Episode Description:
They were confident. Charismatic. Had an answer for everything. You loved them. But did you actually learn whether they could do the job?
In this episode of Don't Tell Me About Yourself, Expert Interviewers co-founders Victoria Gates and Lorna Erickson unpack why being great at interviewing doesn't always translate to being great at the job. From the "shiny candidate" effect and the bias toward confident, likable people to rehearsed answers and AI-assisted interview preparation, they explore how hiring managers can mistake a great performance for actual competence.
Lorna shares her own experience of interviewing her way into a job she wasn't qualified to do, and they debate whether candidates should receive interview questions in advance, why nervous candidates are often underestimated, and whether every hiring manager deserves a seat at the interview table. You'll learn how to look past charisma, ask better follow-up questions, and make hiring decisions based on evidence rather than chemistry.
Because the person who makes the best impression isn't always the person who will make the biggest impact.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Being good at interviewing and being good at the job are two different skills. A polished interview performance doesn't automatically predict job performance.
Confident, charismatic candidates can create a strong first impression that distracts interviewers from evaluating their actual qualifications.
Nervousness, introversion, or a less polished communication style shouldn't be mistaken for incompetence, especially when those traits aren't relevant to the job.
Personal chemistry and likability can influence hiring decisions, but enjoying a conversation with someone isn't evidence that they'll succeed in the role.
Rehearsed answers aren't automatically dishonest. Candidates should be encouraged to prepare, and interviewers need to know how to evaluate the substance of their answers.
AI-assisted interview preparation isn't inherently a problem. The bigger question is whether interviewers can distinguish well-organized answers from demonstrated experience.
Sharing interview questions in advance could help candidates demonstrate their best thinking instead of rewarding whoever is best at responding under pressure.
Hypothetical questions make it easier for candidates to describe what they would do without proving they've ever done it.
Follow-up questions are essential for moving beyond impressive stories. Asking for specific examples, individual contributions, and actual results helps uncover real experience.
Hiring managers who consistently rely on gut feelings, personality, or vague feedback may be especially susceptible to the "shiny candidate" effect.
Seniority and subject matter expertise don't automatically qualify someone to interview candidates. Interviewing is a skill that requires training and practice.
Structured interviews and clearly defined job requirements help hiring teams evaluate candidates against the actual work rather than their interview performance.
Hiring teams should be able to explain their decisions using job-related evidence. If the only feedback is "I loved them," there's probably more evaluating to do.
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 – Are they qualified or just good at interviewing?
01:32 – Why hiring managers fall for shiny candidates
04:13 – Lorna's story: Interviewing into the wrong job
06:40 – What our hiring manager survey revealed
08:03 – Confidence, nervousness, and the interview performance gap
10:41 – When chemistry and likability influence hiring decisions
13:15 – Does communication style actually matter for the job?
14:43 – Are rehearsed interview answers a red flag?
17:06 – How hypothetical questions reward impressive answers
18:13 – Follow-up questions that uncover real experience
20:17 – Should candidates use AI to prepare for interviews?
21:22 – Should we give candidates interview questions in advance?
23:07 – How to spot hiring managers who fall for charisma
25:39 – Why interviewers need training, too
26:15 – Should everyone be allowed to interview candidates?
28:31 – The dangers of being the interviewer nobody can impress
29:26 – How to hire for competence instead of performance
31:34 – Holding hiring teams accountable for evidence
KEYWORDS
good at interviewing, candidate interview performance, how to evaluate candidates, hiring manager training, interview bias, confidence bias, charismatic candidates, shiny candidate effect, interview preparation, rehearsed interview answers, AI interview preparation, ChatGPT interview preparation, interview questions in advance, behavioral interview questions, interview follow-up questions, structured interviews, candidate qualifications, interview evaluation, hiring decisions, job performance, hiring manager mistakes, evidence-based hiring, interview skills, candidate assessment
Powered by the WRKdefined Podcast Network.
[00:00:00] Have you ever finished an interview thinking, wow, that person was incredible, and then you realize you actually don't know if they can do the job? They were confident, articulate, had great answers for everything, and of course, even made their weaknesses sound like strengths. We get this question a lot. How do I know if this person is just good at interviewing or if they can actually do my job? So today we're talking about how much interviews reward confidence, chemistry, and presentation.
[00:00:26] Whether rehearsed answers are really a problem and if we should share questions in advance. And we are answering the question, is the candidate great for the job or just great at interviewing? Because being good at interviewing is a skill. So do you have enough skill to know the difference? Let's get into it. Welcome to Don't Tell Me About Yourself, the podcast where old school hiring meets a modern reality check. I'm Lorna Erickson. And I'm Victoria Gates. And we're the co-founders of Expert Interviewers.
[00:00:53] Between the two of us, we've got 40 years of hiring experience. We've studied interviewing techniques. We've trained thousands of people globally to stop making the same mistakes over and over again. And we've got 340,000 people following us online because apparently everyone has a story about a bad interview. You know the ones. The illegal questions, the 45-minute monologues, showing up late with no apology. So every week, we're tackling the biggest subjects in hiring.
[00:01:18] We bring real stories, real data, and real talk about how to make interviews actually work for everyone. Because great hiring isn't luck. It's a practice skill. So whether you hire, apply, or just love a good interview train wreck, the show is for you. I want to dive into the fundamental problem here. And I've heard this numerous times throughout our career. Someone will walk out of an interview and say things like, I loved her. Or they were so polished. He was a great storyteller.
[00:01:48] Like things like that. I understand it because I get those warm, fuzzy vibes too. And that's kind of how I would describe it. But do those statements actually tell us about somebody's ability to perform the job that you're interviewing them for? No. They don't. They're garbage. Yeah. And there's a difference. I think what you're talking about is like the way that they perform in the interview versus where they might show up for the job, their job performance.
[00:02:17] Those are two different things. And, you know, we candidates prepare for that interview performance. And it can feel performative on both sides. For sure. Totally on both sides. And I think to play devil's advocate here, because I kind of have to, I've heard interviewers say before, well, I do want to know about their communication and preparation. I do want to know if they're able to think on their feet and if they come in with an air of confidence. Are they a good storyteller?
[00:02:45] So like I hear that a lot. I just want to walk through whether or not that's actually defensible. Yeah. And how often does it happen that we confuse somebody with being impressive in those ways I just mentioned versus someone who's actually qualified? Yeah. I think, look, just like anything in interviewing for me, I think about how if it's one only and not the other, well, then I think that's where it gets indefensible, right?
[00:03:12] So if you're walking out going, I love that candidate. I just, I know we just clicked. I want to hire them. And you didn't evaluate anything else. I think that's where you go the other way, right? So if that's going to be something, if you're, if you're the type that says, I want to know about their communication, their storytelling and all of that, you also have to do the evaluation of job performance, right? It just, they go hand in hand. So for me, I have a problem when you get caught up.
[00:03:40] We used to, we used to call them shiny candidates. Yes. Yes. In our training, that's what we used to call them. Yeah. And they are like, they're wonderful. Like they come in, they've, you know, and you know, they're not always, even experienced with interviewing. I would say it's just more of the way that they communicate appropriately and all of that. When you have someone shiny, it can get confusing because you can then leave that second part off, right? You, you tend to get dazzled, hypnotized by their, their wonderful shininess.
[00:04:09] And then you forget to dig into their qualifications. We've seen that so many times. We have seen it so many times. And one of the discussion points I wanted to cover here is how we, have we hired someone who interviewed really well and then didn't perform as expected. And I'll take this from like a slightly different angle. Like I was that candidate who interviewed and nailed it and then sucked in the job. So I've actually been that person to come in with my extrovert energy, matching whatever
[00:04:36] energy they have, saying the things that I know that sure I might have, but it's like, I wasn't having to get into specifics about my experience. Instead, they allowed me to speak in generalities. They allowed me to speak in hypotheticals. And I got this job and fast forward three to six months later, it was very clear that I absolutely sucked in it, that I, that I was not doing or able to do the job that they had asked me to do. So I'm not sure if anyone else has that angle, but yeah, certainly did.
[00:05:06] I'm like, wow, I, I got the job. And then I sucked. I'm wondering too, for you, if you felt like the job was a mismatch because of your skills or like culturally, were you just really good at selling yourself? Like, what do you think it was? Yeah. I think I was able to speak passionately about my experience, but then when the, when I got into the job itself, the responsibilities were things that I had never done before. Yeah. Like, did you feel like you were well-evaluated in the interview as the candidate or were you just pumped about getting the job? What do you remember?
[00:05:34] Here's the hard part is that by that point I knew how to be a good interviewer. So when I heard them asking me hypothetical questions, I'm like, sucks to be you. Well, what I would do was, you know, so I definitely leaned in to answering their questions really well. They were just really bad questions. So like, no, no, I wasn't evaluated well. And yes, I did want a different job and I thought that's the job I wanted. So it was all going to work out, but it didn't, it didn't. It was, it was not a good fit at all. Yeah.
[00:06:02] I think it's interesting because some people are just really good at explaining how they would do a job and other people are really good at actually doing it. And those are not the same people. Those are not the same. And I came in like with a strong amount of passion for all the work that I had done before that aligned really well with my last job. You know, so when you see somebody that passion is kind of contagious and they're like, oh, so passionate about a job, such a good storyteller. I'm like, yeah, okay, but it, it, it didn't actually, didn't actually align.
[00:06:30] And do you think, do you think hiring managers or interviewers, do you think that they know that this is a problem? No, I really don't. Most of the time, I don't think they do. What about you? I went back through our hiring manager survey that we did of about 500 people. And actually what's interesting is that the hiring managers we surveyed, they're adjacent to our community. So maybe they know more than most, right? But 41% of them actually said that they wanted help identifying who actually does know how
[00:06:59] to do the job versus who's good at interviewing. So to me, even though they might, they might not consciously know that they know that this is a problem, like it exists and they don't know how to solve it, right? Because almost half of them said that, that they want help with it. That means they know that it exists, which is good. Every single live training or event that I've done in the last year, I've had multiple people come up and ask me this. How do I know if a candidate is just good at interviewing?
[00:07:27] So I know that interviewers are already suspicious. I mean, we talk about this a lot. Like they come in with their guard up and they're like, is this person actually good? Are they tricking me? Like, are they fooling me? And it's like, no, majority of the time there aren't these ill intentions, but it is something that interviewers are worried about. So if you're worried about that, somebody that's listening, you're not alone in this. I think a lot of people are worried about this. Totally.
[00:07:53] And I think one of the biggest reasons that this happens is that confidence, like you said, you were like, I was comfortable speaking about my experience and passion. I think you used the word passionate. Like that is persuasive. So I'm curious. I want to talk a little bit about the spectrum of candidates and some of the things that we've seen. The confident candidate to me, like let's start there. What have you seen in the super confident candidates or maybe what were you like? What were some of the traits? Yeah.
[00:08:20] So the first of which that comes to mind for me is this extrovert energy, you know, because I mean, came in pretty hot and I'm like, I'm going to maintain eye contact with you the entire time. I'm going to tell my stories with passion and excitement and be proud of them. And I always had an answer. Like I was prepared, you know, so I'm like, I'm guessing you're going to ask me about these things. So I came in prepared with answers. And anytime I'm excited or nervous about an interview, the first thing was try to create
[00:08:49] rapport with the person. And I'm like, let's banter. Let's make you like me before the interview even starts. So I think that in my mind, it's a lot of those extrovert vibes. That makes total sense. That's where the extrovert bias comes from. Exactly. And what's interesting is the other side of that I think about like is mainly the opposite of what you've said. So for someone who's more reserved or anxious, they might take their time answering questions. They might ramble or lose their train of thought.
[00:09:15] Their answers are probably not going to be as entertaining and they might not naturally lean towards building rapport. They might be sitting there waiting for the interviewer to take to take the lead. Yeah. I think that's where the biggest discrepancy feels like is that confidence is something that gives the air that you're capable and nervousness gives it like you're not prepared or you're not competent. And those two things are not the same. And they get mistaken for each other all the time.
[00:09:46] They do. And there's so much danger in that because the confident candidate hiring them and they can't do the job, moi, or the reserved nervous candidate who might be an introvert, they might be neurodivergent, and they might be extremely qualified for your job. And you'll never know it because you don't have to write follow-up questions or you just try to confirm your vibes from the first five seconds that you met them.
[00:10:12] And in researching this episode, I saw there was a study that talked about how all those nonverbal cues, appearance, eye contact, professional appearance, all of that impacted interview ratings significantly. So proof of job performance isn't usually on that list, right, of what impacts their ratings. So we talk about wanting objective hiring decisions, but how much of those decisions are based on just how someone's making us feel versus the proof?
[00:10:41] That's exactly right. Yeah. There's the chemistry component, the likability traps that get involved with all that. And there is an important distinction here is that, you know, would I enjoy interviewing this person or hanging out with them is not the same as if this person would be effective at the job. It's what we're doing. Do you remember in our episode about the worst interviews on the internet, we talked about that four-day trip test, right? Yeah. Like, do you want to spend four days with this person? Mm-hmm. That's what we're saying this is.
[00:11:10] Based on this interview, like, I think I'd like working with them. Like, they're cool, right? Why do you think we just instinctively trust confident, likable candidates more? Right. It just makes you feel safe, I guess you can say. And it's like a lot of times interviewers naturally want to hire someone who is like them. Like, it's easy to get sucked into somebody that makes you feel comfortable even as the interviewer, even as the person in the position of power in interviewing.
[00:11:40] You want to be near someone that makes you feel comfortable and makes you feel like they're competent. And by the way, again, I'm just going to devil's advocate here. Like, what's wrong with that? Like, I want to enjoy going to work and I want to enjoy my coworkers. Like, why wouldn't I want to work with someone who I get along with? Like, that seems to be like, to be fair, I think a reasonable thing to want. Yes. Right? It is.
[00:12:08] And, you know, when I think about you and I being business partners, I wouldn't do that if I didn't like you. You know what I mean? Wow. That feels so nice to hear. Thank you so much. Yeah. Breaking news. Victoria and I are also right outside of this. After 15 years of friendship almost and three years of this business. Right. She likes me. I like Victoria. I like Victoria.
[00:12:32] And so before someone points at us and be like, frauds, if we were going to scale and grow our company, we would need to be able to hire people who are capable of doing the job that maybe we don't want to share a hotel room with. So we're so right. You know, I think that what you mentioned is just it's such a natural thing to want to work with somebody and to want to enjoy working with somebody. But as a company scales and grows, you need a whole bunch of different kinds of somebodies
[00:13:01] to make it really work. Totally. And I think that chemistry plays a role in some ways. But again, if that's the only thing you're evaluating, that's where you're running into an issue. Confidence, communication, like those things do matter. Yeah. Specifically, it depends on the role, though. If we were hiring someone to do data analysis, to sit behind a desk and they're not interacting with our clients, they're not interacting with us all that much outside of reporting and stuff. I don't know.
[00:13:27] I'm thinking I don't really care if you're a good storyteller on the phone or in person because you're doing a job that's admin. But if you're someone, if you're representing us, you're trying to sell our services or you're working with our clients. Well, yeah, I need you to be a confident, communicative person. So I also think it's role dependent in some ways. It totally should be role dependent and defining success for each of those things. Because let's say somebody is extremely nervous during the interview, is sweating.
[00:13:55] I've had interviewers give this feedback for this kind of candidate. It was like pulling teeth to get answers out of them. And therefore, I don't think that they're a fit. And I'm like, OK. Just because you have to work a little harder as an interviewer to get answers out of a candidate doesn't mean that they're not qualified. Instead, it's figuring out has their type of communication style ever held them back in jobs similar to the one that you're trying to hire them for? Like you mentioned, if somebody is going to be working with data and Excel spreadsheets
[00:14:23] and primarily by themselves every week, then they don't need to have really extremely strong communication skills. And then also, if it's that big of a concern for you, has it ever negatively impacted their previous work? You can ask interview questions specific to that to identify those things. And if it hasn't, then let's give them a shot. Yeah, that's fair. There's another problem that we've seen quite a bit, which is like what happens when someone's so good at interviewing that we're like questioning? Almost like their answers are too rehearsed, too good.
[00:14:53] We've seen that come up quite a bit. We have seen that come up. And isn't it? I mean, it goes to show everything that I mentioned before of like interviewers, they have this like, I don't know. Sussed. Like I just pictured. Yeah, they're sused. They have like a tin hat on and they're like, I'm going to identify the candidate that's lying to me. And it is funny how often it comes up as they were so prepared that that was a red flag or they had to answer it with every question I asked. And that was a red flag. And so what are your thoughts on that?
[00:15:22] Is it a candidate problem? Is it an interviewer problem? Like, what do you think about that? We actually do tons of skits like this, where you will do like reasons companies reject candidates and it'll be like, they were not prepared enough. They did not know enough about our company. And then the next one will be, they were too prepared. Their answers were too rehearsed. So I think that it's a trap. I think that it is such a double standard. I think we tell them to be prepared and then we get mad at them when they're too prepared.
[00:15:50] So like, what do you want? Because I do not think that a rehearsed answer or a practiced answer automatically equals dishonest answer. Do you? No, I definitely don't. We don't give candidate advice. But when friends ask me, I'm just like, you need to go in with, write down all the challenges you've ever had in your job and what you did about them. Like, that's the advice I give to my friends if they're going to go in. And for them to have those ready examples, you can help to maximize your time when you're
[00:16:20] together. But it's also not a bad thing if a candidate has to sit there for a second and think about things. Yeah. Like if they have a rehearsed answer, they've thought about it. They've taken the time. Like now it's possible. It could mean that they memorize an answer and they don't totally like they just regurgitated something, especially in the age of AI tools. Like it's possible that they are giving you an answer that sounds really good, but doesn't want to answer your question. And they might have learned over time, hey, when I say this story, people have loved it.
[00:16:50] So regardless of whether it fits here, I'm just going to give it. And like, it can mean all those things. Yeah. When you talked about regurgitating an answer. So this reminded me of an example we use a lot in our training where we say, how would you lead a team that's struggling? And let's say they just got done reading the top 10 leadership books that they've had. If the interviewer asks a hypothetical question like that, that does allow the candidate to
[00:17:16] come in with an extremely rehearsed, regurgitated answer that they've never done before. But it sounds really good. So good. Yes. So good. And so that regurgitation is going to happen and it is going to sound good. And it does, it still doesn't mean that the candidate can do the job or can't do the job. It's just a regurgitated answer that sounds really shiny. So we, we do, we do have to make them, them prove it. It's like, totally. That sounds cool.
[00:17:44] But also let's talk about when that's happened before. Yeah. Yeah. There's times where we might even hear a perfect answer. We get the whole understanding of what went down. We get what the candidate did. We get the result. We get all those things that we're looking for, but we still didn't learn anything. That happens often too, where an answer can be perfect. It can sound perfect, but then we're like, hold on, did we actually get what we needed? We see that a lot and we have a go-to to help with that, don't we?
[00:18:12] I think about our, our number one solution for that is those follow-up questions too. They are. Yeah, they are. The true sign of, of what you were just talking about of when you feel like you just got this amazing story from somewhere like, God, that's, that's cool. But if the whole time they were using words like generally, typically, oftentimes, if they're using those, those terms of generality, then we really don't know anything. And so that, that does push us to those follow-up questions that you're going for here.
[00:18:42] Cause those are really important. What are some of our favorites? Follow-up questions? Yeah. The number one that I've used throughout my career is, that's great. Like, tell me what your role was in that. They were talking about their team and they said we, and I just want to know what they did. That's, that's my go-to. What about you? Yeah. That one comes up so often. Like you just said, cause we work with teams all the time. So people use we all the time and it's not bad. It's just how we talk.
[00:19:09] I think that my, my number one go-to, cause we talked about making candidates prove it. And if you're worried that you're getting these regurgitated answers from the last 10 leadership books they read, all you have to do is just, can you walk me through a specific time that added, that you had an unmotivated team? Can you walk me through a specific time that you had somebody who was underperforming?
[00:19:30] And so it is a lot harder for somebody to make up a specific story about one situation or one person on your team. And, and I, I know that too, because early in my training career, I was trying to do a role play for behavioral questions. And I was like, so listen for my answers, everyone. Let's see how we do here. And I was supposed to be coming up with a real example and I, I couldn't do it on the spot.
[00:19:58] I realized that and I'm like, oh crap, I, you know, for training purposes, I need to come up with some real examples that have happened in my career because it's really hard to do that. It's easy to speak in generalities. It's hard to be specific. Well, and we talked about this in our previous episode about outdated interview questions. The follow-up questions oftentimes even matter more than the original interview question you ask. So I think this makes a ton of sense. I do want to get back to something though that we like briefly talked about, which I think a lot of people will be interested to hear our take on is what happens when a candidate
[00:20:26] does use chat GPT or Claude or insert AI tool. Why do we care if they use AI to prepare? Because so many people do and it's like a hot topic on the internet. If they have the right experience and they're using the AI to help them organize or help them format their answers, why does it matter? I agree. Why does it matter? You know, I think it matters to people who are suspicious and scared and not skilled at
[00:20:50] interviewing because it is scary to think that it is the candidate and AI versus them. Yeah. The interviewer. So I can see why people would be intimidated or scared by that. But companies and interviewers are using AI. Having a candidate sit and talk their experience and to chat GPT before an interview and say, help me organize these thoughts or help me understand the motivators for this job, I think can only
[00:21:19] enhance their ability to find the right job for themselves. It's reminding me of a conversation we had when we were in Paris a couple weeks ago. Just casual drop. I just love that for us, by the way. Just casual. We were in Paris. But we were asking attendees about giving candidates questions in advance. And I think a lot of the reasons why people say no is partially because of these AI tools, because they feel like it gives an unfair advantage and then they get rehearsed answers. And so this really all kind of ties in.
[00:21:45] If we want candidates to demonstrate their best thinking, if we do want them to be prepared, and if we do want answers that are applicable to what we're doing, I don't know why we insist on surprising them at this point, right? Right. Yeah. I'm curious. If we gave them the questions, would it be better or worse? I don't know. Yeah. I think for rational people like you and I who know that interviewing is a skill, we're like, give it to them. Just give it to them. It won't make a difference. We're like, yeah, it's going to be great. Exactly.
[00:22:16] But for people that are paranoid, their immediate thought is, well, they're going to cheat. What do you mean? Like, what exactly do you mean? What do you think people think about that? Why do you think that? Like, what trauma did you go through that you think every candidate is out to get you? Right. Because you were a candidate once. Nobody who works in a job that's in a position of being a hiring manager, I'm assuming, has never in their life interviewed or been a candidate before. You had to do something to get the job that you're at. Unless you're an EPO baby, I guess maybe not.
[00:22:45] But you know what I'm saying? Like, come on. How would you feel if the interviewer was sus of you and you did nothing to deserve that? Yeah. Man, maybe I should be making a skit about a candidate who's extremely sus of an interviewer. I mean, I think we gotta. I think we gotta. Sus of an interviewer. How are we not already? You know, I know. All right. Keep an eye out for that, listeners, in the next two to three weeks because it'll be out.
[00:23:12] So I do want to now transition into we've worked with hiring teams and hiring managers who are especially susceptible to a shiny candidate. Yes. So many. How do we know that? What were the traits that these hiring managers showed that they were especially susceptible to charisma? So how do we know that? And then two, should everyone have the opportunity to interview even if they've continued to show that over and over again?
[00:23:42] So let's start with the first one. How do we know if an interviewer is especially susceptible to charisma? The biggest indication that I see is in the way that they talk about either what they're looking for or the way they talk about candidates they've interviewed in the past. Yeah. That's an indication to me that they're going to be susceptible to it because they'll say a lot of things that are fluffy without any substance to it. Like, I just need somebody who's got good vibes. Yeah. I need somebody who's going to bring energy.
[00:24:12] Or they interview someone and they say, wow, I want to have a beer with that person. Instantly, I'm like, beep, beep, beep. This person is susceptible. Yeah. I love that you started off with when you're initially figuring out what they want in this role during that rec and take, perhaps. They are the ones that are like, I'll know it when I see it. I need somebody that has the right vibes, that meets our culture fit. If they can't get below that, the depths of those characteristics, then you know that the
[00:24:41] feedback that they give is going to be equally as shallow. Totally. And so we hear it on the front end and the back end with the feedback piece. And it is funny to me how most companies choose hiring managers. It's based on seniority. It's based on how good they are at their job, which maybe sounds good, but there's a loophole to that. Just because their job doesn't mean that they're going to be a good interviewer. Interviewing the most assumed skill in business.
[00:25:10] We say it every freaking day. Get it tattooed right here. I know. Our forehead is filling up a little bit. We've got to find other body parts to tattoo. Seriously, next conference we should go to, we should literally get tattoos and put them on our forehead. Honestly, I know. That could be good. Okay. We just got to write them all down. Okay. Anyway, moving on. So the ideas never stop here. I know. So you had some extra data from our Question Pro data that you might be able to share about this hiring manager survey.
[00:25:39] There's a couple of things. Of the people that we talked to, 44% of them had no formal interview training. If you're not hearing vague feedback or whatever, I think one indication that someone's going to be susceptible to this is that they've had no formal interview training right there. And it's very black and white. If you're someone who's just relying on gut feeling and you've received no training and you admit to not using structured interviews, to me, it's like, you're the top of my list. Right. Exactly. Yes. And I love these three or four questions here.
[00:26:09] And I want to ask you them specifically because I want to see what your initial thoughts are. Oh, God. Okay. Should interviewers have to demonstrate interviewing competence before being included on a hiring team? Yeah, for sure. A hundred percent. If you're going to be interviewing other people, you need to shadow X amount or put in X amount of hours before you're capable because seniority is not going to do that for you. I do think if you are sitting in on interviews, we'll count your time served.
[00:26:38] But I do think, yes. Yes. You need to demonstrate it. Okay. All right. And is being a subject matter expert enough? Like, this is the best designer that's ever designed anything. Does that mean that they will be a good interviewer? Well, we just talked about it. Is being the best interviewer ever mean you're going to be good at the job? No. So the answer is no. That's not enough. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And this one, oh, this one's like interesting.
[00:27:04] So what if somebody has been a hiring manager at a company for 20 years and they're terrible evaluating candidates? Like, should they still be interviewing? I mean, they've been doing it for a really long time. Yeah. And what is the worst thing ever is to just keep doing the same thing over and over again and expect a different result. That's the definition of insanity. So look, like, I think we can't be afraid to confront even people that have just been doing things for a long time. And I actually think people would be surprised because if I put myself in that manager's
[00:27:33] shoes and I've been doing something unsuccessfully for a long time, I'm probably not happy with it. If I'm bad at interviewing and hiring, I know it. I feel it. My team feels it. And like, while it might be hard to change, I would appreciate somebody actually confronting me on it or pulling me out and saying, hey, no, you can't be doing this. Let's get you. Like, do you want to work on it? Because we can get you right. We can get this going. So I just think they should be stopped and someone should be there to support them.
[00:28:02] I wish this was more prevalent in companies, but unfortunately it's not. When you're sitting around a table and people are discussing a candidate and someone can't explain why they liked the candidate or why they didn't like the candidate, they should be revoking that person's influence on that hiring decision. Be like, yeah, out. We will help you for the next one if you want it. If you don't, you're no longer involved with these hiring decisions. But unfortunately, that doesn't really happen. I feel like they just allow it, you know?
[00:28:30] It's like, let's just let these vibes ride. I'm curious your take on, because we've talked a lot about the person who's really susceptible to the shiny candidates, but what about the opposite? What about the person that just no one impresses them? They're like not excited about anything. I just like, can you speak to your opinion on that? Because that's something that is not as common in my opinion, but it comes up. And they're known as like the hard interviewer and they're just like, nope. And they always wear it like a badge of honor. They do. Like a badge of honor. It's their identity. It is.
[00:28:58] And they're oftentimes, I don't mean to make too many generalizations, but what I do know is that that is just as dangerous as the opposite. Because this kind of person is impulsively rejecting candidates just because of that badge of honor. And they're like, nope, they're not going to make it past me. The gatekeeper. Yeah. Obviously, the interviewer can absolutely be a problem. How do we make sure we're hiring the best candidate instead of just the best performance artist in an interview? Like, how do we do that?
[00:29:27] I think you mentioned it earlier when we were saying at the very, very start, how is somebody describing who they want in this job? So the other tattoo, defining success before even meeting candidates. What does it actually mean to be personable or charismatic? Or they can use those terms to start off with. That's cool. But they need to get a step further into that and define some of those actions so that everyone can agree on what a strong performance actually looks like. Amen, sister.
[00:29:56] I also think about structured interviewing. We've spoken about this in the past, but it's the number one predictor of job performance is when you have a structured interview because it's consistent. You have questions laid out ahead of time. You understand what the competencies are that you're looking for. So structured interviewing, that will get you there. Chef's Kiss.com. Yes. Yeah. And those follow-up questions that you mentioned, it's just an absolute must-have. Nobody is going to have a complete interview just by reading the question.
[00:30:26] Yeah. And we have a lot of questions that are on a piece of paper in front of you or on your computer. So it's follow-up questions that are going to be a big differentiator. And we do have a podcast just about follow-up questions, right? Yeah. Totally. Go listen to it. It's awesome. Go listen to that. I think it's a whole entire—how we did a whole entire episode on it, we probably could have done three. We're obsessed with follow-up questions. I know. Yeah. Yeah. And there's so few follow-up questions that we strongly support. The fact that we filled, you know, a whole episode and then plus however many more if we keep— Yeah. You know, it's like we— Yeah. —fill a lot of time with those because they're so important.
[00:30:56] Yeah. So we covered before and during the interview what you should be doing. And then afterwards, I do think that discussion amongst the group, we talked about like if somebody's giving opinions, it just needs to be brought back to the evidence. Stay away from those biases and assumptions and evaluate the candidate against the job, not against other candidates. So I think you can identify the best person for the job by sticking to the job and the evidence you uncovered.
[00:31:24] I think the other thing is like, hey, I also think they would get along with the team really well. Can come after. Like after. Right? But I think in that discussion, that's critical. I do too. Yeah. And I think during or after the interview, not letting your peers dictate whether someone should be hired or not based off of the shininess or, you know, I don't think they're going to be a fit here. The person was really nervous the whole time. I could visibly see them sweating. Yeah. Who cares? Yeah. Who cares? What's the actual evidence behind?
[00:31:54] The fact that you think that they can't do the job. Like. Right. Prove it. You're asked. You need to ask the candidates to prove it. And then hiring teams need to hold each other accountable. Prove it as well. Prove it. Prove it. Another tattoo. And because we're not. I just want to be clear here. We are not saying that you shouldn't hire the person who interviews well. We are just saying you should be able to explain why that person was qualified outside of the fact that they interviewed well. Yes. And when that combination exists, that's the magic right there. Totally. Yep. Yeah. Yeah.
[00:32:24] Confidence, preparation, chemistry are really great, but none of those things should be a substitute for evidence that their person's going to be great at the job. The person who makes like the best impressions isn't necessarily the person who's going to make the biggest impact in your company over the next however many years. And ultimately, we're hiring someone to do the job, not to just win an interview. So let's think about that, people. All right. Until next time. Happy interviewing.


