Organizational Psychology vs HR: What Each Field Gets Right About People at Work
The HR HubNovember 17, 202600:23:54

Organizational Psychology vs HR: What Each Field Gets Right About People at Work

Organizational psychology and HR work side by side, but they have different priorities. Dr. Ehsan Etezad, organizational psychologist and co-founder and CEO of MEUS Science, explains what organizational psychology is, how it differs from HR, and what HR can borrow from it to build safe, happy and productive workplaces. Key takeaways: - Organizational psychology works at three levels: explaining behaviour at work, predicting it, and influencing it. Influencing behaviour, such as getting crews to wear safety gear, is the most complex. - The goal is a workplace that is safe, happy and productive. Remove any one of the three and the organization runs into trouble. - Organizational psychologists coach leaders on how they lead. Clinical concerns go to a clinician or the EAP. - Ehsan would retire the annual performance rating and replace it with frequent, future-focused "feed forward" conversations. - Reward the things people control, such as effort and preparation, and design rewards for the job: what motivates a sales team can damage a creative team. - Progressive discipline is sound in principle. Problems come from setting people up to fail and from using the process to build a case for termination. 00:00 HR vs. organizational psychology 00:54 What is organizational psychology? 01:19 Explain, predict and influence behaviour 02:56 Getting workers to wear safety gear 04:05 How organizational psychology differs from HR 05:04 Safe, happy and productive employees 06:16 Do organizational psychologists counsel employees? 09:16 What organizational psychologists get hired for 10:05 Why large organizations need surveys 11:10 The HR practice to retire 12:17 Feed forward instead of feedback 14:26 Performance ratings and compensation 15:34 How to decide merit increases 17:20 Sales teams versus creative teams 18:16 Is progressive discipline still useful? 20:16 Setting people up for success 21:36 Fix the system, not the person 22:58 Where to find Ehsan **Find Ehsan** Website: https://withmeus.com/ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ehsanetezad/ Book titles or other links: Weekly Performance Science newsletter: https://withmeus.com/newsletter/ | Personal website: https://ehsanetezad.com/ **Find Andrea** Website: https://thehrhub.ca/ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/andrea-adams1/

Powered by the WRKdefined Podcast Network. 

[00:00:00] So, HR and Organizational Psychology. Are we the same, overlapping, totally different? What is Organizational Psychology and what can we learn from it? That whole conversation is coming up now. I'm Andrea Adams and today on the The HR Hub we have Dr. Ahsan Adizad. Dr. Ahsan is an Organizational Psychologist. He's the co-founder and CEO of Me Us Science,

[00:00:31] which helps organizations build healthy, high-performing workplaces. Hi Ahsan, how are you? Hi, very happy to be here. Thank you, Andrea. Well, thank you for coming on. Okay, so I appreciate you doing this episode. I'm sure you study things that are far more sophisticated than what is Organizational Psychology, but I bet a lot of people are curious. So what is it and what kind of problems does it solve?

[00:00:58] Redd ish and I think the one sentence description of it is Organizational Psychology is the science of people at work. That's the one version. But the way I like to describe it is that Organizational Psychology comes with three different levels of understanding of people at work. The first level is just understanding and explaining human behavior at work. What does that mean? It means that, imagine

[00:01:21] there is a leader, there's a manager who after a teamwork, he steals credit from other people. He doesn't give them credit. So what happens is that people stop working hard because they say, well, all work is not seen or we are not getting credit. So just understanding and explaining what happens, that's level one. Level two is predicting what would be the outcome behavior in a specific

[00:01:48] set of circumstances. What does that mean? An example of it is that at the second level, you say, okay, I know there's a leader. He's very good at tanking people and saying, I appreciate you for going above and beyond. And what is going to happen next when there's another opportunity that people need to go above and beyond for this leader? So you predict that they got to do the same because they got appreciated the first time that they did that, right? That's the prediction

[00:02:15] level. And the third level of organizational psychology is the level of influence, which means how would you influence and change is the rate of behavior, a desired behavior at work. So what is the example of that? Imagine you have a team, they're not motivated, nobody comes up with any new ideas. So what is the fix? What's the solution? How can we change that, right? Or from the safety point of view, imagine you have a construction company, it's the construction site, and people don't

[00:02:44] wear their hard hat, they don't wear the safety equipment. How you want to intervene, how you want to influence them, and how you want to change that behavior. So these are all examples that comes at these three levels. I also want to know, how do you actually, like that's a real problem, like the safety performance? You know, you have the stick, right? But then you show up and, you know, you peek around a corner

[00:03:12] or something, and there they are, they're not wearing it because it's uncomfortable or whatever. How do you get them to wear their hard hats, or their respirator, or whatever it is? It's a case by case, right? You need to know the organization, you know, you need to know the leader, you know, you need to know the perception of the employees who are there, you don't need to know what is the dynamic in that workplace. And I think that's where the complexity of organizational psychology

[00:03:37] comes. Because at the first level of just understanding what's going on, that's easy, because you're observing. The second level of predicting what's going on, that becomes a bit tricky. But to your point, when you want to influence and change people's behavior, that's the level that has the most amount of complexity. Because we know humans are complicated, and you have to consider a lot of different factors before coming with a plan that can change their people's

[00:04:03] behavior. How is organizational psychology different than HR? Because, I mean, we don't do just that, the understanding, predicting, and influencing behavior. But we do do a lot of that. One of the HR and organizational psychology really are hand in hand, and they're really complementary disciplines that they help each other. But they have a different priority system. HR runs a lot of

[00:04:32] systems, procedures every day, from hiring to pay to policy, employee relation, union connections, you know, like making sure the compliance aspects are there. So there's a lot of those aspects that HR is involved with every day. But organizational psychology, the level of priority there is around why things work, how can we measure that the way they work, and how we can sort of influence and

[00:04:57] change the procedures, you know, sort of the reasoning behind why a program is successful, and how about we can take away from it. And one thing maybe to highlight is, when it comes to organizational psychology, the ultimate goal, like the North Star is to have employees that are safe, happy, and productive. So if we can have a triangle of safe, happy, and productive,

[00:05:22] that's sort of the goal that organizational psychology wants to work toward. Because if you have employees that are safe and happy, but they're not productive, that's probably not the, that's not why their business exists in the first place, right? You're going to be a bankrupt, happy and safe workplace. Right. But if you are also safe and productive, but people are not happy, you're going to have attrition problem, people are going to leave, people are not going to enjoy their job. And on the other hand, if you have a happy and productive workplace, but people come

[00:05:52] in with two arms and two legs, and they leave losing their arm and their leg, like that's also not the way that organization is supposed to exist, right? Nobody wants to go to work, say, oh, I may lose a finger today. Right. So this is sort of the goal we pursue in organizational psychology is to create that work environment that people are safe, happy, and productive, or at least in my opinion, that's how I would look at it. Okay, this is probably a dumb question,

[00:06:18] but as an organization, and this is like really at the heart of what organizational psychology is, it's psychology. Do you counsel employees? So counseling employees? No, it's not our main job. And if someone needs therapy, the right move is to make a referral to a clinician or add the workplace environment to their EAP, EFAP program that they would be able to offer those.

[00:06:44] But organizational psychologists do a lot of leadership and executive coaching and training. So if it's a coaching conversation, and if it's a sort of a helping a leader, it's mostly focused and targeted on how they lead, not the leader themselves. So we never been in a conversation with a leader, we ask how we want to create a more high performance team, but we never say to a leader,

[00:07:12] let's talk about your mom and the relationship you had with dad. Like this is not a conversation you're going to have with your organizational psychologist, but we got to talk about how do you motivate your team? How do you manage a meeting to make sure everyone's heard? How do you show your respect to your team? And how do you expect to receive that? So the conversations are more about how you show up at work, not who you are deep down as a like a person.

[00:07:37] What if your like relationship with your dad, or mom is impacting how you're showing up? I mean, how you can't really pull these things apart. Oh yeah, it absolutely does. Absolutely does. Like, I mean, every leader show up with their own insecurity, with their own vulnerabilities, right? And they all have it and it influenced the way they

[00:08:00] lead. But I think if it comes to a level that it stops them from being productive, right? So like what we define for clinical psychology is if it influence your functionality, then you need to seek professional help, right? So if you can't sleep, or if you get panic attack, or if you sort of completely are disoriented, that that's where the clinicians, counselors, clinical psychologists, EAP programs, they can come in and they can offer you the help that you need.

[00:08:32] But our zone of competence is people who are functional. So they wake up fine, they go to bed fine. And in the middle, they want to just know how to be a more effective leader. And I think the most leaders like maybe 90% are in that zone, right? They're very high performers, but they just want to know how they can do better or how they can improve their sleep, improve their stress management,

[00:08:56] prevent burnout. But it's not that they are like, can be diagnosed, diagnosed with anything clinical, right? They're fairly healthy people. Okay, okay. As a clinic, as a sorry, I was about to say as a clinical psychologist, huh? As an organizational psychologist, what is some of the most common projects you're going to take on? Like, what do you get hired to do?

[00:09:25] Mm-hmm. Very good question. So it's, it's a wide range of things. You never know, like when people email you and says, can I pick up your brain? You never know exactly what type of project they got to ride you. But it's a lot of training. It's a lot of leadership training, a stress management training that I personally do. It's a lot of coaching or executive facilitation. Sometimes if an organization wants to come up with their charter for their culture, like how are we

[00:09:51] behaving in this organization? What are our values in this organization? So that comes with a lot of executive facilitation or around this strategy, right? If they want to do their strat planning, their strategy planning, that comes also with a lot of facilitation. Another aspect is probably we get hired to do a lot of surveys, you know? I know people hate surveys, but here's the thing. I always explain to people that if you're an organization with 10 employees, you don't need survey. You just walk

[00:10:18] down the hallway and you see if people are laughing or not, and you know how your organizations, how your employees are feeling. But if you have 10,000 employees in 10 different locations, you have no way of knowing what's going on unless you do these surveys. So that's the big portion of what we do in terms of those psychological assessment that comes into play at a scale. When you have 10,000,

[00:10:44] 100,000 employees, what do you want to do, right? You cannot just like rely on the narratives or the signals that come to the boardroom. And also the last one is working with associations on a lot of toolkit development or advising on policies they have just to create more resources for people to make sure they are safer, happier and more productive. Okay, so I have some pet questions.

[00:11:09] Okay. So from the perspective of an organizational psychologist who studied organizations, what's one HR practice you think we need to get rid of? Okay, here's the thing. There are probably a lot of things that we do that historically it worked, but it doesn't work anymore. But if I want to choose one that really we need to get rid of it is the traditional annual performance review models we have.

[00:11:39] The once a year rating that the supervisor and the employee sit across each other and they say, let me, there are six items that I need to rank you from one to five based on what you did last year. So for example, I don't know your level of project delivery, excellence. Should I give you a five or should I give you a four? That's just waste of hours. That doesn't lead to anything helpful. And it's a

[00:12:04] very unfair practice too, because we know there are some managers who give five to everyone and there are some managers who give two to everyone. And they say, if you get a three out of me, that's the best you can get. And that's just not fair and it's not helpful to organizations. And in terms of the alternative, what I would suggest that comes from a research that happened at Stanford is to use a feed

[00:12:30] forward model instead of feedback. What does that mean? The feed forward model is that encourage more often conversations between the supervisor and the employees to talk about the future solution focus rather than feedback being blame focus and talk about what can be achieved rather than talking about

[00:12:52] what has happened already. And also it's a faster process because you get together and you say, okay, what do we need to do to make sure you can do your job better in the next quarter rather than talking to the employees? Because maybe for a lot of people who are not aware of it, the feedback session, sometimes it becomes very toxic and discouraging for employees because you go in and they say, first of all,

[00:13:19] the managers don't even remember what you did the last year, right? They just remember like five events happening that is like highlighted in their brain. If they have like 20 people reporting to them, they have no idea about the whole thing, right? So all of a sudden they tell you, I remember that you were not doing this part right. And automatically what that creates, that accusation, the employee feel the resistance. They want to sort of come back. And then what they do

[00:13:48] is that they direct it at someone else. I said, no, no, no, my part was ready. I was waiting for another department. It's their fault. I did everything perfectly. And the whole thing happened like nine months ago. So you can keep wrestling. You can keep like saying what happened nine months ago, but it's very useless to talk about something that happened nine months ago. Because if this conversation was helpful, it should have been a briefing at the time to say what we learned from

[00:14:15] it. Not right now after nine months, right? So I would definitely change these feedback once your traditional annual performance review, and I would change it with feed forward. And you can add the elements because I know a lot of HR experts they're hearing this. They say, no, but we use performance review to justify promotion. We use it to justify if we want to let go of someone. It's a very critical

[00:14:38] number in the system. And we use it for compensation. We use it for compensation. And that's actually when they tell me that I'm like, these are all the reason we need to get rid of it because it's unfair and it's not consistent. And it really depends if the manager having a good day or a bad day and using it that number for influencing pay and compensation is just unfair. Like it just

[00:15:04] doesn't make sense. So I think connecting those variables to something that truly matters, not something that is easy to measure, right? Because a lot of times I think in HR measurements, we default into what's accessible to measure, not what's the right thing to measure. So measuring the wrong things, I think it's one of the problems, like fundamental problems that all HR departments are dealing with to different extents.

[00:15:34] Yeah. Okay. I have to ask, then how should we measure, like how should we make decisions on merit increases for compensation? Yeah, it's a big question and depends on the job. You know, like, I mean, I want to keep this conversation super practical for people, but I want to also tell them it so depends on the job, right? So like a retail environment is very different from a law firm. It's very different

[00:15:59] from a creative agency, right? You can never reward creative people, let's say for the number of hours you spend because sometimes they may come up with the best idea in 30 minutes. Someone else, it may take 30 hours. Like you cannot control it that way. But in general sense, as much as you can find a way that are more outcome and output driven, but also at the same time, focus on things that are within the

[00:16:27] areas of people control, like within their area of control. So what is the example of that? Let's say we want to reward and compensate NBA players, right? Don't reward them based on how many, like three pointers they score in the game, because that's outside their control, right? But you can reward them based on how many days they show up in practice at the training, right? Because that's within their

[00:16:53] control and how much they're giving their true best effort when they are sort of practicing. Because in the real game, who wins, who loses, that's just millions of factors coming to play. So choosing things that are within people's control motivates people to put that behavior forward and it increases the rate of that desired behavior. And it's job specific. Super job specific, right? Honestly,

[00:17:22] like if you have a sales department, the way you treat them has to be different when you're treating a creative, like your graphic designers. You cannot try to build on competition in a creative department. It's going to be so toxic so quickly. But salespeople, they already want to compete. Like they have it in their nature. You cannot tell them, you know, they're more competitive by nature and the job and the

[00:17:48] compensation, the commission, like the whole structure is around competition. But imagine you bring the same model and want to apply for people who want to design games. They want to design creative products. They want to design a packaging. Like it's just going to ruin it. Like nothing good is going to come out of that department if you treat them the same. Like I guarantee that, you know? Oh yes. Okay. I could ask so many more questions. Okay. Another pet question.

[00:18:18] What do you think of progressive discipline? It's like a, it's like a fundamental everlasting process in HR and does it do anything? I mean, it's not going away, but anyways, what do you think of it? Yeah, it's a good question. You know, I think it's one of those things that you, you can't live with it, but you don't, can't live without it either.

[00:18:47] Totally. Totally. We have to rely on it because we don't have any better alternative, but I'll tell you this, the foundation of progressive discipline is correct, right? People need to know what is the expected behavior. So this is very important. People need to know what is the expected behavior. People need to know what happens if they deviate from that expected behavior, like in terms of the procedure, right? Yeah.

[00:19:16] And the discipline has to be consistent for everyone who deviate. So that's another part because and I'm emphasizing because it's not how it actually goes in practice sometimes. And it has to offer people a right to appeal and sort of argue their case all the time, right? So these are foundations of it. It's fabulous. It's great. Like it's the only way that makes sense because you don't want to like,

[00:19:44] like a small deviant matter to behavior, deviant matters, but you also don't want to fire people on a whim, right? That just doesn't make sense either. So the foundation of it is great. The place that I think it goes wrong, it's not about progressive discipline. It's about leadership styles, and it's about people using it and weaponizing it for their own purpose of building up a case for determination.

[00:20:10] So what I would say is that if someone comes to me and says, should we get rid of it? I say no. But a lot of the problems and a lot of the issues we have with that is because the management styles are not supportive. So what happens is we have organizations that they have these made up expectations, but they

[00:20:35] haven't set up their people for success. And actually there are ones that they set up people for failure, right? Yeah. Imagine you, let's just say somebody is an accountant, right? And they're a good accountant. So all of a sudden you say, hmm, you're such a good accountant. Let's, let's promote you to the vice president of finance. It's exciting, right? Everyone says, whoa, so such a good news. But if you don't give

[00:21:01] this person the leadership, like teaching and the expectation, the new challenges, because the job of running a finance department is very different from just being an accountant, like it's two different world, right? And if you just promote this person to that position, what's going to happen? It's just going to be complaint after complaint after complaint after complaint, because this is not something that

[00:21:28] they were ready for, they were not set up for the success in this new role. Now, this is just a more glorified, beautiful example, but we do that in a lot of different cases. We say, oh, you know, there was like this case of let's say violence in the workplace, but every factor of violence was present and nobody did anything, you know? People are drinking after their shift. So there was alcohol involved. People have

[00:21:57] access to like, like cash being around, like people are already frustrated. You know, you look at some industries, like restaurant, hospitality industry, they have a lot of like alcohol related problems, right? So like there's a lot of factor that you can control in the environment so that it's not in a past that everyone who gets that job, because it's not about one or two bad apples. It's like you

[00:22:23] have a system that creates these problems and you need to fix the system, not just point at one person and says, oh, they were really bad. No, the process is very bad. Such a good point. And yes, the restaurant and hospitality industry, it's crazy. Yeah. Okay. If someone in the audience, I think worked there, they're going to nod heavily when we talk

[00:22:50] about like the challenges that comes from that and the discipline process, because you cannot just keep firing people. Right. Right. Okay. If someone wants to learn more about organizational psychology or find you, what do you suggest? Yes. So I have a newsletter called Weekly Performance Science. They can find a newsletter and I think the link will be included in the description of the video as well. But there are 16,000 leaders who I send weekly emails every Tuesday to them. So you can join the

[00:23:19] list and you can also find me on LinkedIn, Instagram, YouTube, and all the good places. Well, thanks, Ahsan. That was excellent. Like actually so many great tips in there and uh, in principles. And then what I'm thinking about is that we're trying to create a safe, happy, and productive workplace. And with any one of those missing, you know, it's a three-legged stool. You're

[00:23:45] going to fall over. Um, I've done other episodes actually with the organizational psychologists. So one of those is right here. Um, thanks for watching out there. See you next time.