all to know. Please do it right now.
[00:16:07] Exactly. Just the no update update. Hey, I'm just touching base. And you could do that via email. You could do that via text. There's so many ways. And then of course, I think that there's one more thing. I'm still on your answer to your question. No, no. I love it.
[00:16:22] That the hiring manager has an active role and responsibility in this thing. Yeah. I mean, it's not just, Hey, go get me a person. Right. It's like, I want somebody to join my team. What am I going to do? Can I be a talent maker? And so when I'm a talent maker, the way I brief the recruiter is one responsibility. Second one is I might record a little video. Hey, this is the role I'm looking for. Here's the kind of person I would love for you to apply. Immediately you begin to get a sense of what it's going to be like.
[00:16:51] What is the role you're going to do? And so what would I like to work with this hiring manager? Those are all golden moments. And so if a candidate goes through that process and they have this experience and they have had the communication, even if they don't get the job, they feel respected in that process. And so they leave that going, I didn't get it, but this is a good brand. And they'll keep monitoring. Brand, brand, brand, brand, brand. Exactly. 100%. I have been rejected from jobs in the most beautiful way. And I'm like, I love this brand. Yeah.
[00:17:19] Oh no, there's only one person that can get hired. Good for you. Good for you. I love that so much. And I believe that AI is, I love AI. It's a thing. I am a solopreneur and I don't think I could get all the things done in a day that I get done with AI. But what I do think, I am my own. It's me and Claudia doing things. I have made Claudine also. Oh! She speaks with a very French accent. Oh! Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[00:17:49] Boom. I love that. I love that. How are you dressed today? I wonder if Claudine is doing things. But I do believe what Ashley said, that in the world of AI, what it did do was bring out all the inefficiencies that we should have been able to take care of.
[00:18:30] It's very true. Like, why not? The nightmares that people go through to actually try to get a thing scheduled. There are places all along this journey that I think it is ripe for complete reimagining because of AI. And so we have this one thought at Greenhouse and that is, we think, A, we need to eradicate the use of poor AI or bad AI.
[00:18:54] But number two, we think that hiring is ripe for like a radical rethink because it doesn't need to happen quite the way that it is right now. We agree. So two things that I think you really hit on here. So at Talent Ed, we call it talent infrastructure and we feel most companies lack that and their inability to do so many things such as even follow ups for managers. They don't have SLAs in place. They don't have expectations in place. Clear communication on that.
[00:19:23] Or even interview training maybe? And so they lack talent infrastructure and then they automate what's broken or they put artificial intelligence already on top of it. Not just productivity, right? Correct. And so it breaks things that are already so broken. So broken. Well, it's an interesting thing. In this AI era, the most fundamental thing is to go back to the core human experience, right?
[00:19:47] And then you look at that and you go, okay, now how do we reimagine this? How do we actually put AI in place that can actually sort of not only bridge, but fundamentally shift? Yes. And that's the key part. So whenever you have that solid talent infrastructure, you can now actually start, we call it hiring based on outcomes. Yes. Which is essentially what happens when we don't have resumes anymore that can provide signals because now we're adhering to AI bots and what we think they want.
[00:20:15] And so we've altered essentially the whole entire job search process, the apply path, all of these different things to where it doesn't, it never adds up anymore. We're all just wasting water from data centers on AI circles that we've created. So kind of that, by having that infrastructure, you can do hiring based off of outcomes, which is bringing it back to that core. Because that's how we used to hire. We used to assess people based off of how they would actually perform in the role.
[00:20:42] But now it is, talk to me about how you could perform in the role, maybe. And we judge it based off of their delivery, their content, how well they are at speaking. And none of those are necessarily indicators on how they would actually perform this job. And so it's just interesting how much AI we've added and how far we've gone in one direction. When in reality, you're right, we have to come back to the essence and to the core. There's something there that you said that I just want to, we've been speaking a lot about the recruiting process,
[00:21:12] but there's also something that needs reimagining in the job search process itself. Oh, I agree. You know, and so what we have done, we started to realize that we can't solve any of our employers' problems if we also don't address the job seeker problem. And the way that job seekers are trying to find a job is just so miserable. So we've been building, we've been building a kind of a, I want to say a home for job search, which is My Greenhouse. It's called My Greenhouse.
[00:21:40] And the thing that we're trying to do is to invite job seekers to come and sign up and do a profile on My Greenhouse. Tell us a little bit about you. Yes, you can upload your resume, but we want to know extra things. We want to know like what kind of environment is the best, brings out the best in you. Are you a remote person or do you want to be in like in office? There's all this additional information that actually is the context of you as a human.
[00:22:06] And so we believe that if we could create a place, a portal where job seekers can actually say, here I am, I'm looking for these kinds of jobs. We actually make jobs visible to job seekers and we give them a thing, which is a little extra piece of signal. We call it My Dream Job. And so once a month, by the way, I have done this thing. Yes. You know, we have had 88,000 job seekers who've done My Dream Job.
[00:22:35] And 5,000 of them have actually landed their job. It's actually wonderful. Why? Because the recruiter looks at this and goes, this person is sending a signal of intent. They really want this job. And you're like, it rises to the top of that recruiter's list to interview and screen. And so we're trying to close the distance between where the recruiter is trying to do a good job, but where the job seeker is trying to be there in the moment and see me for who I am.
[00:23:03] And when you do it, you have to say why, right? Absolutely. You have to say why this is your dream job, which is different than like, hey, this is my cool resume and I did all these things. Right. It's like, here's why I really want to work for Greenhouse. This company, right. Whatever company it is, you have to like put it in there and you have to think about that because now you can't write AI. Like, is it reads AI at that point?
[00:23:24] Do you know that in the study that we just did, I do not remember the exact percentage, but job seekers are telling us that they are now looking through their resume, trying to sound more like a human. I mean, isn't that the most crazy thing? They were moving the end dash. They were like, you know, so you still see the desperation. And so what can we do to make the signal stronger and give more people access to the signal?
[00:23:50] So in our ecosystem, we basically want to bring job seekers closer in, recruiters and hiring managers closer in and have the act of hiring happen in one place. So if we could orchestrate all of that, it takes the misery out. It closes the distance and it increases the speed or the chance of you actually being, you know, in the right place at the right time for the right job. I love it. Thank you so much for joining us today. Please do any plugs you need for Greenhouse right now. Send people to the right places.
[00:24:20] I would say if you want to do the right, if you want to hire in the right way, you've got to check out Greenhouse and just go to our website, greenhouse.com and structured hiring. Desiree out. Thank you. Mike job. Thank you so much, Karen, for doing this.


