Why are qualified candidates applying to hundreds of jobs and still struggling to get interviews? This episode examines today’s hiring process from both sides, with recruiter Joe Shanbaum and resume writer Melissa Kelley breaking down what job seekers are experiencing and what employers are actually looking for. The conversation covers resume strategy, confusing job descriptions, skills alignment, Applicant Tracking Systems, AI-assisted applications, ghosting, and common job search myths. You’ll learn why constantly rewriting your resume may not be the answer, how to show the business value behind your experience, when to apply even if you do not meet every requirement, and why technology still cannot replace communication and human judgment in hiring.
Melissa Kelley - linkedin.com/in/mkelleycprw Joe Shanbaum -
linkedin.com/in/joeshanbaum
Key Takeaways
Qualified candidates can still be overlooked even when they have relevant experience.
A resume should build a business case for why an employer should talk to you, not simply list responsibilities.
Achievements and measurable impact are more valuable than a list of job duties.
Job descriptions play a critical role in helping candidates understand whether their skills align with an opportunity.
Candidates should focus resume customization on the most relevant skills instead of completely rewriting their resume for every application.
Applicant Tracking Systems are only as effective as the way employers configure and use them.
AI can help tailor resumes and applications, but its output should never be treated as a finished product.
Candidates need to be able to explain and defend everything AI helps them put on a resume.
Meeting roughly 70% of a job’s requirements may still be enough reason to apply.
Communication, feedback, empathy, and human involvement remain essential to a better hiring experience.
Timestamps
00:00 Why today’s job market feels contradictory
06:04 Why job descriptions matter
09:00 Why resumes stop getting results
17:54 What gets candidates noticed
26:37 How ATS actually affects hiring
34:08 How much should you customize resumes?
42:52 Using AI during the job search
49:55 Balancing AI with your own voice
56:19 Why candidate communication matters
78:55 Keeping the human element in hiring
Keywords
job search
resume writing
Applicant Tracking Systems
AI in hiring
candidate experience
job descriptions
skills-based hiring
resume customization
recruiting
hiring process
Powered by the WRKdefined Podcast Network.
Sponsors
