Why are companies holding off on hiring, and what should HR do next? Host Joey Price speaks with Joseph Mayans, chief economist at Experian North America, about how AI adoption and economic uncertainty affect hiring, why low unemployment can hide longer job searches, and what employees staying put out of caution means for retention. Mara Nicholl of Experian Employer Services discusses how HR teams can keep compliance practices consistent across systems, vendors, and processes. Learn what these trends mean for workforce planning, employee engagement, and evaluating AI's role in business growth. This episode is sponsored by Experian Employer Services.
Key Takeaways
- Employers may postpone hiring while testing whether AI can handle additional work.
- Low unemployment can mask a weaker labor market when fewer people are seeking work.
- College-educated job seekers and new graduates can face hiring barriers as employers reassess staffing needs.
- Employees staying in their jobs out of caution does not necessarily indicate satisfaction or engagement.
- HR teams can respond to job hugging by strengthening recognition and understanding employee needs.
- Evaluate whether AI can support business growth alongside employees when considering staffing decisions.
- Look beyond headline economic figures to understand which industries are investing and adding jobs.
- Keep compliance changes consistent across HR platforms, vendors, and internal processes.
- Pair automation with trusted guidance and organized records to support compliance and audit preparation.
Timestamps
00:00 – Why employers are waiting to hire
03:00 – Uneven investment and data center growth
04:00 – Why low unemployment can be misleading
06:00 – Job hugging and employee engagement
07:00 – Why white collar job searches are harder
08:00 – How AI uncertainty affects hiring decisions
09:00 – Limited hiring and concentrated job growth
11:00 – Using AI to grow alongside employees
12:00 – Keeping compliance consistent across HR systems
13:00 – Finding trusted compliance guidance
Keywords
AI hiring slowdown, hiring pause, economic uncertainty, workforce planning, white collar job market, entry level hiring, job hugging, employee retention, AI in HR, HR compliance
AI and Economic Uncertainty in Recruiting
Workforce Planning and Compliance for HR Leaders
Visit Jumpstart HR and Jumpstart HR Research
Purchase Joey's latest book "The Power of HR: How to Make an Organizational Impact as a People Professional"
Learn more about our episode sponsor: Experian Employer Services
Powered by the WRKdefined Podcast Network.
[00:00:00] What AI is doing at the moment is just causing employers to take a pause, see what AI can do. Maybe they're just initiating it. Maybe they've gone through a couple rounds using AI, seeing how they're actually getting some tangible benefits, and just saying, let's hold off on hiring another FTE right now, especially if we're not so sure what the economy is going to do over the next couple of years. Let's just see what AI can do. But that has meaningful impact for if you're a new grad, you're entering the workforce, it's very difficult to get a job.
[00:00:28] If you read the headlines today, there's a lot of conversation happening around employment, data centers, and so many other dinner table conversations that impact your job as an HR leader, whether you know it or not. In this episode brought to you by Experian Employer Services, we actually get to sit down with Joseph Mayans, who's a chief economist at Experian North America, to talk about how those dinner conversations actually translates into what you should be doing at work.
[00:00:58] We also get an opportunity to hear from Mara Nichols, who stops by for us to talk about what life is like as an employee at Experian Employer Services, and what she's excited about for all the things that's happening at Experian. So without further ado, let's get into the show. You led a session at HR Tech Conference at the HRE Strategist Summit, and you gave an outlook on the economy. Was it a good outlook, bad outlook, somewhere in between?
[00:01:28] Don't give us the rosy picture. Give us the honest picture, because I want honesty in this conversation today. Absolutely, Joey Price. So I'll give you the honest picture. So I'll say this. As an economist, I primarily work in the financial services industry. I'm talking to a lot of chief risk officers, chief lenders, lending officers. So that's how I think about it. What does the economic impact mean for lenders at the end? But in between that piece, very much what's happening with the labor market, right?
[00:01:57] You don't want to lend to somebody probably who doesn't have a job, or may not have a job down the road. But I think that ties in very well with the HR space, thinking about where the labor market may go. So overall picture, I tend to be more optimistic than most economists. Over the last five years, especially in my space, what I like to focus on, you had the Russian invasion of Ukraine. You had the Federal Reserve raising interest rates, 500 basis points. You had the regional bank crisis. You had all the tariff announcements. Then you had the war in Iran.
[00:02:25] And through that, I have been, like I said, more optimistic. Many economists in my field, they've called for recessions along the way. I've never done so. And there's a couple of reasons why, and I'll talk about that in a moment. But things have shifted a little bit this year, I think. I've become a little more cautious generally about the outlook. And there's a couple of reasons. If you look overall broadly in the economy, if you read the Wall Street Journal, if you look to the Federal Reserve when they released their minutes and their projections, generally you're going to see a fairly optimistic take.
[00:02:55] Economic growth for most economists. The economy is supposed to expand between 2% and 2.5% this year and next year as well. And that's about average. That's good. But when you look under the hood, there's a little more reason for concern. So if you dive into the details, one area where you can get a flavor on how the economy is actually performing is where in the industry are things being built. So if you're a manufacturer, you're confident about your industry going forward, maybe you're going to build a new plan. Yeah. To hire more people. Cranes in the sky. Exactly.
[00:03:24] Building permits, all that. Yeah. Exactly. But what you've seen really over the last 18 months, two years, since the beginning of 2025, even before that, is you have, you look at housing, for instance, residential construction, how much companies have spent to put houses in the ground. It's down. Non-resitutional construction, down. Manufacturing, down. Pretty much everywhere you look is down, except for one area. Can you guess? Data set. The Dreaded D word. Data set. Right.
[00:03:53] And so that just gives you a flavor on where the growth is happening in the economy. Obviously, AI is not driving everything, but it's a huge, it's a huge topic. So one, one thing that gives me caution is that interest rates are very high right now. And that, that tends to dampen investments and, and, and many parts of the economy. So when I look out in the future, I don't see much improvement in other areas of the economy, other than maybe the AI investment that we're seeing.
[00:04:20] There's questions on how long that can continue under the current interest rate environment, whether valuations are justified, those kinds of things. But that makes me a little bit cautious. The other thing that's flashing a little, you know, amber at me at the moment, when you look at the labor market, it's the same story. If you look at the overall unemployment rate, it's low. It's 4.2%. When you normally see that you'd say, oh, that's great. But there's a couple of reasons why that's happening, but you have way fewer immigrants looking for work.
[00:04:46] The prior administration, yeah, there are some years you had 3 million undocumented immigrants entering the country. That's supply for many industries. You have to think construction, things like that. That's true. So that's really tapered off. The other thing is you're seeing at the other end of the spectrum, 55 plus crowd, you've seen a faster pace of retirement. Some of that's just due because people with the past since COVID, 401k valuations got way up, your Schwab account's gone way up. People just feel more comfortable leaving the workforce.
[00:05:15] But there's also a contingent there that maybe if you're 55 plus, you lose a job, older workforce trying to come back in, it's very challenging. And they just say, maybe I'm just going to step out of the market. So you have some of these dynamics that on the surface, the economy looks good. The labor market looks good. But when you dive into the details, there's reasons to be cautious going forward. Additionally, when you just look at unemployment generally, even though unemployment's low, the duration of people, the length of time people are out of work continues to increase.
[00:05:45] The average is about 26 weeks now, which is also tends to be the average benefit length of benefit max for unemployment. So you're going to start seeing some, I think, additional stress with consumers. Yeah. And I think the thing I would take away as an HR leader for what you've said is get ready for a period, if you haven't already experienced, where recruiting is a little tougher and the trend of job hugging remains.
[00:06:11] So in our world, job hugging is you may not love the job, but it's a job. It beats that 26 weeks of looking for a new one. Absolutely. So people stay a climate HR leader. I'm thinking about what programs can I boost to improve recognition and what programs am I doing to really understand my workforce and how AI and technology complements the workforce that I already have. There are so many things that as HR professionals, we may read the newspaper and say, oh, that
[00:06:41] doesn't connect to what I do on a day-to-day basis. But everything that you said, Joseph, has a real world HR application. That's my take from an HR standpoint. But you started saying you were very optimistic. And then when we got into it, you said a little pessimistic. So what's the time horizon of your optimism? Is it kind of going back up? So I tend to be optimistic, become a little more pessimistic going forward.
[00:07:09] So I really think that the next two years are going to be really key. So I tend to think in the overall labor market, you can see very clearly, we've been talking past a year and a half about the white collar recession. And you're really seeing that in the data where if you're, for instance, bachelor's degree and hire individuals, they lose their job. Out of all the other educational demographics, they're having the hardest time going from unemployed to employed. Are they the 26th? Is that the 26 week gap or?
[00:07:37] There's a big portion that are now making up that portion. And the thing that's very interesting about this dynamic is if this has been happening for about the last year and a half, other than right outside the pandemic recovery, that has never occurred before. They've never lagged. Those are the people with high school degrees or less or just some college. They've always been able to transition back faster. You look at the days that go back to the 1970s, that's never happened before. So something is happening in the labor market. I tend to think, yes, I think it's AI.
[00:08:05] And I think what's happening is there's a lot of discussion even within economics and with economists. Is AI going to end up creating more jobs than there are now? Is it going to end up producing less jobs? I tend to think that question right now is not that applicable over the next couple of years. Five years down the road, it may be the case it creates more, maybe the case it creates less. I really don't know. And I don't think a lot of people know. But I do think what we do know is that what AI is doing at the moment is just causing employers to take a pause, see what AI can do.
[00:08:35] Maybe they're just initiating it. Maybe they've gone through a couple rounds using AI, seeing how they're actually getting some tangible benefits and just saying, let's hold off on hiring another FTE right now, especially if we're not so sure what the economy is going to do over the next couple of years. Let's just see what AI can do. But that has meaningful impact for if you're a new grad, you're entering the workforce. It's very difficult to get a job. And that same goes for all those knowledge workers that are impacted by those hiring. You lose a job, it's very hard to come back and get a job.
[00:09:04] And so that dynamic, the low hire, low fire, I think that's with us for the next couple of years easy. And I also think that because of what I talked about first, where investment is going in the economy right now, the breadth of where jobs are, what industries are being, they're seeing the growth is going to remain very narrow. Right now, you're basically just seeing job creation primarily in the healthcare industry. That's pretty much the only thing that's gained jobs over the past couple of years, at least by far the biggest gainer.
[00:09:31] You have seen though some pickup for construction and stuff like that, especially if you live in the area. Yeah. Yeah. And this conversation is, it's an HR conversation, but it's also a dinner table issue. Yeah, absolutely. And I think that neither of us are political gurus, but I think the midterms will help shed some light on what direction our employers can go or should go when it comes to AI policy, hiring policy, international policy.
[00:10:01] Because the volatility between, or the differences between kind of both sides of the aisle. Absolutely. We really don't know what we're stepping into until the dust has settled. The new lawmakers are in DC and the new lawmakers are in our local governments. My question for you would be, we're at HR tech conference.
[00:10:25] There's so many different companies that are announcing new AI and new features. If you were walking the floor, what things do you think would spark your curiosity? Would it be like the hiring products? Would it be the learning and development products? Actually, I just, before this, I just had a great conversation with some people.
[00:10:48] And honestly, it was the, I have been a little more pessimistic about the impact of AI on the labor market. But hearing some more positive growth stories where companies are actually implementing AI, not just to replace people or even just hold counts, head counts level. But to actually say, actually, if we accelerate head counts, we can then also accelerate, they can work in tandem together to create a greater growth environment.
[00:11:15] I'm a little skeptical at the moment that's going to happen in the near term, next couple of years. After that, it's, there's potential there. But for somebody who, like me, who primarily works with financial services and to think about the impact on credit, hearing directly from the HR side of the house and how some companies are actually making these tangible changes to accelerate growth while also moving in a positive way with head counts. Those are the kind of stories I think that make me a little more optimistic about what we're going.
[00:11:43] You were at the HRE strat session, the strategy summit. Could you tell people what you saw there and what stood out? Yeah, it's really interesting. I think just hearing the challenges that are facing employers today, a lot of things that I've been talking to people have been really focused on compliance and which really fits into our wheelhouse. And really what specifically is facing employers today?
[00:12:08] And there's obviously a lot of conversations about AI, but really like the breadth and the amount of change from a regulatory perspective and the challenges that poses for employers, not just with new employees, but with existing employees and really keeping on top of it. This really has been a consistent theme.
[00:12:26] And I think what's really neat is that right now with the conversations we're having, it's not just about how do I keep track of certain things from an HR perspective and from a compliance perspective, not just to identify the change and then do I note it, make the change and then implement, but really how do I make sure that's contextual? How do I make sure that is consistent across platforms? I really need to understand how that works with my technology and within my different vendors and within certain processes. Are those in place within my organization?
[00:12:55] I think that is something that is, it's a broader conversation, more about a framework. And how do I have, how do I keep that at the center and how do I keep compliance at the center? Yeah. Through all that. What kind of advice do you give to help buckle down in this rollercoaster ride of being an HR pro? I think having a trusted partner. If having a partner that you can go to for like, how do I know that the information is right? How do I know where to get the realistic updates, really get guidance, really get, how do I store like all of my information for audit purposes?
[00:13:25] All of that. We've been having those conversations, just having that trusted advisor and having that partner is really important. And I think a lot of people are looking for that, especially when we're talking about AI and we're talking about automation, which has its place. And honestly, it's very great for the industry, great for these products, great for the HR professional, but really also having that consultative person and that consultative entity to help with that as well.
[00:13:47] Do you have any parting thoughts on Experian's role in the HR conversation and what that means for your customers? Yeah. I think it's an exciting time to be in HR, right? And it's an exciting time to be an HR leader. And what I personally, what I love about where Experian sits and where our products sit specifically, our mission really is around serving employers, serving employees.
[00:14:15] So we keep the employee as a person, the center of what we're doing while we're helping the employers help. What's the best way to find Experian Employer Services? Yeah. The best place to get information about our offerings and what we're doing. We have quite a few different blogs and webinars that are available on our website. And then that would be the best place to see and get more information. Cool. All right. As always, get hanging with you. And until next time. Yeah, of course. Of course.


