Thanks to HRBench for powering this episode. To find out more about the company building the future of people intelligence, reach out to book a demo at hrbench.com/directionallycorrect!
Check out this episode of the #1 people intelligence podcast with special guest, Betsy Summers, Principal Analyst, Future of Work at Forrester!
In this episode Cole Napper talks with Betsy Summers, Principal Analyst for the Future of Work at Forrester, about her recent research report “Time to Take Workforce Planning Seriously” and why so many HR transformations still fail. Betsy explains that while workforce planning has gained real traction inside HR and among vendors, it has moved surprisingly little among business leaders outside the function. Year-over-year surveys show minimal uptake, even as AI makes the need for intentional capacity planning more urgent. Vendors from recruiting, learning, or other adjacent spaces are rushing to rebrand or bolt on workforce-planning modules, yet many lack a clear go-to-market strategy or true understanding of the total addressable market, creating more noise than useful capability.
The conversation ranges widely. Betsy distinguishes writing to think from writing to sell, noting that professional output is shaped by SEO, attention economics, and rhetorical devices she does not naturally favor; she thinks in images and experience more than polished prose. Cole and Betsy explore whether unpaid online writing is mostly selling the reader as the product, contrasting it with paid books or private journaling. They discuss performance management’s deeper tension: finite rewards and recognition cannot match nonlinear discretionary effort, so organizations invent narratives of fairness around zero-sum promotion budgets and stack ranking. Betsy argues that agency-theory systems reward the cheapest path from A to B and remain fundamentally antihuman, while Cole presses on the practical reality that managers must still craft false stories for the people who do not get the scarce promotion.
Betsy shares her unusual path—sailing as an able-bodied seaman, theater stage management, teaching artist and music director in St. Thomas, vendor roles at Cornerstone OnDemand spanning product marketing and sales enablement, and now analyst work—plus the decision she regrets turning down a permanent music-and-theater teaching post out of fear her piano skills were insufficient. She values process over outcome, has worked to detach happiness from external accolades, and sees every community (practitioners, vendors, academics, analysts, podcasters) as convinced it alone is righteous while others are scum. Analysts, she notes, get breadth and permission to ask annoying questions yet rarely see how things actually work inside organizations; practitioners often parent processes they never built. Cole counters that practitioners rarely create the systems they run and that analysts simply aggregate that feedback and treat the pile as insight.
On skills and task intelligence, Betsy says the most transformative step is simply paying intentional attention to workforce data so people can be matched to work they want to do. Tools may get organizations only 75 percent of the way, yet that is still far better than zero. She prefers directional correctness over false precision. In Cole’s Corner she names places she still wants to experience (space, Antarctica, the Amazon, Magnetic North), characters she would choose (Elizabeth Bennet or Aragorn), and the heroine’s journey as a necessary correction to Joseph Campbell. The episode closes with her advice to enjoy the process more than the reward, a reminder that most transformations fail because HR operating models are deeply entangled with the rest of the organization and because scope expands faster than readiness.
If you like this episode, you’d also love exploring prior episodes—visit colenapper.com for the full archive and show links.
Powered by the WRKdefined Podcast Network.
[00:00:00] Hello friends of the podcast and welcome to Directionally Correct, a People Intelligence Podcast with your host Cole Knapper and today's guest Betsy Summers, Principal Analyst for the Future of Work at Forrester. In this episode we will cover the Workforce Planning research Betsy has been publishing at Forrester. You guys at Forrester recently published this Time to Take Workforce Planning Seriously, Seriously.
[00:00:27] What an analyst gets to see across the whole market that practitioners inside a single company never do. A lot of times I don't get to see that as an analyst. I see what people want me to see. But... And why so many HR transformations fail. I would have preferred to learn what three reasons why HR transformations fail. That would have been cool. Now let's get down to business.
[00:00:53] Before we get into it, a quick word about HR Bench, the company powering this podcast. Most HR tech was built for the problems of a decade ago. HR Bench is built for what's next. Analytics, Workforce Planning, Surveys, Data Health, Job Architecture and AI Workforce Transformation unified in one AI native platform. HR Bench innovates faster than anyone in the market and scales to solve real organizational problems.
[00:01:21] The future of people intelligence isn't more dashboards. It's providing solutions for the business in real time. Want to learn more? Book a demo at hrbench.com slash directionally correct. Find out more about the company powering this podcast and building the future of people intelligence. As always, all opinions are our own and thanks for being a listener.
[00:01:43] Well, I have to say this as a preface. Before we get into it today that I think the world of Betsy and I think she's one of the smarter people out there. But coming into this podcast, Betsy told me that we don't disagree enough on the podcast. And so I'm going to do my best to disagree with you today, Betsy, even though I think we agree on most things.
[00:02:08] I would love that. I would love to find some things that I don't know. We just kind of challenge each other on. And usually it's not a disagreement. It's a consideration of a different perspective of like, but how does that vibe with this particular example? Or then how would you reframe it this way or whatever? It's I've just heard a lot of the same examples over and over.
[00:02:36] Like if I had a nickel for any time you or your guests brought up Taylor or Ford or any, you know, insert any other example of the things that thought leaders talk about these days. You're cutting me down deep, you know? You're hitting me right where it hurts, Betsy. That is not my intention.
[00:03:04] Well, let's do it. So one of the one of the primary reasons I invite you on is you guys at Forrester recently published this time to take workforce planning seriously, seriously in the age of A.I. Always be workforce planning. Well, this is you and some of your co, some of your co researchers at Forrester. Great title. Being funny with the titles. Being funny with the titles.
[00:03:34] And, you know, I'm going to come out strong. I looked at the summary. It's got all the right buzzwords. Very thought leader-y, you know? So, so tell me about it. What did you find in your workforce planning report? Well, and I will respond to the digs. I'll say that we have to put in keywords into the summary.
[00:03:58] And also, of course, we have to be very thoughtful about the titles to make sure that it gets attention or the clicks that we want. And of course, for people to know this is for them or for it to be just compelling or controversial enough that they feel compelled to click on it or whatever. I, the writing component of the job to me is separate from the, what ideas do you have or what do you think about this topic?
[00:04:27] I have colleagues who tend to conflate the two. They think that writing is thinking. And yes, while I agree that writing helps to clarify your thought process and to, and to maybe find where you could be more specific. I don't conflate those two things, mostly because I tend to think in imagery and through metaphors and also experience, not always through the words.
[00:04:59] And so anyway, I say all of that to excuse my bad writing in the report that if anyone comes for me and is like, this is poorly written. I say to you, that is not my natural form of expression. Sorry. But I also understand that it is the world's preferred form of expression. So fine. Well, actually, let me dig into this.
[00:05:25] This is something I don't think we've ever spoken about on the podcast before, but I really appreciate what you were saying that, you know, you've got to do some like SEO considerations when you're going into your writing. It has to be controversial, but not too controversial. It has people have to see themselves in the article. It has to have a catchy title, but not cheesy. And, and, and historically speaking, that wasn't always the case. And so I was actually thinking about this this morning, unrelated to you at all.
[00:05:54] Um, but it's funny you're bringing it up, which is, I, I started thinking about, I don't think anyone is writing. You know, you used to like writing to think. Right. And I would say most people nowadays are writing to sell. Yeah. Right. Every, and I was trying to think, are there any mediums in which writing is occurring where it's actually just somebody writing for your own benefit? Right. And there was this whole notion around social media in the past, where if you're not paying for the product, you are the product.
[00:06:23] And, and so if you're reading something online, I've started to feel this way. If you're not paying for what you're reading, you are the product. Like they're, they're, they're, they're selling to you. Right. And so they're using all these different hacks to kind of gain your attention so that you, cause it's more of about the attention economy than it is about the content of what you're writing. And I think many actually, you know, classically trained scientists really struggle with this notion. They say, Oh, they're just hacks. And the reality is I even see it in academia.
[00:06:52] Right. And cause the top academics have found ways of gaming, the academic publishing, and it's not even for you. Cause if you're not paying for it, it's not for you. It's just for them to get tenure or them to get the appropriate attention or them to, you know, get the chair ships or whatever you're going to get at that university. And so I started thinking that maybe books that you buy are the only thing that are actually for you. Right. And I don't know if that's a crazy notion, but I really, I started coming to this conclusion.
[00:07:19] I think that the only good things I read anymore books that I buy, and I don't even read books that much anymore. What do you think about that? Well, when you first asked the question of what writing is for you, I immediately thought of, of journaling, like writing that is from me to me. I'm writing to myself as a self-reflective exercise.
[00:07:37] And I think that that is highly valuable as a, as a way of just reflecting on your life and reframing or working out problems or issues, or even just documenting what happens if you have a really bad memory and you need to go back. What did I do last week and how did I feel about it?
[00:07:56] But to the point of writing something for another individual and the monetization of that or the economy, the economics of that and, and injecting or providing some kind of value through written word. There are professional writers who know what they're doing, or at least have been trained to use rhetorical devices to solicit some kind of reaction from people to get an emotional response from people.
[00:08:24] And then there are people who are trying to communicate their ideas, sometimes not very aware of the rhetorical devices with which to do that very powerfully. And I'm one of those people. I don't consider myself a writer. I have to do it a lot for my job, but I haven't been trained, nor do I have the motivation to become a writer. There are so many people who are much better writers than I.
[00:08:52] And I just put my energy elsewhere, but I do love having ideas. But just because then I don't articulate them well through writing doesn't mean that my ideas are bad. It just means, it means that I haven't studied the way to best communicate them, perhaps. Well, what are some of the, just to kind of take us home, because you did say before this that you love going on tangents and I love a good tangent too. Yeah, buckle up everyone. I actually want to learn about some of the things that you researched in the workforce planning report. Yeah. What are some of the things that you actually found? Yeah.
[00:09:22] So one of the things that was, I think most, most alarming in the, in the workforce planning work, and this was an update to a report that I had originally written between 2022 and 2023 is, is just how little the needle has moved when it comes to workforce planning in the business disciplines.
[00:09:48] So in the HR tech world and within the realm of HR and HR professionals and those that orbit them, workforce planning has become really, really important or a lot more important. And we have, we had a lot of statistics or numbers from various people within the industry saying how many more job descriptions or how many more postings were out there for some kind of workforce planning or people analytics type of work.
[00:10:18] Um, and how many more people attended the strategic workforce planning forums and summits and things like that, that yes, it was becoming a lot more important to HR, but within the, within the other functions within the enterprise and the business, um, it hadn't really gained a lot of traction.
[00:10:36] Part of the reason for my writing was to try to get that ball rolling because I believe that workforce planning, both as a formal discipline and also just as a, a capability, like a, an embedded capability within any function of the business matters a ton, especially now with people thinking about, Oh, what machines can take over human work, et cetera, et cetera.
[00:11:02] But we, we, we found through some like various surveys that there, there was pretty minimal movement, uh, in the number of business leaders outside of HR who were thinking about workforce planning as part of their jobs, um, as a kind of year over year comparison. Like it just hasn't ticked up that, that much. Uh, so I, it was kind of,
[00:11:30] one of those I'm shocked, not surprised kind of situations. Um, and also the like HR tech vendors falling all over themselves to get into this workforce planning space, but coming to it from wherever they had been from their, you know, originating capabilities. Like if they're a recruiting company or a recruiting vendor and they're like, Hey, workforce planning is hot.
[00:11:58] Let's build some kind of talent planning or workforce planning module. As part of their offering. I was like, who's going to buy this? Your TA buyers don't care. This is not part of their job. This might be interesting to them, but you're going to have to create a whole new go-to market strategy. And what is that? How much are you willing to invest to actually show up in those spaces? And what is your TAM for that? Like, do you actually know what your market opportunity will be for that?
[00:12:26] And how much are you willing to invest to, to get that market share? Or, or even worse. They'll just be a recruiting company and they'll just start calling themselves a workforce planning company and do exactly what they were already doing. Yes. There's also a lot of that too. And they're like, no one will notice. No one will notice. It's, it's, I don't, I don't think it is isolated to the HR tech function at all. It is something that happens.
[00:12:57] Marketers come up with fancier words. They want to, speaking of SEO, they want to attach to a certain trend that's going on. And, you know, all roads lead back to Rome. So they try to like take a long walk around the park showing how their solution is, lo and behold, an employee experience solution, or it is a workforce planning solution, or it is an XYZ, whatever the next trend is going to be. So that I do find quite annoying about the vendors.
[00:13:27] Um, but I love being in a space where I can be totally objective about it and not anymore working for a vendor, trying to put a spin on things. Have you done that before? Yes. I'm so surprised you didn't know that because you usually research your, uh, podcast guests very, very thoroughly. Well, I just, I thought of you in a higher regard. I'm sorry for thinking of you. Oh, that I stooped so low to work at a vendor.
[00:13:56] Um, where do you work again? That's how people treat me. So I'm like, I'm. Who's sponsoring this podcast again? What's happening? Yeah, exactly. No, I, I think it's very important to have vendor experience so that you, you know, and you can see what the motivations are. Like from, you know, from the kind of organizational motivation theory of like, why does this organization exist? What are its goals?
[00:14:21] And having experience in that realm helps you triangulate your perspective a lot, a lot better. So I'm very, I'm grateful for my time working at vendors. Most recently I was at Cornerstone on demand. I was leading their competitive intelligence strategy and the, there are multiple, you know, there are so many elements of a competitive intelligence job.
[00:14:45] Uh, and I, without throughout my tenure there, I moved between different departments and that changed what I did in my job and what people saw as, uh, I guess the fulfillment of the job requirements. So when I was in product marketing, it was a lot more about helping product managers understand the landscape of the market and who has what capabilities and functionalities, et cetera.
[00:15:14] And a lot more around the product strategy and helping the rest of the marketing team understand the competitive differentiation. When I was part of the sales enablement team, it meant helping the sellers and helping all the reps understand the landscape and kind of put a spin on various competitive differences. Uh, and so it just kind of where you sit totally colors what you see as your job.
[00:15:38] And I mean, we see that not just with my experience, but like we see that across the enterprise functions overall. It's like where you sit governs what you see is important. Well, I'm curious what you think about this. Um, I don't know. I want to go on a bunch of tangents today. Good. Let's do it. Here's one tangent I have is that one of the things I like doing is I like talking, by the way, I knew you worked at a vendor. One of the things, the tools and tips of being a podcast host is you just play dumb.
[00:16:07] So you can let people answer their own questions. You know, you get the chance to talk about your prior experience. And I don't have to say, remember that time you were at cornerstone on demand. So anyway, this little inside a baseball there. I love that because that, that I'm going to add that question to when I get to finally ask you questions. How has podcasting changed you as a person? Okay, go ahead. Well, I mean, we'll come back to it. Um, but like I, I, I've worn multiple hats now.
[00:16:35] And one of the things that I notice is whatever community I go into, whether it's a practitioner community and academic community, a vendor community, you know, the analyst community, the podcasting community, the authorship community. Everybody thinks that they're like the only true moral people out there. They're doing things the right way. And all the other people are just like scum of the earth. And the reality is, I think it's, it is, it doesn't matter what like discipline you're in.
[00:17:04] It's just, are you like doing the right things? Well, I don't know if, because doing the right things implies some kind of judgment, which leads me back to the, well, leads, leads back to the whole, we are right. You are wrong, or we are the best. You are scum of the earth or whatever. Yeah. I have found that all the unhappiness in my life, I can walk back to judgment, judgment of other people or judgment of myself.
[00:17:29] And so I truly believe that like everyone's doing the best they can given the resources that they have. And everyone deserves to be here. We all have the opportunity to do something great. And every moment is a new opportunity to do something else. And so like, for me, it's the question is what based on who I am or what skills I have and what I like to do, how can I contribute in this moment? And sometimes I have very little to contribute. And sometimes I have a lot to contribute.
[00:17:58] But I tend to, I like the process of contributing. I like the process of learning and, you know, asking questions and getting to know people. I do not care about the outcome that I get from it. Like accolades, awards, recognition.
[00:18:22] I have, I have thankfully done a lot of work on myself to just separate my sense of happiness and fulfillment from the extrinsic motivation or the kind of external rewards that might come from my contributions. Capitalism, of course, like messes all that up. But we can also talk about that because it's tangent day. Yeah. Well, you want to talk about it? Let's talk about it.
[00:18:47] I actually think when we did, when you interviewed me for that workforce planning report, we did go on a tangent like this about like, well, is this all just because of capitalism? Yes. Yes. One of the, one of the, like the last interview questions was because it was related to Taylorism, et cetera. But I was like, like, is there any way that we can get ourselves out of this mess? Because the system in which we're like, which we're in. This is part of it.
[00:19:17] It, it definitely rewards this particular conversation of who is the cheapest labor or what is the shortest line between point A and point B from a productivity and efficiency standpoint, et cetera.
[00:19:32] And it, it is quite anti-human when it, when you get down to it, which is why a lot of vendors have trouble getting into performance management and like untangling and unpicking that because at the root of performance management is this intractable conversation about how rewards and recognition within a capitalist or with, within an organization that operates an agency theory does not actually match what's going to happen.
[00:20:01] And that's what helps people learn and grow and do better work. Thank you for saying that out loud. That's such a good point. I know I'm not supposed to agree with you today. So I'm going to say actually it was a bad point. And I disagree with it. It's opposite day. Oh, good. I don't know. I have a six year old. Cause I, so I'm very familiar with opposite day. Well, okay. Let me, let me reflect on it here for a second. So the main issue, I think you up leveled my issue with performance. Okay.
[00:20:30] Like a, like, like maybe the more of a root cause. Mm hmm. And, and I was thinking of it more in terms of, you have a finite number of rewards and theoretically a finite amount of recognition, even though you can just tell people you love them as many times as you want. But let's say for the sake of argument, there's a finite amount of recognition as well. Yeah. People could give, you know, non-linear amounts of discretionary effort above and beyond what is typical performance. Mm hmm.
[00:20:59] And they can't be rewarded in kind for that. Right. Right. And therefore we have to like create all of these like fake narratives around why, you know, a five point rating scale is actually a great thing. And then we have this force distribution and, and, and like how these things are all like meritocratic and fair. And it's like, I don't think we're, I think we're just talking past each other at a certain point. Yeah.
[00:21:25] And it's because there you're, you have a system in which you're working in that forces you to be in this type of environment and it doesn't have to be that way if it weren't that way. Yes. And I, one of your previous guests had also talked about the fact that, um, the, the discussion around promotion budgets is inherently one of the most political. Mm hmm.
[00:21:49] And then there's a lot of political discussions and conversations that you can have in an organization with employees or, you know, just among, um, leaders trying to make that calibration decision or promotion decision. Um, and. So let's say why the reason why it's a zero sum game. Yes. Yes. And so the person who gets to give that promotion. Mm hmm. Allowing them to do that is usually a formulation of who has the most power in this particular circumstance.
[00:22:17] Not an objective review or evaluation of one person's work versus another, because sometimes they're not commensurate or they're not. You can't, you can't equalize them or, um, you probably have some kind of fancy term for it in people analytics. I'm sure there's some, um, there's some term for it, but it's, I think there are a lot of false narratives, as you said, around performance management.
[00:22:53] Um, you know, what's a, what's. Yeah. Um, you know, what's a, what's. Um, you know, what's a good practice versus the necessary evil practice or the bad practice and kind of meet them where they are and put everything on the table and then help them actually break some things apart. Yeah.
[00:23:08] So for example, like the pay for performance conversation does not necessarily have to include stack ranking or the bell curve or what people tend to.
[00:23:25] They just tend to take what's happening, happening currently, or like the inertia of the status quo and accept it as this is the way things have to be because untangling it from compensation and payroll to another point in another one of your podcast episodes. Like all thing, all roads and at payroll and how people are in the HR tech community. Yeah. Yeah. Well, and capitalism, I mean like how people are paid, right?
[00:23:52] Because we have reduced the value of work to what is it worth in terms of a monetary value. We are because we're ignoring any of the intrinsic motivation that people have for their work, right? They're seeking for meaning and purpose and wanting to contribute to their community. Uh, we've divorced and isolated that since the, what are the stories about the shoes? Who was that? Uh, Aristotle anyway. Yeah.
[00:24:19] I mean, there's like, I think it's Aristotle quote, which is like society grows great when, you know, old men play plant trees in which shade they'll never sit or something like that. Yeah. And there's not a good capitalistic solution for that. No. Right. It's just a different kind of orientation. I do want to come back to the, the, the promotion budget thing that I've got for a second. Okay. So like, let's take even for the sake of argument, you're, you're a typical manager, right?
[00:24:46] Maybe you have 10 people on your team, three by any objective criteria are ready for promotion. They've met all of the criteria that would be ready, but you know, because it's promotion budget time that, uh, you're only going to get one. You're only going to get one. And so you have to be in this uncomfortable position, which is again, one of the reasons why a lot of people don't like being in management. But you got to figure out which of the one of the three you're going to give it to.
[00:25:13] And then you have to craft what, you know, is a false narrative for the other two. Right. Why they're still doing a great job while you really still appreciate them, why it really, you know, is, or it's unfair and the man's out to get you. Um, whatever, whatever direction you want to go as a manager, you can be a weakling or a strong one. Doesn't matter. You still have to craft a false narrative. Why the other two didn't get it. Yeah. Right.
[00:25:40] And again, that's a zero sum system at work. And yes, I would also say that then we need to go back to the, the evaluation criteria for promotion. If the evaluation criteria is not helpful at finding the differentiator for highest performance, then we need to look at those criteria again.
[00:26:01] Um, because if it just comes out and says, everyone is ready for promotion, that's not going to help that it's supposed to be a decision tool for managers. So that would be my, like my first pull, my, my one work stream. Let me actually, let me take issue with that. Okay. Right. And then I'm going to give a work worth planning example. I've used this many times. I gave it in my book as well, which is, you know, what's a better predictor for the future than machine learning demographics.
[00:26:32] Right. So let's say you're a company and, and you, uh, you know, have hired at a steady rate for like 10 years. Right. And then one year you're starting to see some growth on the horizon. So you hire triple the number of college graduates that year than you have historically speaking. I can predict your future.
[00:26:53] I can predict that within 18 to 24 months, those people are going to be expecting promotions and there's not going to be enough of them to go around because your entire promotional infrastructure is built for steady state.
[00:27:35] Okay. So that's a good thing. That's a good thing. That's a good thing. Yeah. Okay. I see that. I mean, I, for what it's worth, I don't think that's really a challenge. I think it's just like a, there's another side we need to look at in that circumstance.
[00:27:54] Then it would be smart for that organization then to think of other kinds of talent mobility opportunities or other kinds of what a career lattice is that might be available for these people who are seeking learning and growth. Sure. To invent a false narrative around, you know, internal mobility that's never going to happen or, you know, it's a, it's a, it's a lattice, not a ladder.
[00:28:20] Or, you know, it's a, you, experiences matter more than money. Yeah. So we'll invent more false narratives. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I, and this is, it's true. This is why I don't like being a manager is I don't like having to lie to people. Yeah.
[00:28:38] What I, and actually this came up, this exact scenario came up in a training that I did around accountability and like accountability conversations.
[00:28:51] Um, I guess for those who don't know at Forrester, I write a lot about, uh, a lot of like HR workforce types of strategies and HR tech, but I also work a lot with our clients on, um, stakeholder management skills, coaching skills, and leadership skills as well.
[00:29:17] So I can spend a day talking to clients where no mention of HR tech or any of these kind of like workforce planning or skills intelligence and workforce intelligence stuff comes out of my mouth. I'm only talking about like influencing or coaching or stakeholder management. And then, this scenario came up with, um, with managers who their company was not doing well.
[00:29:42] And so there was this scenario where these people who are ready for promotion would not get promoted because the company, there was not enough budget. We talked about the value of being honest about that, that the outcome of promotion does not just depend on your performance employee. It also depends because it is an economic relationship. It depends on the organization's readiness and the organization's own performance.
[00:30:12] Um, so that conversation I think should be on the table. And also it allows the manager to then say, look, I want to help you and support you in your career as much as I can. This promotion is not on the table this year. What would you like to do about that? How does it make you feel? How would you like to move forward? How can I help you in your career even without this particular promotion? Are there other skills that you want to learn?
[00:30:42] Are there other experiences you want to have? Do you want to reference? Do you want to look out more broadly at what's available? Like, I'm sorry that we can't get you give you a promotion. And maybe this is why people wouldn't hire me as a manager is because I want to have these honest conversations with people. But yeah, I don't like to lie to people. I feel like that is my responsibility as a human being supersedes my responsibility as an agent to the principal.
[00:31:09] So I don't. Yeah, I that's kind of my stance. Well, let me get even more cynical about this. So what we described is like, you know, you move into management, you're going to have to learn a bunch of false narratives and you just gave all your kind of get out of jail free cards for how to not have those false narratives if you were a manager. So let's say you're you've you've mastered your false narratives you and and I want to get to something in a second.
[00:31:38] Remind me to come back to it about like, who are the progenitors of these things? Okay. But if you really want to get good at it and you want to move up in the world, you need you need to not just master the false narratives. You need to be able to do so while maintaining this for your own personal benefit. So you can't tell people, hey, I'll write you a good reference because then actually might make your team underperform. And if your team underperforms, you're not going to get your next promotion. Right.
[00:32:05] And so the best leader, the quote unquote best leaders are able to get so good at mastering the false narratives and get everybody kind of like put them under a spell that they actually get their own promotion while the person that they just convinced that it's OK, you didn't get your promotion. I totally don't agree. I mean, like I or or maybe I would say I'm not so cynical as to do that.
[00:32:35] But let me get even more cynical then, because I do want to come back to that point, which is, you know, the worst people are not those people. It's not the managers. It's not the people who become executives because they, you know, can even do it in their best interest. It's actually the people who who create the lie. Hmm. Right. Right. Because those are the people that everyone listens to out in the market and I see them parrot back. I was like, why does every leader turn into a Stepford wife? Right. Where they're just parroting back the things that they hear, you know, and you could name them. I'm not going to.
[00:33:05] But you could find the people out there that people ever hear it back everything that they say and realize, oh, these are the worst people because they create the lie. Right. Right. It's not that they're just the one implementing the lie. They create the lie. And that's why people look up to them so much is because, oh, finally, they gave us the right talking points so that we're doing the evil thing. But we actually created the right words that it sounds positive.
[00:33:29] And so I have this rule in HR and in the HR tech community, which is if somebody is explaining something to me and they're using all these words, but I still can't understand it. It's probably a lie. And I don't know what the lie is. I just know lies happening. So if a vendor is explaining all the things that they're doing and it's they're using all this jargon, it's like, wow, it sounds like you're using a lot of words here, but I still don't understand what it is you do. What you're doing doesn't work. Like, I don't know what it is, but it does not work.
[00:33:54] And if you're an internal HR leader and you're talking about how all these things are going to be great for me, but I don't see the tangibility of how great it is, you're just lying to me. And it's like, okay, so this has become a good rule for me in this space is like, if people are just using things to obfuscate what's really happening, that means it's not real.
[00:34:11] Well, it's not real to you. Like it's not for you. It the lie is that what the word, the fancy words that we're saying should should immediately resonate with you. Like that's the lie or like the kind of this, the twist that, that these people who are trying to make you believe. But this happens a lot in change narratives and sometimes it's not malicious.
[00:34:39] It's just because people don't follow the thread all the way through. Um, and so maybe it's like lazy thinking or they don't have enough time or they think they know, but, but really no one has actually sat them down and say, hey, what you're, what you're saying. Um, it makes no sense to the people who need to hear it or who are listening.
[00:34:59] Um, I've talked to a lot of AR professionals as well, who are very good at spinning those webs of words and you're like, what are you saying to me? I don't understand. And you're right. The only logical conclusion is, is then you were trying to hide something or you actually don't understand what's going on. And so either way, I don't want to hear from you. Thank you for coming on the podcast today, Betsy.
[00:35:24] Oh, you're allowing me. I really mean this. I'm being extremely authentic. And I'm not taking vulnerable when I say this. You're allowing me to actually say some of the things that I've thought about for a long time and have been too afraid to say out loud. So thank you for being here. Really? Is that? Yeah. Yes. Really? Yeah. I mean that because like, I'll just say I've been on my own personal journey over the last two years or so, or I've really been struggling about like, there's a lot of rewards in this world to be the progenitor of the lie.
[00:35:53] Right. And you can, you can make a lot of money. You can become white, quite well known. And frankly, a lot of gravity has pulled me in that direction over time. Right. Because there's a lot, there's a lot of positives there. You can be the progenitor of the lie. You will do well in this world. And then there's this other part of me, which is like, am I brave enough to not be? And frankly, I've been weak. And so I, I really value being able to bring on people who I can have a real authentic conversation with.
[00:36:23] So thank you for doing that. Wow. Well, it is, it is absolutely my pleasure. And I'm so glad to be in this space with you. Oh gosh, shut up now. Yeah. And also like to the article that you sent me as well, you might be rich and powerful if you follow that path, but will you truly be happy? And what's your goal? If I just follow Forrester's research, I will be rich and powerful. Forrester aside, because they have their own goals and who knows what they are.
[00:36:53] But I, and that is also part of my, my releasing of, of judgment on my, like off of myself and off of others is that it, I know that if, if my employment with Forrester has to come to an end at any time, I'll be okay. Because I have, I have one, been there before.
[00:37:21] I've been fired and laid off before, and I didn't die then. I'm not going to die now. And I landed myself in great roles following that. I'm very confident in my ability to deal with whatever comes. And so Forrester, she doesn't mean it. She likes her paycheck. She wants to receive the benefits she receives. I do. That's so funny.
[00:37:43] I do love working at Forrester because they give me a very wide latitude for the autonomy that I crave. I get to chase the ideas that I find interesting without a lot of like thumbs on the scales or this kind of like directive micromanagement of ideas. And I really, really appreciate that. I mean, you, you, and I mean this not to just like compliment you.
[00:38:11] You have a really cool role and you do have a lot of, of just agency, I would say. And many people who don't have that level of agency look at that type of role and they're like, wow, you have made it. And so I just want you to know that. I have made it. Wow. Well, and I would be happy for anyone listening to reach out to me and ask me more about it and how I did that for myself.
[00:38:38] And maybe bringing more of that into your own life because it is possible. It's not about replicating whatever happened with me. It's about figuring it out for yourself of what you want. But anyway, we've officially talked about almost nothing we intended to talk about today. Fantastic. So just keep with that vein. Do you want to ask some questions to me? Cause you had a bunch of them before. I did. And I do have many questions. Sorry for the sound leveling. Okay.
[00:39:09] Ah, in one of your previous episodes, you and one of your guests who you have incredible guests on your podcast. You are amazing at sourcing these guests and having great conversations with them. You are so good at that. It is awesome. Where is this going? Are you buttering me up before you like slap me or something? No, what's happening here? No, I'm giving you a compliment. Okay. Um, you want me to actually talk about that?
[00:39:37] Because there's a, again, one of the things I've been trying to do is just like explain kind of like how the sausage gets made sometimes. And cause I actually agree and I'm not taking this as a compliment. I'm like, I'm so awesome. Right. Is because to find people like you, cause I'm going to say you are one of these awesome guests is really difficult. And oftentimes it takes months, if not years. And I mean multiple years to like, I, I just, I like yesterday I was emailing and texting a few friends.
[00:40:07] Like I have a guest upcoming that's early next year that I've been working on for over two years. Just because I think that they're really good. Cool. They're really good. And, and I talked to like, you know, marketing people and other podcasters and like, they'll like send out hyperlinks. Like, yeah, you can join. Like anybody can join my podcast as any time to be a guest. And I'll tell people like I'm booked out six months in advance. Like how are you doing this? And it's because I only care about having good conversations with interesting people and they still don't always work out.
[00:40:37] Right. And I'm extremely intentional about it. And so it is different. It is special and it is unique. And I don't care about people's talking points. And I do want to hear what they really have to think. And that's not common. Hmm. Yeah. I mean, I can see why it's not common or how it's not common, but it, but that still does surprise me because I do believe that. Everyone has something interesting in them.
[00:41:06] Maybe it's just about the courage to say it or the courage to be known about a particular topic. Sure. Oh yeah. I mean, it's, it's, uh, I mean, we used to talk about this all the time back when I had a cohost is like the second that red light turns on of the recording, even the most interesting person can be a deer in headlights. Yeah. Right. It's just, there's something about the little red light coming on. And so that's actually a part of like my sourcing strategy now is like, can I find people who aren't going to turn weird when the red light turns on?
[00:41:37] That's hilarious. I love that. That would be interesting too. Like I would be, I'm interested in the, the signals and like evidence that you use to figure out like who would be best. Like what's your criteria for, for sourcing a good guest. People have asked me this before. I'm pretty cagey about it. I will say, um, I do have like hypotheses that I sort of test sometimes, but most of it comes down to just feel and seeing them in other environments.
[00:42:06] It's like feel in terms of the rapport that I have when I'm talking to them and seeing them having done it somewhere else. Cool. Good. Cause I have someone I want you to interview, but I won't name drop her now because I don't, I don't want to poison the well or anything like that. But I mean, Sandra Loughlin, Loughlin, uh, name dropped you. And that was a good one. And so far it's working out. All right. Going great. This might be the last episode. Sorry guys.
[00:42:37] Like blow it up after this. Yeah. Cole's going to go work on a farm or something like that after. Okay. Um, back to my question. Okay. With this guest. Uh, you were kind of criticizing, you got into a little conversation where you were making fun of first, the gross. The gross mindset model and then servant leadership model. And I was very curious.
[00:43:04] What's the root of either that cynicism or the kind of dismissal of maybe we might say like the pop, the kind of pop psychology models. But I just, I want to understand more. I immediately wanted to ask you a ton of questions to shape out where your areas of concern or cynicism were. Well, let's pick into it. Okay. And that guest was Kelly Monahan.
[00:43:33] Uh, and, and I believe I criticized the growth mindset. She criticized servant leadership. I don't really have that much of a bone to pick with it. I have more of a bone to pick with just leadership in general. Um, like any leadership as an, as a big L thing. Yeah. Yes. Um, but I would say, um, in terms of growth mindset, but there's been a few of these, which is, um, let's call it like my, uh, punk rock upbringing.
[00:43:59] That anytime somebody comes along with like the new solution, I immediately, my inclination is like, yeah, that probably doesn't work. I'm going to tear that thing down. Right. And, and so when, uh, like about 10 years ago, when the whole replication crisis started happening in the social sciences for the first time, a lot of these concepts that I think a lot of people knew were baloney started getting torn down as if they actually were baloney.
[00:44:28] And I promise you, I was as raw, raw, this is the greatest thing ever, um, moment because I'm like, finally, they're getting their comeuppance that they, they, again, if you're not paying for the product, you are the product. They weren't writing to explain. They were writing to sell and they were, they were selling like hotcakes, some of these concepts. And I did not like that. I would say as I've grown up and matured though, and I think I said this on the episode, I kind of don't care anymore.
[00:44:57] Cause I see the game. I didn't recognize the game before I see the game now. And so I just see what they're doing. It doesn't piss me off as much kind of like, Oh, you're just selling. That's it. And I shouldn't be so upset over that. It's like, Oh, you're just trying to be a globally known academic or a globally known consultant or a globally known researcher. And your way of doing this is saying, look at this snake oil that I have. It's the best snake oil. It fixes all of your problems. And it's like, once you've seen one snake oil, you've seen them all.
[00:45:24] And so I, I just kind of, um, I see the game and I, I don't respect the game, but I understand the game. So then would you ever be able to divorce the game from any goodness of the content of what they're saying? Or does that poison everything? No, it doesn't poison everything. What I would say is, and like, I unpacked the growth mindset while I was on there. I said, it's like, it's not one concept.
[00:45:51] It's actually like seven concepts that we know all independently work. When you smash them together, they don't work anymore. Or they're not like one coherent construct. And the reality is like, I'm a big believer in like internal versus external locus of control or goal setting theory. But it's like, um, I can't remember. I think it was like Richard Feynman, physicist, famous physicist talked about like, there is almost nothing in modern mathematics and physics that wasn't discovered by the ancients. Yeah.
[00:46:21] Right. Like people before they even had computers, before they were using their abacus or something. And it's a lot of what we find nowadays is just rediscovering something that was already known like 3000 years ago. Yeah. And I think the same holds true for human nature. If you are finding something that the ancients didn't already discover, um, that's probably not real. And the other thing that is really, again, if you're trying to sell, here's a really successful strategy. I'll give you the strategy that I think every popular person uses.
[00:46:49] They find something that actually the ancients did discover, and then they give it a new catchy name and they give it a new catchy name and they say, I discovered this. And that's a wonderful way of making a career. And I know that sounds cynical, but it's actually a really smart sales stack. And so I think that's what a lot of these people do. And again, it used to really like frustrate me. Now I just kind of understand it. Okay. I mean, okay. Now push back on me. Okay. All right.
[00:47:18] I hear like, I, there, I, I hear a couple of things going on. You, you don't like the, uh, the seller, uh, the, the thought leader seller repackaging what's old to gain status or recognition or reward for their quote. Just give it, give credit what credit is due. Right.
[00:47:44] Um, I would, I would say though, that's at least.
[00:47:50] It could be that the, maybe bundling everything into growth mindset and calling it a thing and Dweck shipping it as all the things combined has more to do with the worry of how readers will be able to understand and implement something versus the veracity of the, the, the model itself.
[00:48:17] That like, it's the concern for the dumb readers that cause thought leaders to rename things or package things up in a certain way. Um, it's a, it's a, it's a recontextualization. Um, at least that's how I would, I would kind of pick out like, what's the goodness in this. Um, I, I agree that trying to capitalize on someone else's discovery is, um, is never great. And we shouldn't be doing that.
[00:48:47] And we should also be referencing what has been known and what has been found. And honestly, that is one of the favorite parts of my job as an analyst to say like, this is not new. This framework is built from this framework, which is synonymous with this framework, which goes back to so-and-so or whatever.
[00:49:09] But, um, but I, I can also see a world where a lot of these pop psych things, there's a lot of goodness in what they're trying to communicate, but the packaging is frustrating because maybe they're trying to play to the lowest common denominator or something like that. Yeah, I would say, um, this is related to what we were saying about like how I invite podcast guests. Yeah.
[00:49:36] Cause I, I always have this, um, this mindset when you think about like marketing is you're choosing, like most people misunderstand the term marketing. They think it means advertising. Advertising is like putting up billboards, writing, you know, copy, whatever it may be. Marketing is literally means creating a market. Market didn't exist. You're creating it. What is the market you want to play in? Right. And I think about this in terms of choosing your market, like choosing your audience, that is your market.
[00:50:06] And so what you're saying is somebody like Carol Dweck is choosing the dumb people to be her audience. That's I'm, I'm, I'm, again, I'm quoting you back to you. It's not what I said. And I say, one of the things that I think about with this podcast is I constrain its growth intentionally. Hmm. Because I want to make sure that we have too complicated conversations that some of the audience tunes out. Hmm. Yeah. Do that intentionally on purpose.
[00:50:36] Okay. And I think that's fine. Um, I would change my word from dumb to uninformed. Uninformed. Okay. Here's another thing that you can do if you're going after the uninformed crowd. You know, another thing that sells polarization. Right. So you create beautiful new idea. A lot of uninformed people start to see like, wow, because they're not familiar with this concept having existed in the past, nor did they care probably.
[00:51:05] They're like, I'm a believer in this new thing. And then they're another group forms and they say, oh, you uninformed. We actually have the righteous in the way of knowing that this isn't the new concept. This is the other concept. And just by the interchange between the uninformed and the informed that creates a polarization, which gives more noise and credence to the idea. And therefore it sells more books and they get more speaking gigs and they do all this kind of stuff. And again, it's just the game. And I see the game now.
[00:51:34] I mean, you still not see the game. Well, and the alternative is to never say anything definitive and always ride the fence. Sure. And I guess that's fine. I mean, I'll tell you this when I write, I'm writing an article right now. I'll give you an example. It's like, I'm citing a lot of economic theory in the article. I could have said to the uninformed crowd, I could have just gone there. I invented all these theories. You don't know this, but they're actually my ideas and I'm the most brilliant person who ever existed.
[00:52:02] But I spent a lot of time going in there and I hyperlink back to obscure esoteric economic theories and researchers from like the 1920s in this article, just because I feel like I'm honest. I'm not just honest. Well, not just honesty. It's not just the academic honesty.
[00:52:20] It's also the kind of standing on the shoulder of giants that what was true back then, or maybe what were the context in which this was particularly true or challenged? And then what's different about where we are now, which is why historiography is so interesting of like the study of looking at how history is told or how history is portrayed over time.
[00:52:48] Like those that kind of meta analysis of the applicability of certain models, I think is more interesting. But again, maybe then I'm an informed person and not not one of the uninformed.
[00:53:04] Although now that's a very inelegant kind of dissection of the market, too, because it relates back to growth mindset, of course, because the statement of I have a growth mindset is in itself a fixed mindset notion. And so it's hilarious to see people wrap themselves in circles around growth mindset stuff.
[00:53:31] And people are if people love to put themselves in boxes, you know, which is why like MBTI and all of these other psychographic and psychometric assessments are so popular. They love to say, like, I'm a this, I'm a that, I'm a Virgo, I'm a Libra, I'm a ENFP or whatever. Give me a good colors based assessment. Am I red or a blue or green or yellow? Yes. And I used to work for one of those. And, you know, it's I.
[00:54:00] What mattered to me was that it helped people understand themselves and the relationships they had with other people in a way that was pro social, it was helpful for their kind of existence and interaction in the world. If it isn't entirely historically accurate or precise enough. I don't I don't know sometimes like I might not take an issue with that. Well, let me let's actually dig into this is a really good one.
[00:54:29] I love it. So let's take colors based assessments. OK, and then contrast them with astrology. Right. So your horoscope. Yeah, yeah. Which, you know, scientists studied many, many times and there's no predictive efficacy of a horoscope. Right. There might be a little predictive efficacy of a colors based assessment depending on how they can have face and construct validity. Sure. It's not great, but it's there's much better options, but it's not the worst thing on Earth.
[00:54:59] Right. I think the issue is where is your line? So like let's let's play out a scenario, which is let's say you use your colors based assessment. It's not very predictive, but you come to a conclusion about yourself. It's actually wrong. Right or wrong. Right or wrong. According to whom?
[00:55:28] Right in terms of like a maybe it helps you overcome a fear or, you know, helps you land a spouse or maybe helps you get ready, prepare for a job or whatever. Like like let's use the growth might like maybe it helps you be more resilient to a problem, some adversity you're facing. Right. Yeah. Like, and it actually helped you. Yeah. Right. Right. And so the thing is, like, where people's lying at is actually the more interesting question, not because I'll hear people like say colors based assessments are the worst thing on Earth.
[00:55:58] I'm like, well, there's worse things. And then I hear people say that horoscopes are terrible. And then I hear people who say horoscopes are great. And and I'm actually inclined to agree with all of them nowadays, because like I care about false negatives the most, which is like good things happening that weren't intended. Like, no, everybody cares about false positives. I love false negatives. Right.
[00:56:21] The person who should have never succeeded who ends up succeeding. I love that. That's an underdog story. I love that. Right. And so if a colors based assessment or a horoscope is sending you into false negative land, as far as I'm concerned, awesome. Yeah. I agree. Dret, something else we agree on. To me, it comes it. I agree with you that the value or my line is in the utility of it, like the efficacy of it.
[00:56:51] And I do care about the pro social efficacy of it. Like I don't just like people kind of sometimes misuse therapy terms and then use it as an excuse to like cut people out of their lives or lead very selfish or egocentric lives.
[00:57:09] And then use it as a coping mechanism for protecting themselves. Like I would hope that any use of these assessments is triangulated against other kinds of self-help or introspection or professional help or whatever. But yeah, any tool that helps people orient themselves in the world, I think is great. I don't care.
[00:57:38] Now, when there is, I'll say though, back to your snake oil comment, right? We talk about like psychics, for example, because that would be a line. That's your line. Psychic. I don't, but I can tell people, I don't know. No, but I mean, it's just where's your line? Yeah. Yeah. Where's your line? If a psychic helps someone, who am I to say they're committing fraud or whatever?
[00:58:05] Well, the courts, I would assume, but yeah, I'm not a court. Like who am I to judge that?
[00:58:11] But I guess my point is, is like, unless you're, so let's go back to assessments here for a second. Like actually legally, you know, valid, scientifically validated, you know, the things that meet all the bars of standards of thresholds that would be necessary to be used in a high efficacy environment, even though it was only work coin flip.
[00:58:37] Right. And that's as good as you've got. Yeah. And we're talking about like what we were talking about with self discovery and self awareness and stuff like that is a pretty low stakes environment. Yeah. So like everything's fine, who cares? But yeah, when you take the same conversation, then put it in a work context, I have big issues with that.
[00:58:54] Like even from a skills intelligence perspective, or like one of my biggest beefs right now with these AI tools that do workforce readiness or skills intelligence mapping people to jobs and role fit and stuff like that is they are completely unaware of the ranges of possibilities that someone might be effective at a particular role.
[00:59:20] Even if they have a totally different skill set or proficiency levels of particular skills and knowledge versus another person.
[00:59:29] And somehow, somehow, somehow relying on like a numerical comparison system that says like this person is a better match for this role versus another person, based on what kind of signals of skills, like what kind of verification methods have you been using for skills?
[00:59:51] Is it self declaration? Is it self declaration? Is it manager feedback is it assessments or any type of like simulated experiences or whatever? I have a really big problem with people now building products that give people this illusion of accuracy and precision. I'm like, what does this number mean?
[01:00:13] I was looking at this vendor's dashboard of like a role fit, like someone's, someone's skill profile representing an actual human being in a person in a role and it said 38% role fit. And I turned to a leader and I would say, okay, if you saw that dashboard, what would you do with that person? And he said, I'd fire him. Get out of here.
[01:00:42] And I was like, is this the world you want to be building towards and how defensible is that number? And you it has a percentage here. What does that mean? What show me what 100% looks like? Is it calibrated effectively? How do you know? Like all of these questions that they could not answer and gave me the word salad thing that you were talking about. That is a huge risk and a problem for me as these AI tools promise this kind of false accuracy and precision. I hate it.
[01:01:12] Well, again, like I try to not attack like straw man and argument, like the weakest formula. I want to track the strongest form and argument. And so the strongest form is like, let's say these AI assessments, they're even better. Like they're, they're really, really good, but they're still not a hundred percent. Let's say they're, they're, they're, they're like, if, if it used to be a coin flip, now they're 75% accurate. Right.
[01:01:39] I still see people in the assessment community where folks will come along and they'll say like, look, I've taken assessments. I hate them. I don't want us to use assessments. I don't think even if it's face valid, even if it's, you know, legally valid, it doesn't matter. I hate them. And I don't think employers should use them. And they go, I can't understand why anybody would ever have that opinion.
[01:02:01] And it's like, well, maybe they took an assessment once they would have been great at the job and they were still failed. That happened to you. Even one time, you'd probably say, you know what? Screw assessments. I don't like assessments anymore. And you would be right to do so.
[01:02:17] So even if your AI assessments are even better than the legacy ones, as long as they're not a hundred percent, which they never will get there because human behavior is just not, I mean, unless we're like literally in the matrix and we're talking about like, you know, like the, the, whatever it was there, the Oracle lady and the main guy, I can't remember his name.
[01:02:34] And they're like, we've got human behavior perfectly. Unless we're in that environment, which we're not, you know, this isn't this, there's always going to be error. And as long as there's error, you have a right to doubt them. Yeah. I, I worry about people over-relying on AI tools for too much and vendors building towards that.
[01:03:02] Um, I used to be really in favor of democratizing workforce insights out to managers who need to make talent decisions. But what, after what I've seen vendors build as a response to that, I wish I had not said that, or at least I, not that I regret, regret my words. I, I wish they could have done better.
[01:03:29] And I hope that they continue to think about the impact that their dashboards have on people who are maybe uninformed. This is the best. Is it? I don't know. I feel like none of these calls are controversial and yet maybe they are. Although that actually is something that has surprised me a lot.
[01:03:53] That being an analyst and working with so many different types of leaders at organizations, I thought most were kind of in the 75 percentile range of maturity on certain capabilities.
[01:04:05] I was surprised. They are not, they are usually much lower. Um, and I, that, that did surprise me in having to really work to meet people where they are and it's not their fault. I'm not criticizing them for it. It is usually, uh, it's usually an outcome of the resources that they're given.
[01:04:26] And, you know, the legacies that they're working towards or against, but that has always surprised me. The power of inertia is strong. It is strong. It might be the most powerful thing out there. Like one of the things I think about, and again, this is coming back to like, kind of like my punk rock mindset from my youth is like, can you build the case for something unsavory? Right.
[01:04:50] So if we, if I'm attacking something that people associate as good, like having validity and reliability and assessments, which a lot, most people agree, like that's a good thing. And so I'm over here attacking it. What if I started like building the case that it's like, Hey, maybe nepotism is good. Or maybe, you know, like referrals, we can talk about recruiting referrals that falls into this bucket. Yeah. Referrals. Like some people think referrals are terrible. Other people. I mean, I mean, I can't tell you how many times we've cited a Dr. John Sullivan article on here where he's talking.
[01:05:19] Some variation of how referrals are awesome. And it's like, and then other people demonize it, you know, it's like, all right, well, whatever. They do work. I don't know. Maybe you should bring back like, I don't know, hereditary royals with manifest destiny or something. I don't know. Define right of Kings. Yeah. Yeah. Like what, like as long as we're attacking things, like let's attack them all. Let's attack leadership. Let's go full circle back to leadership and why I don't like it.
[01:05:47] Like leader leadership implies there's one ruler and a bunch of followers. Right. And so that's, that's really the tyranny of the minority. Right. It's just one person ruling over the majority. And it's like, do you really like that? I mean, we all talk about like, and he's like, and then the flip side is you, you mentioned democratization of insights. He used to be a believer in that. And then you saw the negative externalities of it. And it's like, well, there's, and so you realize that like, I keep getting into this point.
[01:06:12] Like I had a AI go through and analyze the transcripts of a lot of my episodes just for like self-discovery purposes. You're like, what do you, what do you know about me that other people don't know about me? One of the things it says is cold too often, not too often, but this is my own editorialization. I was like, Oh, AI. Okay. Go off. Cold too often talks about the Goldilocks zone, not too hot, not too cold.
[01:06:37] And it's just like, we, we probably need a little bit of democratization of insights, but too much is probably terrible. We probably need, uh, you know, a little bit of efficacy for our assessments, but you know, too much is probably not even possible and not enough as a horoscope. Right. And, and so like a lot of the themes are just what I'm saying. Like we, we probably should recognize that everybody's kind of selling something, but too much of it, it probably isn't in your best interest, but you can still learn something probably from the growth mindset.
[01:07:06] Right. It's like the theme through everything that I'm doing is just like, I'm just moderating as an individual. Moderation. Yeah. Yeah. There is, and I can't remember again, who came up with it. I don't even know if it's an old concept or not, but the, a lot of times people think of balance as a compromise in the middle where you are losing the best of one side and the best of another side and compromising on everything to meet at the middle.
[01:07:33] But there, there's some philosophy of balance where the middle is actually just taking the component parts of each side that you wish to retain and wish to keep. And so it's not really a compromise. You're not losing anything. You're just being very selective about the pieces that you retain.
[01:07:52] And so maybe, maybe that could help you reframe that Goldilocks zone, not as this, the tepid middle area, but retaining some of the extreme heat or the extreme cold that you actually like from both sides. I mean, I'm very tyrannical about my podcast guests, you know, like people who try to invite themselves on all the time. I'm like, Nope. Oh, that's so funny.
[01:08:24] I, I mean, I, I love being part of this club, although I, what is the, what is the Karl Marx quote? I wouldn't want to be a member of any club who would have me as a member or something like that. I felt that way about Phi Beta Kappa when I was inducted into Phi Beta Kappa. And I was like, what is this thing? And my parents are both PhDs and academics and they're like, it's a huge honor. Like it's a really big deal. And I was like, I don't plan to go into academia.
[01:08:53] That's, that's for someone else, not for me. So anyway, I like totally rejected it. And I mean, that is what the young people do. That is what the young people do. Those punk rock young people. Yeah. Just turning over tables. I don't know. You have anything you want to ask me or you want to wrap this thing up? Well, what about Cole's corner? Right.
[01:09:19] Didn't you have questions for me about like, what would I be doing if I weren't doing, if I weren't doing this? Let's do some Cole's corner. Let's do that before we wrap up. I'm trying, I'm trying to give myself permission. So one of the things that I learned about, I knew about myself, but this podcast has made me realize even more is how like black and white a thinker I am about certain things. And so when I have a structure that I need to follow, I follow it religiously. Okay.
[01:09:44] And I've been trying to give myself permission to not follow the structure that I myself created. And I know that sounds paradoxical. It's fine. But I'm really struggling with that, but I've been struggling with it. And so I'm trying to like mix it up. But I would like to, would you like to join me in Cole's corner, Betsy? I would love to. Welcome to Cole's corner. All right. Let's start out with some rapid fire questions.
[01:10:15] If you weren't an industry analyst and previously an employer of Cornerstone on demand, what would you have done with your career? Yeah. Hearing, hearing this back from other guests made me think about and relitigate decisions that I had made in my life where I would have taken a different path. There was a really big moment I had when I was working in St. Thomas as a teaching artist.
[01:10:44] And I was a musical director of a theater where I was invited to stay and work at one of the private schools as a music and theater teacher. And I said, no, not because I didn't want to do it. It was because I was really afraid about being successful. My piano skills were not up to snuff. I had not practiced. I was not a good accompanist. I couldn't like sight read piano very well. And so I was really afraid that I wouldn't have what it takes.
[01:11:14] And so I said no. And I really wanted to say yes. So I would probably, if I had been brave and more true to myself, I would probably be doing something in music. You mentioned to me in prepping for this that you've had five different careers. What were those careers? Yeah. I think I said five just off the dome. I don't even know if that's the number or whatever.
[01:11:40] But after doing a sailing study abroad trip, I stayed as a deckhand with them. And I trained and I sat for my licensure of the able-bodied semen. And I did all the international... I don't know what the acronym stands for. It's STCW. I don't know. It's some kind of like international credentialing for sailing.
[01:12:07] I loved sailing and I loved being on the open ocean. I was doing open ocean sailing. And I love that so much. I was working in theater as a stage manager and a dramaturg. And I love doing that. The teaching artist and music directing down in St. Thomas after college. And then the corporate career, whatever that is. I kind of mush all the corporate together though. Like I've been a marketer.
[01:12:38] And then this industry analyst thing is new for me. And also a parent. Maybe that's a career. Don't skip the manual labor. Oh, yeah. Well, I mean, there are various parts with sailing is definitely all manual labor. Mostly manual labor. We have it. I had a shirt that I recently found in my closet that says, don't lift with your back, lift with your deckhands.
[01:13:03] And it has a bunch of us on the bottom of a boat lifting it up. But in just, yeah, a lot of like building and anyway, a lot of that. I feel like humans are not designed to sit around and stare at computers all day. We're not evolved to do that. We shouldn't expect humans to be good at that for the whole day. We have bodies for a reason.
[01:13:32] And we should be using them. We should be using them. Which leads to my next question. What's the place you've never been to that you most like to go and why? Okay. I have, I couldn't narrow it down to one. I'd love to go to space. I'd love to go to Antarctica. I'd love to go to the Amazon and I'd love to go to magnetic north. I'm sure magnetic north is like not interesting at all. It's just like a place in the ground, but I want to see if I experience anything different.
[01:14:02] Having done like celestial navigation and having to, having to do all the calculations for like the magnetics, the magnetic north. And it's always been very fascinating to me that that kind of moves around the earth. I, I want to go to those places because I want to have different experiences. Like I'm a very experiential, experientially curious person.
[01:14:29] Um, and I think all of those places would be really fascinating. I, I put on my list bottom of the ocean and then I cross it out. Cause I'm, I realized I don't want to go there. It's dark. There's a lot of pressure. I already have problems with my ears and pressure and I have no business being down there. And for a second, until you said the ocean thing, I thought that you might've been in, been into aliens because all the places you described
[01:14:57] are places that people say the aliens come from. Um, but as, uh, as an aside, what do you think happens when the poles flip? Since you're talking about magnetic north, what do you think happens to the earth? And what do you think causes it? Oh gosh, I don't know what, I mean, I don't know what causes it. Cause I'm not like an astrophysicist. I'm sure it has something to do with the magnetic, some things from the sun, whatever
[01:15:25] in gravity, I'm totally out of my depth. Um, but I, I would imagine that a lot of the navigational systems would go down. Um, and that would probably be the riskiest like for flight. And since everything kind of runs on computers these days, and certainly sailors are not trained in celestial navigation anymore.
[01:15:49] I feel like if the poles flip, a lot of people would be like shit out of luck, uh, for getting around the world, um, and cars and all that stuff. But I don't know, like there's probably more catastrophic things that happen. I don't know. Do you know what will happen? Oh, I just assume we're all going to die. But you also mentioned earlier, I think we're all going to die because of capitalism too. I think we're all just going to die.
[01:16:19] We're all just going to die. Yes. We're, and, and we have a heavy hand in it. Like we're such a funny species where we're just like really gunning for the death of each other. It's crazy. Speaking of, if you were a character in any book, TV show or movie, who would you be and why? Yeah. Ah, realistically, I'd probably be someone like an Elizabeth Bennett.
[01:16:46] Um, if I, if I could like really choose to put myself like in some kind of like here, you know, like I'm the hero of this story or whatever. Um, I would probably choose something like an Aragorn or something like that from the Lord of the Rings. That sounds super dope. Um, yeah, that's what I'll say. I like that because it's punk rock too, right?
[01:17:13] The kind of like the strider mentality of the outsider who's really the king or whatever. Everyone aspires to that. I also do, um, in terms of like the hero's journey, uh, you know, Joseph Campbell's conception of the hero's journey, uh, is not built for women and how they experience the world either.
[01:17:37] So if any, if any women are so inclined, the, um, the heroine's journey is a fabulous read and I highly recommend it. Um, does frozen follow the heroine's journey format? Kind of. Yeah. Okay. I mean, the heroine's journey is more about the, uh, a girl and a woman's relationship with the feminine and the masculine.
[01:18:06] And so the frozen story kind of uses that, but very metaphorically, um, and kind of coming back to embrace the power that you have, um, after a period of isolation. Um, but it's, it's quite good. Maureen Murdoch is the author, unless I'm totally mistaken and pulled that name out of somewhere else. But, um, she was one of Joseph Campbell's students and she went to him and was like,
[01:18:34] this does not comport to my experience as a woman, nor my own patients. She's a psychotherapist too. And he was like, oh no, women have already always been part of the hero's journey story. They're the ones that the men are fighting for and looking for. And she was like, excuse me. That's a, you don't realize this, but I've been fighting for you this whole time. And you're just an outsider on my journey. Yeah. Yeah. I'm just the potted plant.
[01:19:01] And so, uh, she wrote her own narrative. Uh, and I like it. That was smart of her to do. Yeah. Good for her. Uh, and thank you for her too, for, you know, going back to the whole writing thing. I'm glad she wrote down her thoughts because I found them very helpful. You want to hear, um, a little kind of like, uh, behind the curtain, kind of interesting aside about that question. Sure. Can I ask, um, I think I saw an article.
[01:19:31] I don't even know if this is true or not. Don't care. It just made me chuckle is, uh, I heard that Mark Zuckerberg asked this question in job interviews to people. Um, if you were a character in any book, TV show or movie, who would you be and why? Yeah. And I thought that that was like the stupidest question to ask in a job interview. And so I incorporated it into my rapid fire questions on the podcast and just to figure it out. Cause I never, that would never ask that in a job interview.
[01:19:58] So I'm like curious, what would people actually say if you answer it? And it's the question that always messes with people. Like for whatever reason, they always struggle with the, if you were a character in any book, TV show or movie. And I realized like, this might be the worst question you could ask at a job interview. Yeah. It's really hard. The, the worst job, the worst, worst question I've ever gotten in a job interview was like, what one thing in your life are you the most proud of?
[01:20:25] Or like, what one thing have you done in your life that you're the most proud of? And at that time I was like 26 and I, I, I don't, I didn't count anything as like hugely important to anyone else, but me. I mean, I could have told any stories from my previous experiences, but I wasn't necessarily like proud of them. Like, you know, hang my flag on anything. It was very, it was a very weird question. Now, if you were to ask me that question, I would say giving birth in a car.
[01:20:54] I think that is the coolest thing that I, that I'm proud of, but also just like being alive and happy. I'm very proud of that. Sometimes it's the little things. And giving birth in a car and manual labor. So we checked all the boxes today. I mean, giving birth in a car is manual labor. So it goes right there. Yeah. It's, it's definitely some kind of labor. I think that was a pun.
[01:21:24] Oh dear. All right. I got one big question for you. Okay. Since we really haven't talked about it at all. Okay. I was intending to during this episode. An analyst gets to see across the entire market. Practitioners only see what's inside, which is actually kind of back to my point from earlier that every community thinks that they're the only one righteous community and everybody else is scum.
[01:21:51] Practitioners only see inside myopically within their own single organization. What's the thing that you get to see as an industry analyst that they don't get to? Hmm. I mean, I, I have sometimes tremendous energy, like envy and admiration for practitioners. Um, and not even envy.
[01:22:19] It's mostly just admiration, uh, because I really care how something works. That's what I care about. And a lot of times I don't get to see that as an analyst. I see what people want me to see, but I do get a very wide breadth. Of, uh, things available in the market. And I have the permission to ask really annoying questions.
[01:22:50] Um, and so it's really just about a scale of what I'm able to see. I don't think I'm more or less special than anyone else. I'm just put in this position to have more visibility across what's possible. Yeah. So I'm going to argue with you on this one. Okay. Um, practitioners are the worst. So I've had tons and tons of practitioners on here.
[01:23:18] So obviously I'm in awe of what many of them do, but I'm going to tell you why they're the worst. Okay. Almost no practitioners have ever built what they are putting forward. Right. So if you run performance management at a company, chances are you didn't build the performance management process. If you are running compensation, if you're running even people analytics nowadays,
[01:23:42] and that's one of the reasons why I thought people analytics was unique and interesting when I started the field is because for one of the rare occurrences that happens as a practitioner, you actually build something for the first time. You understand why you made the decisions. You understand what's happening as a consequence. And even that doesn't really exist anymore because people analytics isn't new anymore. And so practitioners are the worst because they don't actually do anything. They're just parroting off what other people are telling them to do. But doesn't, I mean, you could accuse anyone of that.
[01:24:12] You could accuse analysts of that as well. Well, no, analysts are even worse because then they just talk to a bunch of practitioners and they take all of their feedback, combine it together, and act like if you take a bunch and you pile it together, it actually makes it something that's golden and it's not. So that's why analysts are the worst. Yeah. The podcasters are the worst because they actually think, I mean, I'm sorry. I rant now. I'm here for it.
[01:24:41] I will say the community because I talk to a lot of them because I'm part of the Work Defined Network. There's over a hundred different podcasts in there. So I get to talk to a lot of other podcasters. They're the worst because they actually think that people are listening to the podcast for them. And they're not. They're listening for the guests. Nobody listens to this podcast for me. They listen to the people I bring on. Yeah. I will say, I will say analysts are also the worst in that they really care a lot about credit.
[01:25:11] That has, that has been something I've seen. Not all, of course, there are, just as you said, you carved out your practitioners whom you love. There are wonderful analysts who see themselves as kind of like journalists with a huge, with huge contextual past of like what, what's happening and why is this happening and what's come before, et cetera. But a lot of analysts I run into have such an ego.
[01:25:40] It gets in the way of them having great conversations and contributing value because they, they want to claim credit for things. So like, well, I'm the one who had that idea first. So that sounds like something that I came up with a while ago. And I'm like, nobody cares. Nobody cares. People remember you if you contribute and you're helpful to them. So why don't you try to be helpful instead of complaining and whining about everything? That's my rant.
[01:26:10] I think everybody actually cares about credit, but I do think it's interesting because I think I only have time to cover one article today instead of all three. But I do want to talk about this one just for a second that we were going to cover one about scientific impact. Actually, the more impact that you have as a scientist or a researcher, the less happy you are. And so the more credit that you want and that you get, the less happy you will be. Which is not causal. It's correlational. But I thought that was sort of funny. Yeah.
[01:26:37] With that said, I think let's jump into one. What am I reading? We have the Talent Strategy Group. Previous guest of the podcast, Mark Efron, wrote an article called Three Reasons Why HR Transformations Fail. And he didn't even actually give three reasons why they fail. He gives three reasons that they can succeed. Yeah. So the title's wrong. But one, he says that they need to set the true north for their function.
[01:27:05] So this is under the assumption that a CHRO explains their vision for the future. And then everybody misunderstands that vision and therefore conflict and chaos ensues rather than everybody having their true north. The second is they need to increase the talent quality. So implicit behind this, are you saying that, you know, HR is a bunch of laggards and they don't know what they're doing, but they need to create these three different roles and fill them with talent. A business junkie, the HR disciple and a trusted advisor.
[01:27:34] And then the last one is they need to move faster. So even if they're making bureaucratic, slow decisions, you need to make those bureaucratic decisions more quickly. What did you think about this one, Betsy? I didn't find it incredibly insightful or new to the conversation, which is fine. Not everything has to be new and novel and completely disruptive.
[01:28:10] I don't know that those are maybe the three reasons if I had to choose three that HR transformations fail. But and if it's helpful to someone, I'm glad for it. I do. I would have preferred to learn what three reasons why HR transformations fail. Yeah. That would have been cool.
[01:28:35] Yeah, I I I mostly suspect that HR transformations typically fail. I mean, and there has been a lot of litigation of this and like a lot of a lot of consultancies have come out with their own opinions about why transformations and HR transformations in particular fail.
[01:28:55] But I think most often at least what I see is that people don't realize how integrated all of the HR structural decisions and like the operating model and the org design of HR, how integrated it is into the fabric of the organization itself.
[01:29:17] And that it's really hard to like the way that it's really hard to like untangle that and change people's expectation for how they're going to interact with HR and what HR is going to be doing moving forward. That's different from what they did in the past. I just I find that the scope usually gets way too big really quickly. And that's typically why it fails.
[01:29:44] I mean, especially like what is failure even mean? People think of it as like, I guess, not fitting within the budget target, the timeline and what the scope or something like that. They use those three vectors for figuring out if something failed, like not achieving its objectives. I don't know. I hate talking about transformations. Aww. For a person who likes skills and task intelligence, that's really cute.
[01:30:15] I know, isn't it? Well, I don't like talking about it as like a bounded thing because I feel like they are just... There were... We can always string together change like projects or changes and call them a big transformation. I have a really hard time grappling with change management and change leadership.
[01:30:43] I, the one point I really like about what he, what he said around change readiness. I think he was like, stop waiting to be ready for change and to like have all your ducks in a row before you start. I think that is very true, but you do have to have certain things in place before you start or get permission to continue.
[01:31:08] Well, let me, let's reward the people who are still listening because probably very few of them. Yeah. What I intended to bring you on to talk about today was workforce planning, but also some of your work in the skills and task intelligence space. What do you see in the market related to skills and task intelligence that would actually be transformative? Right? So the transformation wouldn't fail. What do you think would be transformative for businesses?
[01:31:35] What do you know from your vantage point as an analyst of the industry who gets to see it at all the different vendors, all the different practitioners? What's, what's working? What is something that people can take home as a reward for listening this long? What's the role of the work that you can take home as a reward for listening to the people who are working in the world?
[01:31:57] I think the attention to workforce data is, I think, very valuable and important that whether it's structured or unstructured data, having some intentional hypotheses around like, how do we help support people in their work? And do their best work?
[01:32:25] And how can we match people with work that they want to do? Um, I think taking a more intentional approach to that through the use of technology and like task intelligence or skills intelligence is a great starting point. Um, that it's like that saying of if people run your business, why is it that you know so little about them? Um, I think that that making any effort to challenge that is important.
[01:32:57] So that's what I'd say. It's very loose. Um, a lot of the skills, I'd say the, a lot of the skills intelligence tools can get you to your point, like maybe 75% of the way there. And that's still better than zero, um, where you had no accounting of what skills might be required for a particular role and what skills people have or what tasks they might be doing, uh, versus what's required for a role.
[01:33:26] I'd say the most important thing is to, with your podcast, like keep it directional. Oh, um, directionally correct, perhaps directionally correct in that this is a range and this is directional in nature. Um, it is not all precise and it might not all be accurate, but it is better than knowing nothing or better than the information you think you have in your head.
[01:33:58] Well, I'll say this, this has been, this has been cool. Betsy. I appreciate you. I knew you were going to be a good sport today when you reached out beforehand and you were like, you know, I want to argue. All right, great. Let's do it. Yeah. I don't know if we successfully argued. One of my questions was going to be like, do you believe in God? Tell me why or why not? Like, tell me about you. Um, but well, I'll give you the answer. There's a difference. There's a difference between believing and knowing.
[01:34:27] And I'm, I'm unclear if I believe, but I definitely know. Okay. That was a very interesting answer. That is a very interesting answer. I'll leave it at that for today. Great. Um, I will, I will make a plea to folks out there listening. Um, if you really hate this kind of episode, please let me know. And if you really like it, also let me know. Because, uh, I don't get a whole lot of feedback on these things and they're unless a guest comes on and they're really awesome. And they're like, your guest was awesome.
[01:34:57] I'm like, that's great. It doesn't help me at all trying to make this thing better. Um, just get great guests. Okay. Thank you. Um, but you were a great guest today, Betsy. Thank you for, for joining me. Any, um, any final words for wrap up? The only, the only thing that I was hoping to be able to say, I think probably in the context of the scientific article that we looked at is to enjoy the process.
[01:35:27] More than you seek the outcome or the reward and recognition for the outcome. That if you love the process, then that is a reward in itself. Look at that. Some ancient wisdom. It's not the journey or it's not the destination. It's the journey. We got it. We heard from Betsy here with no attribution either. So that's great. General attribution. There you go.
[01:35:52] Uh, so, uh, well, you've been listening to directionally correct to people intelligence podcast, sort of today with your host Cole Knapper and today's guest Betsy Summers. Thanks for joining me, Betsy. Thank you. Thank you.


